This story contains scenes of a sexual nature, but as this is the seventeenth chapter I'm guessing you know that already. Don't read it if it is not lawful to do so or if you're really dull and and get easily offended by such things. Also, please donate to Nifty, it's an awesome site.
Hello lovely readers. I hope this chapter was worth the wait, it continues straight on from chapter 16 so there's gonna be plenty of action, and there's still loads more to come. Thanks as always for any thoughts/comments/feedback, it's all welcome to matterotica@hotmail.co.uk
Benny Takes Control by Matt
Chapter 17
As the six naked boys all headed back into the lounge, they didn't return to the floor where they had been before, instead sitting on the sofa and armchairs. Nick had sat in the middle of the sofa with Josh and Dale either side of him, Warren had taken one of the armchairs while Benny and Corey had squeezed together onto the other one.
"Okay, truth or dare, simple rules, anyone can come up with the question or the dare, you can't have two truths in a row and if you refuse to do a dare you get the forfeit." Benny explained.
"What's the forfeit?" Dale asked. "If it's anything like the last one, Corey might do it voluntarily."
The whole group laughed as Corey raised his arms into the air triumphantly.
"We can decide that if it happens. I get a feeling most of us'll be happy with the dares we get!" Benny said, still chuckling at Dale's comment.
"I suppose I'm first again?" Josh asked, once again faking his reluctance. As Benny nodded, he added, "Let's start with a truth then."
"I've got a good one." Benny said keenly. "Out of the five of us, whose cock do you like sucking the most?"
The entire group stared immediately at Josh. The question had caught him quite by surprise, it was definitely not the sort of thing he had expected to be asked so soon. He thought back over his experiences with all the boys now waiting for his reply. If it was a matter of size, it would have been a close call between Nick and Dale, but Benny had asked which one he had liked. Suddenly his mind flashed back to Friday afternoon, in that country lane, hearing Warren's delighted stuttering as he ran his finger across the boy's hole while he sucked him. Then feeling the boy licking the cum off of his face. His cock twinged as it attempted to stiffen once more.
Hesitantly, taking a quick look round at Dale first, Josh answered quietly. "Warren's."
"Boo-yah." Warren called out happily, pumping one fist in the air as he grabbed his cock with the other.
"Who's next?" Josh asked, quickly wanting to change the subject.
"How about Warren?" Benny suggested, Warren's hand dropping down limply as he realised he had made himself the next target. "And from now on, whoever answers or does the dare picks the next player."
"Fine. Truth too." Warren said, looking round the room for who might come up with a question for him, not sure if he might have been more sensible choosing a dare.
"I know." Corey said with an almost manic smile. "How often do you think about Dale when you're jacking off?"
"Oof, nice one!" Benny called out as he heard the question.
Both Warren and Dale's faces contorted into a look of sheer terror and embarrassment. "I... erm... well... erm..." Warren stuttered.
"Come on." Josh said with a smile. "If I answered, so can you!"
Dale was now staring at his little brother. The fact that the boy hadn't immediately replied 'never' already told him the boy did it, the question now was just how much.
"Maybe...." Warren started, looking quickly at Dale before staring down at the ground. "Maybe... three... or four times... a week!"
Corey and Benny started laughing and cheering at the boy's humiliation, even more-so as they saw Dale fidgeting uncomfortably in his seat, his cock definitely swelling a little.
"Corey's next!" Warren said sharply.
Josh found it quite strange to see Warren so flustered, but the boy's shame, along with the thought of him jacking off thinking about his brother, was a huge turn-on. Again the cock cage felt tighter.
"I'll take a dare." Corey said excitedly, casually playing with his seemingly permanent erection.
"Of course you will." Dale laughed.
Josh threw his hand in the air, like a schoolboy desperate to shout out an answer. "I've got one for him." the boy's eldest brother said excitedly. He dashed out of the room and upstairs into the spare room before running back down. He grabbed the bottle of lube from Benny's box in the corner then held up a butt plug. "Until you're next turn, you have to keep this in... AND you're not allowed to touch your dick."
Corey looked a strange mix of excited and worried. The plug wasn't big, but he hadn't got much experience with things being inserted yet. On top of that, not being allowed to touch himself was going to be difficult. Ever since he first got hard he hadn't been able to keep his hands off of it.
"Whatever." Corey said, sliding out of the seat and onto the floor. He knelt down and pointed his butt up at his big brother. "Stick it in then."
Josh was a little worried that in his eagerness to suggest the idea, he may have gotten Corey into something that was going to hurt him, but if he had managed getting fucked by Dale earlier in the day, the small butt plug should not really present a challenge. He smothered the toy in lubricant then realised he probably needed to do the same to Corey's hole. He felt the eyes of everyone else in the room fixed on him as his fingers began caressing the boy's crack.
Corey moaned gently and reached out to stroke his solid shaft, all three and a half inches of it, but Josh smacked the hand away. "No touching, remember!" Josh finished preparing his little brother and began pushing the toy inside him. Again Corey moaned, getting a little louder as it got wider and wider.
"Fuck!" Corey called out as he felt it pop all the way in, his hole contracting around the narrow part.
"Okay, you can sit back down." Josh said, gently slapping Corey's arse.
The young boy stood up carefully, testing how the toy felt as he moved around. "That's not so bad." Corey said nonchalantly as he sat back next to Benny.
"Oh yeah, I forgot this." Josh said, thrusting his hand between the boy's legs to grab the end of the device. He flicked the small switch and it began buzzing.
"Haa." Corey yelped as the vibrations spread through his insides. "That's... oh, shit... how long.. does it stay in?" he asked, breathing heavily.
"Until your next turn. So I suggest you get things moving quickly." Josh said, jumping back onto the sofa next to Nick.
"Okay. Dale can go next." Corey said quickly.
All eyes turned to the young man who took a deep breath and said, "Truth." He immediately regretted the choice as he remembered the question his little brother had been asked moments before.
Before anyone else had a chance to speak, Benny called out, "Who's the better cock sucker, Josh or Nick?"
Dale looked to Nick sat by his side, then at Josh who leaned forward to look around his little brother. He thought for a moment, thinking back to his brief encounters with the two brothers. Having them both staring at him, along with the rest of the boys, made it almost impossible to think. "I couldn't pick. They're both great." He eventually answered.
"Boo." Warren called out.
"Lame answer. You get to go again for that!" Benny insisted. "And as you can't have two truths in a row, you'll take a dare. Anyone got one?"
"Yeah, I think I do." Josh said, smiling over at Benny.
"You're getting so good at this." Benny replied cheekily. "I'm so proud."
"Hey, I learned from the best." Josh said, winking back at the boy. "Dale, you have to do whatever it is Warren imagined you doing last time he had a wank thinking about you."
Nick actually gasped as he heard his brother's suggestion. Dale and Warren both looked horrified, while Benny and Corey were virtually bouncing for joy, although in Corey's case that may have been a residual effect of the butt plug vibrating inside him.
"Aw, come on." Dale said, sitting forward to look at Josh. "Really?"
Josh grinned at the uncomfortable-looking young man then looked over to Warren. "So what was it Warren? Last time you had a wank over Dale, what was he doing?"
Warren's mouth flapped, the boy clearly attempting to talk but either too shocked or too embarrassed to manage it.
"I think it's a bit too late for to get shy around us. So what was it?" Josh continued to probe.
"He was..." Warren started, disturbed by the fact he seemed unable to stop staring at his brother. He finally tore his gaze away and stared instead at Josh before he finished, "fucking you!"
"Ha!" Corey called out happily. "That one backfired on you, bro."
Josh could understand how Corey could see this particular turn of events as a backfire, but that's most definitely not what it was. Josh found himself smiling as he looked at Dale, who was doing the same. "Fine by me." he said.
"Same here!" Dale added, standing up.
"Just make it a couple of minutes, I don't want anyone cumming until the next game." Benny ordered. Josh and Dale both nodded.
Dale grabbed the bottle of lube from the floor where Josh had discarded it previously and began stroking his rapidly stiffening cock. It felt a little weird to be touching himself like that in front of Warren and the other boys, but the thought of fucking Josh was all he could really think about.
"Lay down on the floor." Josh ordered, taking the lube off of Dale and applying some to his own rear. Dale did as Josh told him and lay flat on his back, holding the shaft of his penis to keep it pointing up. Josh stood over him and then squatted, lowering his arse towards Dale's boner. He felt the tip of it press into his crack and moved slightly to align it with his hole, the head easily sliding inside him.
Both boys gasped with pleasure as it began, their moans growing louder as Josh continued to lower himself until the entirety of Dale's erection was inside him.
"Oh my God." Dale gasped, his eyes closed as he felt Josh push upwards and then slide back down.
As Josh began to get into a steady rhythm, he looked around the room. Three of the observing boys were playing with their cocks, it was only Corey who wasn't. Josh was impressed by his little brother's restraint. The boy was staring at the two young men fucking like it was the most exciting thing he had ever seen. That, along with his already heightened state of arousal and the butt plug vibrating in his arse, would probably have been enough to make most boys give in and start wanking. Corey was clearly made of tougher stuff though.
Josh reached down to caress Dale's chest, running his fingers through the short dark hair and teasing his nipples with his fingertips. His touch must have aroused Dale even further as he began bucking his hips to fuck Josh harder.
"Ah, yeah." Josh called out.
Dale opened his eyes as he heard Josh speak. Seeing the sexy young man riding him, his face a mix of embarrassment, excitement and pure exhilaration, was almost enough to push Dale over the edge. He sat up and kissed Josh, the shock of it slowing fucking down massively, much to Dale's relief.
As the two young men kissed, Josh opened his eyes and looked sideways. He was worried about what this might be doing to Benny. It can't have been easy for the boy to see Josh being so intimate with another man. He was pleased to see, however, that Benny actually seemed to be enjoying the show. Before turning his full attention back to Dale, Josh took a glance at Warren. This had been his idea, his wank fantasy and he was very clearly enjoying seeing it be played out in real life for him.
"Okay, that's long enough." Benny called out, partly to keep the game moving, but also because he could tell that Nick and Warren were as close to cumming as he was. The other boys stopped jerking off as Josh let go of Dale and stood up. Josh reached down and helped Dale to his feet, the two young men holding hands just a few moments longer than was necessary before returning to their seats.
Dale, who remained slightly breathless, turned to the boy next to him and said, "I think Nick needs to have a turn."
"Okay...." Nick said calmly. "I think I'll have... truth, no, dare. Wait, truth. No, dare, I'm gonna stick with a dare."
"Are you sure about that?" Warren asked, teasingly. Nick just blushed a little and nodded.
"So who else has a suggestion?" Benny asked. "I think me and Josh have done our share. And I think little Corey here might be a bit too distracted to come up with anything."
"What?" Corey asked, looking up from his stiffy at the rest of the boys to the sound of laughter.
"So I guess that leaves you and Dale." Benny said, looking at Warren. "What have you got?"
"I know." Dale said, still slightly breathless. "We've seen Corey being fearless outside, and I think most of us know what Josh has done outdoors, so let's see if Nick's as brave as his brothers. You have to go and lay on the front lawn and wank for two minutes."
Nick just shook his head. "No way, I'm not doing it, I'll take the forfeit."
"Well before you agree to it, you should probably hear what it'll be." Benny suggested. "If you refuse to do your dare, we'll just lock you out of the house naked for the rest of the night!"
Nick looked distraught. Although the forfeit sounded much worse, he was still considering it. At least he could find somewhere to hide if he was locked out. But if a stranger walked by while he was wanking, there really isn't any explanation for that.
"Come on guys." Nick pleaded. "Please, give me something else. At least leave stuff like that til it's dark."
Benny and Dale looked at each other and shrugged. "Okay." Benny said. "You can choose which of those dares to do later. But that doesn't get you off the hook now. Let's think of something you can do in the meantime."
Dale grinned and said, "I've got another one." He leaned over and whispered something in Nick's ear.
Nick pulled away and stared at Dale in horror.
"Hey, it's either that or you're going outside!" Dale said sternly.
"What? What is it?" Benny asked, desperate to know what had been suggested.
Nick closed his eyes and rubbed his face before standing up and taking a deep breath. "I hate you!" he whispered to Dale. He turned and walked slowly over to Warren. Dale's little brother looked up at Nick nervously, unsure of what Dale might have ordered.
"Do it." Dale called out.
Nick looked back at him then stared at Warren, a tear forming in his eye. "Warren... I think you're... you're really cute and insanely sexy and when you kissed me before it was... it was totally amazing and I think I really like you." By the end of it, Nick was visibly shaking.
Warren stood up, wrapped his arms around Nick and pulled him into a hug. Nick just stood there, arms frozen by his sides, totally unable to move. "Did Dale dare you to say that?" Warren whispered.
"No." Nick whispered back, almost crying. "He just dared me to tell you how I feel."
Warren pulled away slightly, just enough so that he could look Nick in the eye. He placed a hand on the older boy's cheek, leaned in a kissed him softly on the lips for just a second. "How about tomorrow, you and me do something together."
"You mean... a date?" Nick stuttered, his eyes wide.
"Yeah." Warren smiled warmly.
Nick smiled back at him and said happily. "Yeah. Yeah, sure. That'd be... awesome."
"Awwwwww." Dale and Josh called out from the sofa.
"Young love!" Josh added, smiling even more as he saw Nick turn and give him an angry look.
"Shut up." Nick snapped at him. He ran back to the sofa to hit his brother, but the older boy quickly overpowered him and threw him on the sofa, sitting his chest. "Get off!" Nick called out.
"I will... eventually. For now though, pick who's next." Josh ordered his little brother.
"Me." Corey called out. "Please pick me. Please Nick. Aah." It was very clear how turned on the young boy was. His hands were edging closer and closer to his bright red cock as he arched his back in an attempt to reduce the pressure from the butt plug.
"Benny!" Nick called out, much to Corey's disappointment.
Benny hesitated for a moment. After all the things he had done to the others, he thought that taking a dare might be a little risky. Instead, he said, "I'll take a truth."
The room went silent. Either nobody knew what to ask him, or they were worried that their questions might anger the young master and bring out the bad side of him that, by now, they had all had a glimpse of.
"Anyone?" Benny asked. "Ask me anything. Really, it's okay."
"Get off me." Nick insisted, finally getting out from underneath Josh. As he sat back up in his seat, he called out, "I've got one for you. Out of all the videos you've secretly taken, which one is the hottest?"
Benny smiled, not even having to take a second to think about it. "The first one."
"You and Josh?" Nick clarified.
"Yeah, that's the one. So fucking hot." Benny said happily.
"Gotta agree with you there." Nick smiled back at him.
Josh turned to his brother in shock. "You've seen it?" he demanded.
"Yeah, Benny showed it to me at the weekend." Nick explained. He blushed a little as he remembered his own reaction to seeing it at the time.
"Fuck." Josh said, closing his eyes and flopping back in his seat. He had done a lot of similar stuff to that video with Nick, but to know that his little brother had seen his first time, seen him so completely under Benny's control, it was pretty humiliating. Nick and Benny both just smiled at his reaction.
"Okay, who's next then?" Benny said. Corey's hand had been holding onto his for the last few minutes, squeezing gently as waves of pleasure passed through him. The boy's desperation was so arousing. He looked round at the younger boy, reached up and played with his nipple then slid his hand down, stopping just short of the boy's little cock. "I think it should be...."
Corey whimpered as Benny paused, waiting to hear his name.
"Warren." Benny called out.
"Nooo." Corey whined in frustration.
Warren smiled a little at Corey's situation, then sat forward in his seat and said, "Well I had truth last time, so I suppose I gotta have a dare."
"Sixty-nine with Dale." Corey called out before anyone else could make a suggestion. It seemed that the boy had decided that if he had to suffer, he was going to try and make everyone else suffer too.
"You heard the boy." Benny said, looking from Dale to Warren and back again. "Down on the floor, big boy."
Dale couldn't even look at his little brother as he got down onto the floor. He lay in the same position he had been in minutes before with Josh. Warren walked over silently to join him, kneeling just behind his big brother's head. They had clearly both decided to just get it over with as quickly as possible to try and reduce their embarrassment as Warren quickly leaned over across dale's body and took the older boy's cock between his lips. As he did it, Dale reached up and pulled Warren's cock into his mouth.
The two boys lay there, sucking gently on each other's cocks, both being careful not to make the other one cum. Apart from not wanting to disobey Benny's earlier order, it was already weird enough to be sucking on each other's dicks, a mouthful of their own brother's spunk just felt a bit too strange. Dale couldn't stop his hands from exploring Warren's body though as they reached up to stroke his chest and firm stomach, before sliding round to his back, then down to his pale arse cheeks. His fingers were just entering the boy's crack when their activity was stopped.
"That's long enough." Benny called out.
Warren quickly jumped up, his cock even harder than when he started. He couldn't help wondering how far Dale's wandering hands were going to go if Benny hadn't stopped them.
"That looked so hot." Nick whispered to Dale as he sat back next to him.
"Who's next?" Corey demanded.
"I think it should be Benny again." Warren said, smiling as an idea occurred to him. "And as you've got to have a dare this time, I've got a great one. Benny, I dare you... to show us all the video of you and Josh!"
"What?" Josh called out. "No!" The idea terrified Josh. The thought of Corey seeing it too was just too much for him to accept. On top of that, Dale and Warren would see it too? Warren wasn't so bad, he had already witnessed first hand the things Benny could order him to do when they had gone for the drive after swimming. Dale knew the basics about what had happened between him and Benny on that first night, but for the guy he liked to actually see him at the boy's mercy was just too embarrassing.
"Sorry stud, it's not your dare to refuse." Benny said as he got up out of his seat. "I'll be back in a moment." Benny left the lounge and headed upstairs to get the video.
"I don't know what you're so worried about." Nick insisted, looking to his distressed brother beside him. "It's nothing to be ashamed of, seriously, it's probably the sexiest thing I've ever seen."
"No." Corey whimpered again.
The others all laughed at the youngest boy's expression as he thought about watching something so exciting while already so aroused.
"Come on Warren, change the dare to something else, don't watch the video." Josh pleaded.
"No way," Warren said back. "I wanna see it."
"Me too." Dale added. Josh turned round to stare at him, blushing a little.
Josh just sighed, giving in to the inevitable. On the bright side, at least he wouldn't be the only one suffering for a change. He may not have been able to get hard, but that may have been a blessing. Corey was clearly ready to cum at a moment's notice, but Nick, Dale and Warren weren't far behind him. Seeing them so turned on, but not being allowed to cum was quite satisfying and if the video was as good as Nick said it was, then by the end of it they were all going to be pretty desperate for release.
"Okay, I've got it." Benny called out as he came back into the room. He plugged a memory stick into the TV then grabbed the remote, sitting down in front of the sofa between Nick and Dale. "Now, no touching yourselves, I don't want anyone going off before I say so." He pressed play and his bedroom appeared on screen.
"I can't watch this." Josh said. He stood up and headed out into the hallway, taking a seat on the stairs. As he sat there, he could very faintly hear the sounds of the video, but he did his best to block it out.
A couple of minutes later, Josh looked round as Dale emerged from the lounge. Without saying a word, the naked young man came and sat next to Josh.
"You're missing the show." Josh said unhappily.
"I know." was all Dale said back.
Josh paused for a moment, unsure of what was going on. "Why?" he eventually asked.
"You clearly didn't want me to see it, and as hot as I'd probably find it, I couldn't do something that I knew would upset you." Dale explained.
Josh just stared into Dale's beautiful hazel eyes, choked up a little at the gesture. "I... I don't... erm..." Josh stuttered as he thought about it. He took a breath and tried again. "Thank you."
"You're welcome." Dale said back happily, his hand stroking Josh's leg. "Besides, I'm so fucking horny right now that I don't think I'd have been able to watch it without jacking off."
Josh grinned. "Okay, just give me a second to picture that!"
"What, you mean this?" Dale asked as he stood up and turned to face Josh. His cock had softened slightly, but soon shot back up to full length as his fingers wrapped around the shaft. He stood there, slowly stroking his cock as Josh stared up and down his entire body.
"Fuck, what I wouldn't give to be doing that right now!" Josh said weakly, grabbing his caged cock.
"Sorry, I'll stop." Dale said as he saw the frustration on Josh's face. He sat back down next to him. "So... Warren and Nick."
"Yeah, that was really sweet what you did in there." Josh said, thinking of the dare Dale had given his younger brother.
"I don't think Nick saw it that way." Dale chuckled.
"Err, no. He looked just about ready to punch you. But hey, it paid off, our little brothers are going on a date." Josh said, sounding almost proud.
"Maybe... we should make it a double date." Dale said hesitantly.
"Wait, did you just ask me out on a date?" Josh asked as he thought about the suggestion.
Dale just shrugged, looking a little like he was regretting proposing the idea. "Forget it, was just a stupid thought." He stared down at the ground, his face reddening.
"Dale." Josh said. He leaned over and rested his chin on Dale's shoulder, his lips barely an inch away from his ear as he whispered, "I'd love to."
Dale turned his head to face Josh, his lips immediately pressing against the other boy's. Their hands began caressing each other, laying back on the stairs as they made out. They remained there, kissing and holding each other until Benny finally came out to find them.
"Hey, video's finished." Benny said, interrupting them from their kissing.
"Yeah, we're coming." Josh called out.
"Not yet you're not." Benny said with a wink.
As Josh and Dale walked back into the room, they saw Nick, Warren and Corey all frozen in their seats, fists clenched, clearly all fighting the urge to touch themselves.
"You enjoy that?" Benny asked, looking round at Warren.
"Holy fuck." Warren gasped, his eyes wide and his breathing shallow.
Corey's whimpering was now an almost continuous moan.
"Let's put him out of his misery then." Benny said reluctantly. "Corey's turn."
The boy was so close to cumming that he couldn't even comprehend what was happening around him. It wasn't until Josh approached the boy and flicked the switch on the butt plug that he realised what was happening.
"I'm gonna take it out, okay?" Josh said to his youngest brother, getting a slight nod in return. He grabbed the base of the toy and began easing it out.
"Oh my God." Corey yelped as it emerged. "Does this mean... I can touch myself now?"
"Yes." Benny answered, the boy immediately grabbing his cock in response. "But you can't cum yet."
"What? Why?" Corey demanded.
"Because I said so." Benny replied sternly.
"And what'll you do if I cum without your permission?" Corey asked.
Nick found himself staring round at Josh's hairless body. That had been the last punishment Benny had given for cumming without permission. Aside from the few fine hairs above his cock, Corey was already smooth, so Nick wondered what kind of punishment Benny would think of for him.
"If you cum without my permission, you'll get another forfeit." Benny insisted.
"Your forfeits don't scare me." Corey insisted. He sped up his fingers on his small erection and a few moments later he was gasping. "Give me the glass."
Benny was annoyed that the boy was disobeying him, but pleasantly surprised that he had remembered glass of cum. He handed it to Corey who stood up, pointed his little dick into it and shot several squirts of jizz into the slowly growing puddle in the bottom.
"He's gonna regret that, isn't he!" Nick said quietly to Josh.
"Yeah, I'd say so." the older brother replied.
Corey just looked at Benny and shrugged. "Do your worst."
Benny just smiled wickedly. "Not right now, but you'll be punished for this later."
"Whatever." Corey said, as he sat down again.
"What's next then?" Warren asked as he sat playing with his straining erection.
"Nothing." Josh interrupted before Benny could start anything else. "The pizzas should be here any time now, so I say we stop for food and carry on after. That ok with everyone?"
There was a general murmur of agreement and the boys started dressing. With the exception of Josh, they all seemed pretty resistant to the idea of getting dressed as they all very clearly needed to cum. Even Corey was already hard again as he started pulling on his clothes.
Josh was just in the process of clearing the pizza boxes away when Benny decided to announce his next planned activity.
"Okay. Nick, take your clothes off and Warren, grab me a blindfold from that box." Benny instructed as Josh came back in.
Nick was slowly removing his clothes as he asked, "What are we doing?"
"I think I'll call this game... erm... oh, I know, it's called the Edge of Glory!" Benny said happily, changing the name from its original plan. "You'll wear the blindfold and one of us will either wank or suck you off. You have to try and guess who it is."
"Okay." Nick said cautiously. It sounded far too straight-forward for one of Benny's games, there had to be a catch. "And?"
"And if you get it right, that person will make you cum and the game will end." Benny explained.
"And if I don't get it right?" Nick asked as everyone else watched on in anticipation.
"Then they'll stop, just before you cum and someone else will take over." Benny said, smiling wickedly as he revealed his plan.
"So if he keeps getting it wrong..." Dale started.
"Then he keeps getting edged, that's right. Anyway, get down on the floor, it'll give us easier access." Benny explained.
Nick finished removing his clothes and lay down on the floor, looking quite unhappy at playing the victim. "Why me?"
"Well you're the only person who hasn't cum yet. Well, except for Josh, but he can't." Benny answered, making all the boys look round at the older boy who squirmed uncomfortably as the entire room was reminded of his forced impotence. "It was going to be called the Edge of Corey, but he shot his load before dinner, so that leaves you."
Nick glared angrily at Corey who just shrugged. Warren approached the naked boy, looking him up and down before handing the blindfold to him.
"Thanks." Nick said, blushing a little as he took it. It was almost a relief to put it on. He knew the other boys were still staring at him, but at least now he couldn't see them. As he sat there, waiting for the games to start, his cock began stiffening in anticipation. He felt himself blushing a little more knowing that Warren could see him growing.
Silently, Benny pointed to Josh, indicating that he was meant to go first. Josh reached down, took hold of Nick's cock and started stroking it. He found it difficult to resist doing more. The boy's nipples had stiffened too, pointing up and just begging to be licked. Josh shifted slightly as his cock cage grew uncomfortably tight again.
"That's Dale." Nick called out.
Benny raised his finger to his lips indicating for the rest of the boys to remain silent.
"Am I right? Is it Dale?" Nick asked. He was again greeted with silence. "Wait, do I have to wait to see if I cum to know if I'm right?" No response. "Okay, well I won't be waiting long."
Josh could tell Nick was right. The boy's body was writhing beneath his pumping fist, already getting close to cumming. Josh would have loved to continue, to make his little brother shoot a massive load over himself, but just as Nick started moaning in anticipation, he let go.
"Fuck." Nick called out, bucking his hips in the air in the vain hope of making contact with his mystery wanker's fist.
For a minute, nobody moved, all awaiting Benny's command. Eventually he pointed at Corey who eagerly moved down to his brother's side. He took hold of the shaft with both hands and started pumping away at it.
"Oh shit." Nick called out, almost sitting up as he doubled over from the sensation. "That's Benny I think."
Corey smiled as he heard Nick's incorrect guess, knowing what it meant for the blindfolded boy. He continued stroking up and down at top speed. Josh stayed at Corey's side. He was worried the inexperienced boy might not know when to stop, a suspicion that appeared to be correct. Nick was moaning once again, his cock beginning to twitch and Corey showed no signs of stopping until Josh grabbed his arms to halt him.
"No." Nick called out as he felt the stimulation stop just short of the point of no return. A drop of pre-cum oozed from his cock and stretched down onto his smooth stomach.
Josh and Corey stood up as Nick was once again given a few moments to catch his breath. Next Benny pointed to Warren who took his place next to the naked teen. Instead of wrapping his fingers around the boy's shaft, he leant down and took it between his lips, running his tongue over the head as it slipped inside.
"Fuck." Nick called out. The warm mouth engulfing his organ felt amazing, almost enough to make him shoot his load instantly. "Tha...." he tried to make his next guess, but stopped mid-sentence as the mouth slid down the length of his shaft once again.
"Is that Josh?" he asked breathlessly. "Ah, aaah, oooh, fuck, fuck." His lips were quivering as he felt himself nearing the brink once more... then the mouth was gone. He took a few deep breaths, using every ounce of willpower he had as he resisted the urge to stroke his own cock so he could cum.
Next up was Dale, who took the same approach as his little brother, swallowing the boy's cock, but taking it a little slower, gradually easing Nick closer and closer to climax. "Ah yeah, that's good. Is that... I dunno. Is that Benny?" The slow suck worked on him gently, Nick moaning incoherently as he was teased painfully closer and closer to his repeatedly denied orgasm.
As Dale pulled away, leaving the desperate boy gasping once again, Nick reached down and grabbed his cock. "Sorry, I gotta cum."
"Ah, no you don't." Benny called out. He reached down and pulled Nick's hand away, so the naked by just grabbed his cock with the other hand. Josh leant down and pulled the second hand away too. "Grab the handcuffs from the box." Benny ordered Warren, who went over to grab them as ordered.
Benny cuffed Nick's hands together, then slid him round on his back. He pulled the cuffed hands above the boy's head, lifted the corner of the sofa and lopped the cuffs behind the foot of it as he dropped it back down.
"Okay, for that I'm gonna make it worse." Benny said, happy at the escalation.
As Nick lay there, he wondered what Benny might have in store for him, Perhaps the butt plug or one of the vibrators. He soon found out what the boy had planned as he felt first one mouth surrounding his left nipple, then another mouth on the right one.
"Oh fuck." Nick mumbled as he took a few deep breaths, the two tongues lashing at his solid nipples.
Benny directed Warren to go again, the boy this time deciding to stroke Nick's cock. He did it gently, enjoying the feel of the boy's stiff tool in his hand, and enjoying the sight of him writhing in pleasure even more.
"That's... it's... aaah, it's Corey." Nick called out. Seconds later, Warren let go as he felt Nick getting close.
As he felt the fingers releasing his cock, the near-orgasm seemed to linger for even longer than before, the nipple-licking clearly helping to sustain the sensation. Mouths licking his chest began to change over as the boys all took their turns edging the cum-deprived boy, wrong guess after wrong guess coming from him.
Josh went again, then Benny, Warren again, Dale, Corey, Josh, Dale. It was on dale's third go when Nick finally guessed right, whispering, "Is it Dale?" The edging had gone on so long now that he was barely even remembering to guess. He had thought the edging Benny made made him endure on Saturday had been pretty intense, but that had been relatively gentle as he had been given several minutes between teasings. Now though, it was an almost continuous stream of hands and mouths on his cock. It felt like he was now enduring a non-stop pre-orgasm, every touch of his cock like a jolt of electricity, the tongues on his nipples beginning to sting a little.
Hearing the correct guess, Dale had assumed he was supposed to finish the boy off so he sped up his wanking. That was when Benny had pulled his hand away with a cruel grin, shaking his head. The other boys soon realised that he had no intention of letting it end so soon. Nick had no way of knowing whether or not he was right without them telling him, so they simply continued taking it in turns to play with the boy for a few moments.
Josh went again, then Benny, Corey, Warren, Dale. They got into a regular pattern, each of them taking it in turns to tease the solid prick of the tortured boy. They had each taken three more goes before Nick finally guessed correctly again, this time as Corey was stroking him.
"Right at last!" Benny called out, surprising everyone. He reached down and pulled the blindfold off, allowing Nick to see his little brother sat next to him.
Benny lifted the sofa to release the boy's hands as he gestured for Josh and Dale to pick him up. They each grabbed an arm and lifted him, holding the limp boy between them as Corey continued playing with the tired cock. Benny watched eagerly, the cum glass now held in his hands.
"Ah, oh God, oh fuck, fuck, fuck fuck fuck fuck." Nick called out as he finally started to shoot.
Benny got the glass in place just in time to catch the first shot. Nick's cock was bouncing around wildly as shot after shot flowed in to join the other loads, the boy almost screaming as he unleashed one of the most intense orgasms of his life. If it hadn't been for Josh and Dale holding him up, he would have collapsed onto the floor as his legs went weak.
"Ah, ah, fuck, ah." Nick called out as the orgasm slowly began dying down.
Benny lifted up the glass to show the rest of the boys. "Don't forget, someone's drinking this!" he called out happily. He swirled the contents round, the glass barely a tenth of the way full so far. "And there's gonna be lots more in here by the time that happens!"
Nick was still recovering from the intensity of his orgasm, his entire weight currently held up entirely by the two older boys. They carried him over to the sofa and dropped him into a seat. "Fuck, that was... wow!"
"I hope you've got plenty left on you Nicky, you're gonna need it later!" Benny teased.
"Don't worry, I've got plenty left for that." Nick said, winking.
"For what?" Corey asked curiously.
"Wait and see!" Benny answered, rubbing the young boy's head. "Well it's getting pretty dark out there now. I think it's time for Nick to finish his dare from earlier."
All eyes turned to the recovering boy on the sofa. "Wait, what dare?" Nick called out in surprise.
"You're going outside." Benny insisted.
"Shit." Nick muttered, hoping that it had been forgotten.
"Now, what were the choices again, Dale?" Benny asked the older boy who smiled as he took a seat next to Nick.
"It was either lay on the front lawn and wank for two minutes, or get locked out of the house naked for the rest of the night." Dale recounted, much to Nick's dismay.
"That's right." Benny said, trying to pretend he had forgotten. He could tell from Nick's expression that he was dreading the thought of both options, so he decided to offer him an alternative. "If you're struggling to decide, I might be able to help."
"How?" Nick asked, understandably cautious of any offer of kindness from Benny. There was always a catch,
"You could let the cards decide." Benny replied, picking up the deck of cards from the coffee table where they had remained since Monday. "Draw one card. If it's a heart, you wank for two minutes, if it's a diamond, you get tied to the tree and if it's a club, you don't have to do either."
Nick's eyes lit up at the possibility of being let off the hook, but then came the question. "What if it's a spade?"
Benny grinned wickedly. "You'd get... a different forfeit, but you don't get to know what it is in advance. So... you making a choice or taking a card?"
Nick looked around the room. The expression on Josh' face made his opinion quite clear... don't trust Benny. The others though were mixed.
"Take a card!" Corey insisted.
"Just do the dare. Two minutes and you're done." Warren added.
"But you've got a one-in-four chance of getting that club." Dale pointed out.
"Come on Nick, what'll it be?" Benny hurried the boy along, holding out the pile of cards.
Nick looked once again at his older brother, then shrugged and said, "Fine, I'll take a card."
"Idiot." Josh muttered under his breath.
Benny fanned out the cards and held them up to Nick as all of the others moved in closer. Nick reached out and took one, keeping it hidden as most of the group held their breaths. He lifted the card and looked at it without letting any of the others see. "Fuck it." he muttered, then turned the card to reveal the seven of spades. The rest of the boys cheered. "Fine, what is it then?"
"You're gonna have another wank, but this time it's gonna be in the park, naked of course." Benny explained. "Oh yeah, I forgot to say, you're gonna be walking there naked too."
Nick looked terrified. He sat there and just shook his head. "No way. I won't do it."
"Yeah, I thought you might say that, so I thought up an even worse forfeit to go with it." Benny answered with a smile. "Refuse to do it and you'll get taken out onto the street, tied to a lamp-post naked and blindfolded and left there for an hour.
Nick was starting to look angry. He knew there was no way he was getting out of this and that Benny would just keep making it worse if he did. At that point, the best thing to do was take the dare, get it done with and move on. "Fine. Let's go to the park then." he said angrily.