Benny Takes Control

Disclaimer – This story is fictional and contains scenes that may be upsetting to some people. I strongly advise caution when reading.

Note – Please consider donating to Nifty, it's an awesome site http://donate.nifty.org/donate.html

Benny Takes Control

Chapter 23

by Matt

The journey home seemed so different to the one earlier in the day. That one had been filled with noise and excitement, this one was almost eerily quiet, only the sound of gentle snores coming from the back seats.

Dale found himself playing the day's events through his mind. Most of it had been fun, some parts had most definitely not. The thing between Josh and Alex had been difficult for Dale to watch. Not the part where his new boyfriend was having sex with another guy right in front of him. That couldn't really bother him, it had pretty much been the norm for them since they started dating. It was seeing Josh so upset and disturbed.

He had wanted to throw the aggressive boy aside, punch him, make him hurt for making Josh suffer. He wanted to hold his boyfriend in his arms and tell him everything was okay but all he could do was stand and watch. It had only been a few days, but he already felt so attached to Josh. It was that attachment though that made his heart ache as he remembered his earlier conversation.

'Nick thinks he likes you.' Dale repeated his own words in his head. 'Why did I even say that? I knew I wasn't going to like the answer. Oh God, and he likes Warren too. But he said he chose you. He made that clear, it's you, not Warren, not Benny, just you!' Dale attempted to reassure himself, but the thoughts lingered.

'It's Warren's fault. He's pretty much throwing himself at Josh. He knows how much I like him. Although... I suppose he had Josh first.' It carried on going round and round in his head. His eyes were fixed on the road ahead, his knuckles white as his fists clenched around the steering wheel.

Momentarily, he glanced round to the side, expecting his little brother to be asleep like the rest of the passengers. Instead, he was wide awake, his still-wet hair hanging down over one side of his face, the one uncovered eye staring straight at him. He looked back to the road and continued driving in silence.

A few more minutes passed. Another glance and the boy was still looking at him. "What?" he snapped, sharper than he had intended.

"Gonna tell me what's wrong?" Warren asked, his voice low to avoid disturbing the boys sleeping behind him.

"Nothing." Dale replied, still fairly sharp, but quieter now, matching Warren's volume.

A few more silent minutes passed awkwardly. The staring continued. "Stop looking at me!" Dale growled.

"I will, when you start talking to me." Warren said back defiantly.

"You can't have him!" Dale said without thinking, immediately regretting it.

"What?" Warren asked, completely lost.

Dale wished he hadn't said it, but now that it was out there, he figured he may as well get it all out. "Josh. I know you like him!" He looked round quickly at his little brother. The boy looked completely shocked and a little upset.

Silence fell again. Warren turned to stare out the window, leaving Dale feeling like the worst brother in the world. The last thing he had wanted to do was upset the boy. He heard sniffing, Warren was crying. He reached over and touched Warren's shoulder.

Warren turned and looked across at Dale. "I know." he said almost inaudibly. "I know I can't have him."

Dale sighed. "But that's the problem, you probably could if you wanted. He likes you too." he said back, his voice cracking just a little. "I've seen the way you are together."

"Yeah, you've seen that, but there's something you haven't seen." Warren replied.

Dale glanced round again. "What?"

"The way he looks at you when you're not looking. Or the way he smiles when you're not around and someone says your name." Warren said back, wiping the last few tears away. "Yeah he likes me... but he loves you."

Dale didn't know what to say. He was so exceptionally overjoyed to hear Warren saying those things, but at the same time his heart felt like it was ripping in half. It was so clear just how strong the feelings were between Warren and Josh, but the boy was willing to put all of that aside for the sake of Dale's happiness.

"Warren..." Dale said, he could feel tears welling in his own eyes but he held it back. "Thanks." was all he could manage to say.

A few moments later, Warren looked round and said, "Dale."

"Yeah?" the older boy replied.

"When we get home..." the boy 's voice wavered. "Can I have a hug?" The boy burst into tears again, curled up and slowly cried himself to sleep.

By the time they arrived home, most of the passengers had woken up. It was only Corey who was still asleep, but he woke too as the car pulled to a stop in the driveway. Everyone except Warren got out of the car, still dressed in just their shorts. Josh, Nick, Corey and Benny carried their bags inside while Dale walked round to Warren's door, pulling his t-shirt on as he walked. As the door opened, the younger boy just sat there, staring down at his own lap.

"Come here." Dale said, holding his arms out. The boy lunged at him, wrapping his arms around his big brother's waist.

Inside, Josh had gone into the kitchen while the other three had headed straight into the lounge. A few minutes later, Dale came in and headed for Josh while Warren had joined the other boys.

"Everything okay?" Josh asked, noticing how Dale's expression matched his own.

"I'm gonna take Warren home. All this stuff has... been a bit much for him." Dale explained. "I think it'll be best if he stays away for a few days. Me too!"

"Hey." Josh said, walking up to Dale and placing his hands on the young man's waist. "Are we okay?"

"Oh, yeah." Dale said with a smile, looking Josh in the eye and holding onto his sides. He realised the way it had sounded. "Yeah, we're good, and I can't wait for that second date." His smile dropped into something more serious. "But I think things have just got a bit out of hand this week and I've gotta look out for my little brother. He's struggling with a few things. Does that.... make sense?"

Josh nodded solemnly. "Honestly, I've been kinda thinking the same thing. I think... Alex was a bit of a wake up call." Dale felt Josh's entire body tense as he mentioned it. "The thought of Nick or Corey feeling the way I felt... I could throw up just thinking about it. Same goes for Warren, Benny too."

Dale said nothing, just nodded his agreement as he pulled his boyfriend into a hug.

"Don't go." Nick said, pulling an over-exaggerated sad face at Warren as the two sat together on the sofa.

"Dale says we have to." Warren replied, smiling at Nick's expression.

Nick just sighed. "I guess you have to then. Goodbye kiss?" He grinned.

Warren returned the smile before straddling Nick's lap and kissing him.

The boys were still kissing when Dale came in and said, "Time to go Warren, now put him down, you don't know where he's been!" The kiss broke as both boys laughed.

"Your brother's a dick!" Nick said to Warren, but with his eyes fixed on Dale.

"I completely agree." Warren said before pecking Nick on the lips and climbing off his lap. "I'll message you soon. See ya guys." He waved a quick goodbye to Benny and Corey as Dale did the same.

Out in the hallway, Warren looked into the kitchen, saw Josh and smiled at him. Josh smiled back but said nothing as the boy left with Dale.

"Nick!" Josh called out.

Nick ran in to see what he wanted, leaving just Benny and Corey in the lounge. "Sup?" Nick asked as he walked in.

"D'you mind going home with Corey?" Josh asked.

"What's going on?" Nick asked. Dale and Warren's sudden exit had seemed a little strange, but now this was really setting alarm bells ringing.

"Nothing, it's just... this is over." Josh said. Hearing himself say it aloud gave it a suddenly tangible finality.

"What's over?" Nick was just getting more confused.

"All of this. The six of us, the things we've been doing. I need you to stay away. I shouldn't have even let it start. I should have..." Josh started before getting cut off.

"Shut up!" Nick snapped. "Look, I get that you got freaked out earlier and now you're having... I dunno, second thoughts or whatever this is, but I'm not gonna let you stand there and say this week shouldn't have happened."

Josh just stared at his little brother, not sure how to react to the boy's outburst.

"Whatever's happened between all of us, right or wrong we've all had a fuckload of fun, we've made new friends, found boyfriends. And think about it, this has been the best thing to ever happen to mine, yours and Corey's relationship. Do you think we'd ever have been this close without the stuff we've done this week?"

"I guess not." Josh said. He had been so busy thinking about all the bad things, the harm he could be doing that he had completely overlooked the good parts.

"See, it's not all bad. Now get the fuck over it!" Nick said walking right up to his big brother and staring him straight in the eye.

Josh's expression softened. The boy was right. He was blowing all of it right out of proportion. "Ugh, you're right. But... I'd still like it if you could go home with Corey. I think it might be nice for Benny if I spent some time alone with him before his parents get home. After all, he started all of this!"

"Okay." Nick replied. He wanted to stay. In truth he had been having the time of his life messing around with Josh, Benny and the others, but he didn't want to argue. "I'll go and get him."

Nick headed into the lounge. Josh heard his youngest brother complaining, but after a few stern words from Nick, he quietened down.

"We're going now Josh, see ya later." Nick called out.

Josh headed out to the hallway. Nick was pulling on a shirt as the two of them headed for the door. Josh walked up to close the door behind them, but stood for a moment watching them walk down the driveway. "Are you gonna put some clothes on?" Nick demanded, waving Corey's t-shirt at the boy.

"Why? I got nothing to hide!" Corey called back as they reached the road, reaching down to his shorts.

"Corey, put your shorts back on!" Nick yelled as he disappeared around the corner.

Josh laughed at the boys as he closed the door. He turned back and came face to face with Benny who was stood in the lounge doorway, arms crossed.

"What's going on?" he demanded.

"Let's go and sit down, we need to talk." Josh said, walking towards him.

The two of them sat on the sofa. "They're not coming back, are they?" Benny asked.

"No." Josh replied honestly. "At least... not this week. I'm sure you'll see them again."

"Was it... something I did?" Benny asked, his face scrunching up as he tried to think what he might have done to cause this.

"No, I think it's more like something you... might do." Josh replied.

"It's Alex, isn't it?" Benny said, making the connection.

Josh nodded, his fists clenching nervously as he thought about the boy. "Look, you've made me do things this week that I didn't necessarily WANT to do, but I enjoyed them anyway and felt safe with you in charge of me. The thing with Alex, the sub part of me enjoyed what was happening, but the rest of me... Benny, I was scared. I wanted him to stop."

"Well it's over now. He... he can't do anything else to you." Benny stuttered back.

"Yeah, but... this week, there've been a couple of times when you..." Josh stopped, unable to even look Benny in the eye.

"When I what?" Benny demanded.

Josh looked the boy in the eye. "There were times when you were almost like that. Times I had to stop you or when I was actually scared of you." Josh froze. He was worried Benny might already be too far gone, that such a statement might trigger an angry reaction in the boy. He braced himself, ready to take cover if the boy lunged at him.

Benny just stared back at him. "I scared you? I thought... you liked it."

"That's the fucked up part. I did, but that's why I had to stop this. I love you Benny, you've literally changed my life, but the thought of you doing something that hurts my little brothers or Dale or Warren... I couldn't stand it. You're an amazing kid and you're an awesome master, but not when you're hurting people." Josh raised his hand and brushed it gently down Benny's cheek.

Benny sat in silence, absorbing what Josh had just said. "I didn't plan this." Benny said, flopping back into the sofa and facing out into the room. "All the other guys getting involved. Honestly, to begin with I just wanted to see you naked, but things just kind of... snowballed. And... and suddenly I had all these guys who would just do whatever I told them."

"That's a lot of power for one kid to have." Josh said, moving closer to Benny. He put an arm around the boy.

"It was fucking awesome!" Benny said with a grin.

"It was." Josh chuckled back at him. "So it's probably best to end it while it's still awesome and stop before someone gets hurt."

Benny just nodded.

They were both true to their word, all activity of a sexual nature ceased entirely between them. The closest they got to anything out of the ordinary was late that night after they had both gone to bed. Josh was close to falling asleep when he heard the bedroom door open. Benny just stood there. As soon as held an arm out, the boy dashed over and jumped in beside him. Even then, they had just cuddled as they slept.

During the day on Saturday, they had occasionally cuddled up together if they were sat watching a movie, but aside from that it was back to the way things had been before. Just a kid and his sitter, hanging out and having fun. Saturday night had gone much like the night before with Benny climbing in beside Josh to cuddle, but he kept his hands to himself.

Josh spent Sunday morning cleaning the house top to bottom while Benny played video games in his room. He wanted to make sure Mr and Mrs Harrison had a tidy house to come back to. After lunch, Benny had gone back to his room again while Josh did the dishes. When he was done, he headed upstairs to see what Benny was up to.

When Josh walked in, Benny was laying on his bed reading a comic. "Hey, you okay?" Josh asked.

"Yeah, I'm good. Although look what I just found." Benny said. He put down the comic, reached under his pillow and pulled out a pair of handcuffs, spinning them round his finger.

Josh just laughed.

"Whadda you say? One last time?" Benny suggested with an impish smile.

"Benny..." Josh protested.

The boy jumped off the bed and gave Josh a stern look. "Take off your shirt and lay on the bed!" he said firmly.

Josh wanted to resist. He knew he should, but his cock was already swelling and he knew it was pointless to fight it. He pulled his shirt off over his head and lay down as ordered.

"Hands." Benny ordered as he stood at the foot of the bed. Josh put his hands through as ordered and felt the familiar sensation of metal closing around his wrists. The younger boy jumped on top of him and quickly undid the jeans, then pulled them down along with Josh's underwear. A minute later, Benny had the feet secured in place with ropes too.

Josh's cock was rigid already, even before he watched Benny strip. Once he was naked, the boy climbed back on top. The feeling of the boy's bare, smooth skin pressed against his own almost made Josh forget why he had made them stop doing this. As he felt Benny's lips on his chest, any lingering hesitation vanished completely.

Benny worked his way down to Josh's stomach with kisses and licks, then back up via his nipples to nuzzle into his neck. "Kiss me." Josh muttered. Benny happily complied, his tongue pushing deep into Josh's mouth as they kissed like it was their first time. Benny happily lay on top of Josh, kissing him for several minutes as their naked bodies writhed against each other.

When the younger boy finally broke the kiss, it was only so he could straddle Josh's chest and push his small cock into the older teen's mouth. Holding onto the footboard of the bed, he thrust his hips back and forth firmly, shoving his erection as far into Josh's mouth as it would go, causing occasional gagging noises. The boy's breaths grew ragged as he edged closer and closer to cumming. Without warning or any reduction in the speed of his thrusts, he pumped a load deep into Josh's throat making him choke even more.

His cock was softening by the time he pulled out. He said nothing to Josh, just looked at him hungrily then went about undoing his feet. Josh knew what was next, the boy was following almost the exact same routine as their first encounter. Benny used the ropes to pull Josh's legs up towards his head, doubling the young man over and directing his cock into his own face. The ropes were secured in place once again and Benny climbed up to stand on the bed, looking down at his prisoner.

Benny buried his face in Josh's exposed arse, licking the hole. At the same time, he reached round to stroke Josh's boner, occasional drops of precum dropping down onto the captive teen's face. The dual stimulation had him moaning excitedly. There was no edging this time, Benny kept pumping his hand at full speed and a minute later, Josh yelled out in pleasure as he orgasmed, the load splatting heavily down onto his face and into his mouth.

Not even giving Josh a few moments to recover, Benny grabbed a box from under the bed. It contained all of his new toys, now hidden safely away for when his parents returned. He pulled out the largest vibrator and a tube of lube. He slicked it up and jumped back up onto the bed. Not being even remotely gentle, he thrust it into Josh's eager hole.

"Ow, careful!" Josh called out, feeling a twinge of pain, but it soon faded as the device was turned on, strong vibrations filling him with pleasure.

Benny started sliding it in and out vigorously, intentionally pressing it firmly against Josh's prostate as much as possible. Still horny and high from the first orgasm, it didn't take long until a second load twitched free from his still-wet cock.

Again Benny showed no signs of slowing, his eyes filled with lust and desire as he stared down at Josh. The thrusting vibrator continued its assault on his rear and Josh began to whimper in discomfort. The whimpers turned to yells as Benny's hand returned to his cock, but this time squeezing instead of stroking.

"Ow. Benny." Josh called out as he felt the boy's fingers tightening around his sensitive shaft.

"Shut up!" Benny snarled, his eyes wide and wild. He let go of the vibrator and slapped Josh's arse cheek as hard as he could, a red hand print appearing almost instantly.

Josh yelped, a mix of shock and pleasure.

"Oh I forgot how much you enjoy the spanking." Benny said almost deliriously. He pulled out the vibrator so fast it made Josh's entire body spasm, relief spreading through his cock as the squeezing stopped too.

Benny reached into the box and pulled out the wooden paddle. Without any warning, he swung it back and brought it down with a disturbingly loud crack on Josh's bare rear.

"AAARGH!" Josh screamed in pain. There was no pleasure this time, the heavy paddle sending waves of agony through him. Before he could protest, it smacked again.

Benny looked on in an excited frenzy, delighted at the bright red the cheeks were already turning.

"Benny, stop!" Josh called out desperately.

The boy ignored the plea, taking the handle of the paddle in both hands and hitting Josh as hard as he could. Josh screamed, louder than he had ever screamed in his life. "Benny, stop it, let me go!"

Benny dropped the paddle to the bed and lunged towards Josh's face, wet from tears of pain and terror. The boy's fingers wrapped around his throat. "WE STOP WHEN I SAY! YOU BELONG TO ME, DON'T FORGET THAT. YOU'RE MINE!" Benny yelled as his fingers tightened.

Josh was pulling at the cuffs, feeling the metal dig into his wrists as he struggled in vain. The rope chafed his ankles as he pulled, trying to get free. His body bucked wildly, trying to get loose of the boy's grip. "Benny." Josh gasped weakly. Another pull with his legs and rope popped free above him, releasing his legs. He twisted round and pushed his feet as hard as he could into the boy's chest.

Benny flew across the room, slamming into a wardrobe door and dropping to the ground heavily as Josh gasped to regain his breath. He curled into a foetal position, sobbing helplessly and shaking uncontrollably, his hands still secured in the cuffs above his head.

The younger boy just sat there on the floor, staring at the naked, crying teen on his bed, completely unable to comprehend what had just happened. He had no idea how long had passed before he made himself move, it could have been minutes or hours. He walked across the room and removed the cuffs, gasping in shock and fear as he saw the blood on Josh's wrists. He dropped back to the floor, the cuffs still in his hands.

Josh pulled his arms back down, crossing them in front of him as he continued laying there, curled up on the bed.

Benny eventually got back up, standing beside the bed. He reached down to put his hand on Josh's shoulder, "Josh..."

Josh jumped away as he felt the hand on him. "Don't touch me!" he yelled, sitting up on the bed and cowering away from the boy.

"I'm..." Benny attempted to speak, but seeing what he had done to Josh felt like a punch to his stomach, knocking his breath right out of him. He stared down at the cuffs, then back up at Josh. He started to shake uncontrollably. "Help me!" he whimpered through streaming tears.

Josh didn't know how to react. After what the boy had just done, he should be feared or possibly even arrested! But as he stood there, all Josh could see what he really was, a terrified little boy struggling to understand what was happening to him.

"I'm... I'm scared." Benny sobbed. "Please... help me."

Despite his fear of the boy, Josh slid across the bed and wrapped his arms around Benny, holding him tightly.

"I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I'm sorry." Benny repeated over and over as he cried into Josh's chest.

"So am I, Benny, So am I!" Josh whispered to him.

SIX MONTHS LATER

"You okay? You look nervous." Dale said with a comforting smile before turning his attention back to the road.

"I'm fine." Josh said quietly. "Just... yeah, I'm nervous."

"Ya know, we don't have to go. I'll quite happily turn us around and take you wherever you want." Dale said, reaching across and stroking Josh's leg.

"No, I'll be okay. Just... stay with me, okay?" Josh requested.

Dale was the only person aside from Josh and Benny who knew what had actually happened between them that day. Josh had called him as soon as he was able to. Dale had wanted to kill Benny, then call the police, in that order. Josh had managed to stop him from doing both.

There had been a lot of talking that night and a lot of tears. Benny had promised to get help dealing with whatever it was that had made him act that way and Josh had agreed that he had probably played a large part in what had happened. Not in the actual events of the day, Dale refused to let Josh accept any blame for that, but for allowing the boy to wander so far down a dangerous path, he definitely shared some of the responsibility.

Nick, Warren and Corey knew something had happened, but were spared the details. Josh and Dale made it very clear, however, that they were not to go near Benny, at least not until they said it was okay. Today was the first time any of them would be seeing Benny since that week. It was his fourteenth birthday and his parents were having a party for him at their house. Unaware of anything that had happened between the boys, Mr and Mrs Harrison had invited them all to come.

Shortly after the incident, Josh had come out to his own parents and introduced them to Dale. With Nick and Warren dating secretly, because Warren was still so young, their relationship made it a lot easier to explain why Warren was around so much. But whatever the reason for his presence, Josh's parents had happily accepted Dale and Warren into their family, now treating them like their fourth and fifth sons.

When Josh and Dale arrived at Benny's house, they headed around the side of the house to the back garden where the party was being held. A large gazebo had been out up over the grassed area in case of bad weather, but it was surprisingly warm for that time of year. They were greeted by Mr and Mrs Harrison, spoke briefly with Josh's parents who were attending too and then found Nick and Warren standing together on the decking.

"Hey guys." Josh said with a nervous smile.

"Hi." Warren said happily, greeting Josh with a hug.

Nick gave Dale a curious look and nodded towards Josh, silently questioning if he was okay. Dale smiled and nodded back. Nick got the idea.

"Anyone seen him yet?" Josh asked, looking round for any sign of Benny. They all shook their heads, just as Corey appeared from inside the house.

"Hey Cor." Dale said happily.

"Oh you're all here." Corey said as he realised all four of them were together. "That makes my job easier. Benny asked if we could all go inside and see him."

"You've... you've seen him?" Josh stuttered.

"Dude, what happened with you two?" Corey asked, his eyes narrowing. The youngest brother still lacked the tact to approach the matter with any delicacy.

Josh ignored the question. "Come on then." He headed inside, followed by the others and made his way into the lounge.

Benny was sat on the sofa, looking just as nervous as Josh. He stood up as they entered. Josh was amazed at how much he had grown in six months. He must have been about a foot taller now.

The two young men stared at each other for a moment before walking together into a hug. When they let go of each other, Benny looked the the rest of them. "Hey guys, thanks for coming. I know most of you don't know what happened with me and Josh," he flinched as he looked at Dale, knowing Josh's boyfriend knew every detail. "But I just wanted to apologise if I did anything to hurt any of you in any way. The way I acted back then was... it was totally unacceptable, it'll never happen again and I'm truly sorry. I hope we can be friends again because... I miss you!"

Not even knowing what they were actually forgiving him for, Warren Nick and Corey accepted his apology immediately. Josh's lingering affection for the boy made it easy for him to forgive too. Even Dale gradually accepted that the boy truly seemed to have reformed and before they knew it, the six of them were laughing and joking together once again.

"Here you all are." Mr Harrison said as he looked into the room from the hallway. "Come on, the party's outside, it's almost time for the cake."

As they were heading outside, Benny's phone vibrated. He pulled it out of his pocket and looked at the message.

[I'VE DONE AS YOU ORDERED]

Benny smiled at the message and typed back, [GOOD BOY, BUT YOU FORGOT TO CALL ME SIR. SOMEONE'S GETTING PUNISHED TONIGHT!]

THE END

Author's Note – I understand this chapter may not have been the ending that many of you were expecting. Honestly, it's not the ending I had imagined either. Originally I had only pictured this as being a two or three part story when it began, but the characters seemed to take on a life of their own and things just developed from there and I somehow ended up with a novel!

But while this is the end of 'Benny Takes Control', it's not going to be the last you hear of these characters. If you'd like to talk to me about this story or the upcoming ones, or if you have any comments/feedback, I'm always delighted to hear from you at matterotica@hotmail.co.uk

Thanks for sticking with me and I hope you enjoyed it.