This is part 3 of my story from earlier this year. It's a true story. I considered just telling the hot sex parts with a few fictional continuity links but I've had a lot of feedback from guys who want to hear exactly what happened. This part may be less exciting. It's the bit where I found out who did what to me while I was blindfolded and tied up. It is an important link to understand how I ended up in the next scenario which I will add tomorrow as part 4. Please continue to email me your thoughts, feedback and your own similar experiences. It's been so hot reading them.
I got dressed and headed downstairs to the kitchen where I saw my mystery guy for the first time. He was making coffee wearing just a pair of tight white Box trunks. He was in his early 40s about 6'2" with short dark wavy hair, stubble, a solid muscular frame with a nice covering of chest hair and big muscular legs.
Our eyes locked and he smiled at me handing me a coffee, gesturing me to sit on a bar stool in the kitchen. `That was impressive' he said with a wink. I didn't really reply but nervously smiled. I love anon sex but am not so much into the chat.
`I just wanted to make sure you're ok and wondered if you wanted to know anything about tonight'
I didn't really. It was all as it was in my head. The anonymity and my own imagination would have me wanking off for days. I glanced down at the small bulge in his underwear which he noticed me do. `You like that?!' I looked away with embarrassment.
`I just can't believe how big your dick becomes' I said feeling stupid for saying it. He seemed embarrassed this time.
`Yeh well it doesn't look much now but it gets quite big. That's why I put average on my profile.'
It was a monster cock. I hadn't seen it. Just felt it. I was hungry for more but I knew it was game over for both of us tonight. `So I thought it was you and two others but I guess there was a fourth?' I asked trying to make polite conversation while drinking my coffee as quick as I could.
Technically yes', he replied softly. My mate Pete comes over from time to time and we know a few bottom guys we fuck around with. Occasionally we strike gold and find someone new online who likes it a bit kinkier.' He smiled cheekily looking at me straight in the eye. `Pete and I cuffed you and tied you to the bed. Pete fucked you first and came all over you while his mate and I licked your nips. Pete thought you were so hot. He couldn't last and came all over you.'
Yeh he seemed to cum a lot, I guessed he had a smallish cock' i added. What is he like?'
I wouldn't say small. It's about 7 inches. Maybe you're used to bigger' he chuckled. We got you pretty poppered up and your hole was opening nicely when we tied your legs back over your head. He's in his 50s. Gym body.
So he lay beside you making out with you and stuff while I got inside you. There was no way I was pulling out your arse feels amazing.'
Your cock is huge. I don't normally do this but it felt so good. Maybe we shouldn't talk about it anymore', I started. Wait so who was the other guy?!'
`Ah so I posted online that we had a sub lad tied up and asked for tops. A guy arrived just as I started to fuck you.'
`Oh yeh that was a surprise for me. His dick felt really long in me.' So what was he like?' I may as well know all of it.
`Actually he arrived a bit later. He was a 25 year old slim black guy with a big long dick - easily 9 inches. We were all done with you when he arrived so was lucky he got here when he did. He just pulled his cock out and fucked you like a train, shot his load in you and was off without saying a word. We were all speechless as he was so hot!'
That makes sense', I replied. I guessed we were finished but with the blindfold and music I didn't know what was happening. So who is `we all'? There must have been someone else because I felt someone cum over me..'
Well yeh', he began sheepishly. There were actually two other guys I found online. While Pete and I were having a go with you the first one took his shorts off and stood watching and wanking. I offered him to take over from me for a bit but he shook his head. You were moaning and it was all so sexy.'
`That's when another guy I found online turned up. He was about 30 in gym gear. He watched from the door. Wanking guy was quite shy and started getting nervous He wanked faster and harder so I put my hand under his arse and he came like a fountain, mostly over you. It was hot. He got dressed quickly and left. I gestured the other guy to come in and join us. He just raised his hand to say no and walked down the stairs and left.'
Oh right' I replied not knowing what to say. It all sounds as hot as I thought it was.' I was disappointed I knew too much about the events of the night. I loved the anonymous apprehension, touching, cocks and cum. I finished my coffee and stood up to go.
The thing is' he was hesitating. The thing is the guy who didn't come in sent a message just now saying sorry. He said he couldn't take part because he knew you too well.'
Adrenaline rushed through me. What the fuck?! `Who was this guy?' I felt panicked and my heart was racing. What did he look like? Show me his picture!'
`I'm sorry but I described him the best I could already. Maybe about 30. Gym clothes. Tallish. He's blocked me online now so I can't see him. I didn't get a better look because I was nuts deep inside you at the time.'
`I've got to go. Thanks for everything.' I left and got in my car to drive home. Everything has changed from horniness to shame. I couldn't think who he could have been. It's a small enough town. Was it a gay guy I knew? Was it someone in the closet meeting guys discreetly? Was it someone who knew I was there and turned up to catch me out? Was it a friend? A work colleague? Family?! Fuck!!!'
Over the next week I had a few messages from `Tony'. I hadn't known his name until now. He asked about meeting again next week. He asked if I was ok as I hadn't replied. I had cautiously scrutinised everyone I had come into contact with to wonder if they were the mystery guy who saw me tied up naked, blindfolded with my hole open and a huge cock deep inside. It was so bad.
As the days went by I started to get turned on by the whole thing a little more than I should. I must be really twisted to get off on being sexually humiliated in front of someone I knew?! After a few drinks one night I sent Tony a message.
`Sorry I've not been in touch. I was a bit freaked about being watched by someone I know. I loved our group session and thanks for organising it so well. I would love more of the same I'm so horny but I can't risk a repeat of local strangers coming who aren't strangers at all! So I guess that is that. Thanks again.'
I had a reply back a few mins later. `Great to hear from you. Been thinking about that night lots. Sorry for what happened. But glad you like our encounter. I'd love to meet you again. You're such a horny lad and your boyish body makes it easier to manipulate you and you look so good tied up. If we were playing away from this area would you trust me to organise something else? I think it's time to take things out of the bedroom and add a few new kinky ideas to the mix. Would be strangers away from here. Think about it and let me know.. T'