Hey folks...If you like this story and the others at Nifty take a moment to send your appreciation to keep this site supportive of the amazing erotic stories all throughout. https://donate.nifty.org
A Little Fun Becomes Something More - Part 5
Brian -- married to Jody, 6 feet tall 190 pounds age 27 muscled jock 8 inches cut
Jody -- 23 5 feet seven 120 pounds 36c 26 34 blonde
Nick -- 23 6 feet 4 inches 230 pounds muscled 9+ inches ex college quarterback
It was a couple of months before our lives started to settle down a little and we could think beyond just the next day. We were approved for the house we wanted and moved in just days before Jody's and my new jobs began. Nick moved in with us at the same time but he had a little more time before his new job started to get things put away and help us do the same.
All three of us were focusing on our new jobs since everything was new and we wanted to get off on the right foot. By the time we were at home in the evening all we wanted to do was try to eat something healthy and go to bed to do it all over again the next day.
We did a lot of making out among the three of us and although we were horny and wanting to play, more often than not we were asleep shortly after getting into bed. We knew this was not going to be forever, but a new place, new jobs and getting our bearings in a new part of town just took most of our time.
By the fall we started to get a little more work/life balance and start doing things we had put off, like hitting the gym, enjoy some of the entertainment and sports available in LA, enjoy our pool and being naked outside again, and sex. The last one was the most fun. We were able to explore with each other again, mostly the three of us, and with our differences in schedules sometimes, play one on one.
More than a few times one of us would come home to find the other two having sex, and none of us were shy about where inside or outside the house we'd play. It was so incredibly hot to walk in on Jody and Nick going at it and I would debate whether it would be hotter to just watch for a little while or strip naked and jump in on the fun. They both were feeling the same way when one of them would catch the other two having sex.
Before we moved in together I had shoved a finger in Nick's ass while he was fucking Jody, not really giving it a lot of thought, just going with the moment. Nick was surprised when I did it but it made him cum inside her like never before. He was so turned on by that feeling of something in his hole. Since then I had done it a bunch more times and he returned the favor and shoved his finger in my ass a few times as well, and it felt just as good to me as it did to him.
I knew that it was not going to be long before Nick and I moved our sexual play into an area neither of us had considered before. The three of us became closer as time went on and I wanted to be inside of Nick and connected with him like I did with Jody. Nick and I didn't talk about it much, but it was pretty obvious he liked me playing with his ass a lot and was more and more vocal about how hot it was. Neither of us had been fucked by a guy before so that was both a little daunting and also something significant for our relationships.
One weekend Jody had to participate in a company event for a new product they were rolling out and was going to be gone from Friday until Saturday evening. The main event was most of Friday and part of Saturday in San Diego so all of her team was spending Friday night there.
Nick and I took off a little early on Friday so we could hit the gym together then hit a sports bar for awhile. We didn't get to hang out often just the two of us and we both loved sports more than Jody so it was a perfect time to let the testosterone flow.
I started getting turned on in the gym as we worked out. Typically, when Nick and I lift we are super focused and don't allow any distractions. But this particular workout we were both only half committed to our goals. I kept checking Nick out and watching his muscles bulge and get bigger as he worked them. He was doing the same to me and while we were trying to be discrete and not interfere with our sets we were both starting to tent out our gym shorts. When he was on the flat bench and I was spotting him. he was looking up at me and my shorts were just loose enough he could see my jock with my balls and cock trying to escape. He quietly told me what he was looking at and how bad he wanted to have my cock in his mouth. That didn't help either of us keep our hard ons at bay.
We both have big cocks when we are not at all turned on and always bulge out our shorts and pants. If we start to get hard it is very obvious and the looks we get from guys and girls in the gym go from somewhat noticeable to can't miss it. We are used to a lot of attention in the gym in particular since we are both very muscular, but by the time we called it quits both of us were getting a lot of "accidental" touches or rubs from other people in the gym. We needed to get out of there before we were both hard and concerned about losing our membership for being inappropriate.
We got to our car after the quickest shower ever (since we both were already half hard) and once inside he and I locked our arms around each other and made out like a couple teenagers. We were both so fucking horny for each other and turned on from our work out and having so many people check us out and wanting one or both of us.
We headed to a sports bar for a burger and beer and watch some baseball. Like most places in LA the place was indoor and outdoor, so we sat outside in the sun and enjoyed the game. Several girls introduced themselves to us and we were polite but none of them were remotely our type. One woman introduced herself because she recognized Nick from our university as the quarterback. She was really beautiful and she was very pleasant and not at all pushy like some of the others had been.
She was a few years older than me, so early 30's and we had a nice chat with her. I told her it was our boys night out as my wife was out of town. She said she was waiting for her husband and that he would enjoy meeting Nick as well. He showed up about 15 minutes later and the four of us watched the game and had a few beers and got to know each other. I got the distinct impression that they were both open minded sexually and would have invited one or both of us to come home with them if given the chance. But Nick and I were not on the prowl that night, so we shared our contact info and said they should come over sometime to our place and hang out by the pool and meet Jody.
By the time we left we were all worked up again thinking about the couple joining us for some hot play as it had been several months since we had played with a couple we met at a nude resort. We got home and once we got inside I grabbed Nick and told him I wanted him now, and that I was planning on having my way with him all night. He got a big smile on his face and said, "Brian, you have been making me horny all fucking day, and I want you to make me yours."
We were half making out half ripping our clothes off as we moved to the bedroom.
I pushed Nick onto the bed on his back and was just about to get on top of him and start to devour his body when I noticed a gift box and note on the nightstand. I looked at Nick and asked him if it was his and he said it wasn't. We both sat up and he picked up the note.
It was from Jody, and it said, "I hope you two have a wonderful time together. I am going to miss you both desperately, but I hope you guys enjoy some `man time' In the box is a little present from me to you both, and I am sure you will put it to good use. I love you both with all my heart and can't wait to see you tomorrow. Love....Jody"
We looked at each other and I opened the box. Nick and I started laughing our asses off. It was a silicone cock sleeve for two. I had not seen one for two cocks before, just one, but after looking at it and seeing both Nick and my big hard cocks throbbing next to each other I knew it would be put to good use before long.
I fell on top of Nick as we were both still laughing and saying how perfect a gift it was. We were making out again and we were playing with each others hard cocks and feeling each others muscles. We could both feel the mood change as we looked at each other very much in love.
I looked at Nick and said, "Jody is the most beautiful woman I have ever known, and I love her with all my heart. You are the most beautiful man I have ever known, and I love you with all my heart too. I want to make love to you Nick. I want to be inside you and fill you. I want to cum inside of you, and I want you to cum inside of me."
We kissed passionately for a moment and Nick looked up at me and said, "Take me Brian. Make me yours!"
I never thought I would fuck a man much less want a man to fuck me. But everything changed with Nick. I was rock hard and I needed to be inside Nick. I kissed and licked Nicks nips as I played with his cock and balls, moving down past his rock hard abs until I had his cock in my mouth. My hands were on his big pecs and shoulders feeling his muscled body all over. I put his balls in my mouth one by one, feeling their size and pleasuring him with my tongue. I worked down to that special place between his balls and his hole until I got where I was going. I stopped for a moment holding his huge muscled legs open and marveled at his rock hard and smooth ass.
His pink hole was amazing and my tongue found its way there. I started to lick and tongue his hole gently and lovingly as he started moaning and telling me how much he loved it. I made my tongue hard and pointed and pushed it inside his perfect hole. Nick said, "Oh fuck yea baby. Oh god that feels good Brian. Tongue fuck me please!"
I did just that. I tongue fucked him and alternated licking around his taint and balls, then shoving my tongue in again making him moan even louder. His cock was just as hard as mine and we were both leaking precum like crazy. Eventually I pulled my tongue out of his hole and got my index finger wet in my mouth and shoved it inside him. Nick jumped from the entry of my finger as it went past the second knuckle inside him.
"Yea Brian, oh fuck yea I love your finger inside me. Open me up for your huge cock. I want you inside me so bad."
When I pulled out my finger in put my tongue in its place for a moment then got two fingers wet with saliva and pushed them inside him. He jumped again and moaned saying FUCK YES, I LOVE IT.
My cock was hard, leaking and ready to be inside Nick. I reached over to the nightstand where we kept lube and put it on my cock and on my fingers as I put them inside Nick. As I was pulling my fingers our and moved closer to Nick so that my big cock was near his hole, I looked at him and said, "You ready baby? I want you so much, I love you Nick, I need to be inside you and have you feel my love for you." He said, "I am ready Brian and I love you too. Make me yours now"
I pushed my mushroom head slowing against his hole allowing it to open until it popped inside. Nick said, "Oh fuck....its so fucking big Brian. Go easy on me but don't stop." I pushed a bit harder and began working my thick 8 inches inside Nick slowly, allowing him to accept my cock. He was telling me how much he loved me and how much he wanted all of me inside him as I slowly worked my cock until all of me was inside the man I loved.
There was a tear running down Nicks face and I was concerned I had hurt him. But he said it hurt at first, but that was not the reason for the tear. That brought a tear to me as well as he said, "I knew it would feel like this Brian. Fuck me babe. Take my ass. Take all of me. Cum inside me and breed me."
No more words were spoken or needed. I began fucking Nick, taking him. Man to man loving deep and full. I slowly increased my thrusting inside him although that just moved the climax of our bonding forward. By the time I was taking my full 8 inches in and out of his hole and pounding his prostate with each pass Nick was begging me to fuck him hard and deep. Asking for my seed and wanting me to own his ass and make him mine forever.
Just before I shot my cum deep inside him his cock started to pulse and thicken and he shot rope after rope of his own seed onto his chest and neck and face. That triggered my own orgamsm and I screamed, "I'm CUMMING INSIDE YOU NICK." I felt like the entirety of the contents of my balls were now inside Nick.
We were both breathing hard and sweaty as I fell onto Nick then rolling on my side next to him, arms around him. Feeling his cum all over his chest and mine beginning to leak from inside him. I kissed him and told him I loved him. He said he loved me too. After a few minutes of holding each other I got up on my side looking at him and said, "That was amazing Nick. Before tonight is over I want you to fuck me too. I want your seed inside me and I want to give myself to you."
He said, "Brian, I can't describe the feeling I have from you making love to me. I know you are going to feel the same way when I make love to you too. My ass is yours and yours only, now and forever. We will have sex with other men I am sure since it is clear that we are both bi, and I'm sure I'll enjoy it with you and Jody. But the only man that will fuck me is you, because for me it is about love, not just sex."
I was overcome with emotion and told Nick I felt exactly the same and wanted his cock inside me more than ever. We laid on the bed together for awhile when my cell phone rang. It was getting late so I assumed it was Jody calling to say hello. I looked at the phone and indeed it was and just before answering it I told Nick to hold off telling Jody about losing our anal virginities until she gets home the next day. He nodded and I answered the phone.
"Hey babe, how's the gig going? Oh, and by the way I have you on speaker phone and your other man is here with me." Nick said, "Hey sexy!"
Jody shared some of her day and that it went very well and that her team killed it with the customers. The senior people at her company were impressed and hinted about giving her more responsibility. Nick and I took turns telling her about our day and that we missed her and couldn't wait to see her the next day when she returned. I told her about meeting the couple at the sports bar and that we should have them over sometime soon.
Jody then said, "Let me guess, you two hotties were getting hit on by plenty of horny women, and more than a few boys on the prowl." We laughed with her and said "perhaps a few" She said, "Wish I could have seen that, I am sure there were plenty of wet panties and tented shorts. Speaking of tented shorts, I got a few propositions myself. Most were obnoxious guys who thought I should be honored for them making a pass at me, which as you guys know, just pisses me off. But a couple of them were nice guys and super hot. I'd definitely put them in the fuckable category. But I was tired from a long day and really all I wanted was to have my own hotties in bed with me."
I reminded her she could play with anyone she wanted, as long as she told Nick and me all about it. Better still if she told us about it while we were all naked I bed together. We all had a laugh and she said she knew.
We chatted a bit longer and we thanked her for the thoughtful gift, and that we might have to break it in soon. I closed with, `Nick and I have our own surprise for you when you get home tomorrow, but right now, there is a smoking host muscle stud naked next to me with a huge cock that needs to be serviced."
Jody told me she hated us both (laughing) and she was already half way to her own orgasm with her free hand working over her wet pussy. We all said we loved one another and couldn't wait to be together again tomorrow.
After we hung up Nick looked at me and told me how much he loved being with us and that he wanted to be inside me. We kissed and I told him I wanted that too.
"I want you to take my ass Nick, make me yours. But go easy babe, your monster cock is so big and I've never been fucked by anyone before. I was worried about hurting you since it was your first time too, but your cock is even longer than mine."
He kissed me again and said he would never hurt me and that he is not in a hurry, he just wants me to feel like he did from having my cum inside him.
He rolled me over onto my back as we began making out and touching each other all over. My hands were on his back and his muscled ass. His hand was pulling my head deeper into our kiss and his other hand reached down for my legs and ass as they came up around his torso.
I am pretty alpha by nature, and taking a position like that, flat on my back, legs up and opening with a huge muscled man on top of me was at the same time scary because of the vulnerability and passivity, and wonderful because it was expressing my trust and love for Nick.
Nick worked his way down to my cock and balls, then, to my pink hole to start helping me to relax and heighten my desire. He had already lubed his fingers so they could do their magic opening me up and hitting my prostate. I was getting so worked up from the physical sensations he was giving me, not only on my ass, but his huge shoulders and arms on my body. I was getting so turned on by him that I was close to shooting several times and I was not even playing with my cock, although more than a few times he did.
I was so overcome with desire and love for Nick I finally said, "Please Nick, I need to feel you inside me. Breed me with your big cock. Take my virginity and fill me up. Make me your man baby."
He came up over me, for the first time I saw him above me, dominant in a way I've never experienced, but not threatening at all. I could feel him positioning his enormous mushroom head at my hole and start to push it toward me, letting my hole slowly open to accommodate it.
As his head entered me he and I both moaned loudly. We were connected as lovers.
I told him I was okay and he should keep putting more of himself inside me. Nick said, "Oh my god Brian, I love feeling my cock you. I love you so much and want to feel fully inside your hot ass."
He kept pushing a bit at a time slowly until about half of his more than 9 inches were inside me. I asked him to stop for a moment and let me get used to him in me. We kissed and I wrapped my arms around him feeling this huge muscled athlete on top of me. With half of his cock inside me I knew that I needed all of it. We were now going to be connected to each other the way we were connected to Jody, giving ourselves to each other. Being open and vulnerable to each other and falling even deeper in love with one another.
I said, "Now Nick! Take me now! I want all of you inside me and want you to cum deep inside me. Complete the connection of the three of us as soulmates and lovers!"
Nick moaned and pushed one last time until his cock was fully inside me, his huge balls pushed up against me. I cried out telling him, "Yes Nick, oh god yes. I love you inside me" With that he began to move his cock out of me, then back in. Taking his time and allowing us both to enjoy every inch of his cock as it moved in me.
We were both so turned on and into the emotion as well as the physical connections there was no way either of us were going to last long before we reached our peak. I had no sense of time as I was lost in the passion we shared. Eventually I told Nick that I was going to cum. As I said that he grunted and I could feel his powerful cum shots fill my insides. My own release began after his and I shot all over our stomachs and pecs as his release continued.
He fell on top of me, us both breathing hard. I could feel his heartbeat against my chest, his cock still inside me and my legs wrapped around his ass. He looked at me and just before he kissed me deeply he said, "I love you."
Eventually he rolled over to my side and we again were together laying next each other silent with our own thoughts for awhile. I was tired from a long day, the workout at the gym and the workout in our bed, but happier than ever knowing I had been blessed with the love of two amazing people who loved me just as much.
We took a shower together and did a lot of making out and touching before falling in bed together. I was holding Nick as I fell asleep but missing Jody. We were not complete without her with us. I couldn't wait to share with Jody that Nick and I made love to each other. I knew she would be so happy for the three of us. It also meant that it was time to consider what kind of relationship the three of us were going to have together.