Usual stuff applies. Please donate to Nifty, it's an awesome site. Don't read if you're not allowed.
Continued thanks for all comments and feedback, it's all welcome at matterotica@hotmail.co.uk
Benny Takes Control by Matt
Chapter 7
Josh woke up and, realising it was Saturday morning, decided to stay in bed. As it was the weekend, his parents would be home. He had gotten used to having his brothers at home because of the school holidays, but his brothers AND his parents together were a bit too much. Staying in bed and out of the way was clearly the way to go.
He looked for his phone, eventually realising it was on the floor. He had fallen asleep the previous night with it in his hand, waiting to see if Nick would reply to his message or just storm back in when Benny revealed their trap. He felt bad for setting up his little brother, but he figured that if Nick was blackmailing him, he deserved it.
'Did he, though?' he asked himself. 'He didn't actually do anything particularly mean to me. What if he's pissed at me again? He should be. I just hope he doesn't think everything we did was part of the trap. Oh God, I fucked my little brother. Well he fucked me first, so that makes it slightly more okay, doesn't it! Nope. Not even a little bit. Never again. I can't let any of that happen again.' Josh resolved, promising himself to make sure the situation never occurred again.
As he checked his phone, he was surprised to see no messages. He figured there would at least be some kind of response from Nick, even if it was telling him to go fuck himself. Nothing from Benny either. As relieved as he was to be free of orders, he found himself messaging Benny anyway.
[MORNING. YOU OK?]
As always, Benny's reply came quickly. [MORNING. I'M GOOD, HOW U FEELING AFTER LAST NITE?]
[IT'S COMPLICATED. DID NICK REPLY TO YOUR MESSAGE?]
[IT'S COMPLICATED. GOT GOOD NEWS 4 U THO. I'M BUSY 2DAY, SO UR FREE 2 DO WHATEVER U WANT]
Josh was curious about the first part of the reply. Were things actually complicated, and if so why, or was he just mocking Josh's previous message? He soon forgot about it as he considered the rest of the message, after deciphering Benny's text talk.
[THANKS. HAVE A GOOD DAY THEN]
[U2]
Josh lay there, suddenly at a loss for what to do. He found it a little disconcerting how quickly he had adapted to following someone else's orders. The thought of doing what he wanted for the day almost felt wrong.
When he had showered and dressed, he figured it was time to face Nick. He knocked on the boy's door but got no answer. He knocked again – still nothing. Slowly he opened the door and looked inside. The bed was made and Nick wasn't there, so he headed downstairs and into the kitchen.
As Josh walked in, he found his Mum, Dad and youngest brother all sat eating breakfast. "Morning." he said casually to them.
"Wow, up before lunchtime. Special occasion?" his Dad asked sarcastically.
Josh flashed a fake smile. "Wow, you're a funny, funny man." He sat at the table and poured himself some cereal. "Anyone seen Nick this morning?"
His Mum and Corey both shook their heads. His Dad, who was just finishing a mouthful of toast nodded. As he swallowed, he said, "Yeah, he went out really early. Said he had some things to do today and that he'd be back in time for dinner tonight."
Josh looked concerned. He couldn't remember the last time Nick's Saturday morning hadn't consisted of playing on his xbox. Suddenly having plans the day after... everything that had happened seemed somewhat suspicious. He put it out of his mind for a moment, telling himself it was nothing to worry about, that Nick probably just needed some space. "So what are you all doing today?"
"I'm going out for the day with Annabeth." his Mum replied, smiling. "Your Dad's taking Corey to his football match and then he's been roped into chaperoning the team afterwards."
"Yeah, I can't wait." his Dad said flatly. The parents of the boys on the team took it in turns to take the team out for something to eat and some form of entertainment after their matches on Saturday mornings. Josh's Dad really hadn't been looking forward to his next turn; his last one had ended up with a lifetime ban from two different businesses! "Wanna come and help?"
Josh smiled cruelly. "Not even a little bit!"
They finished breakfast and half an hour later, Josh was alone in the house. Still worried about Nick, he decided to go out for a walk, seeing if the boy had gone off to any of his usual places. The first place he decided to check was the park. It was only a ten minute walk away and Nick used to love going there and hanging out on the swings or skimming stones on the lake.
It was a nice day, which meant the park was already fairly busy. People jogging, walking their dogs, bringing their kids to play, teens from the nearby college laying on the grass studying or just hanging out with friends. As Josh looked at the small groups of youngsters, he told himself he had to message a couple of his friends later. Since leaving school, he'd drifted away from them and he rarely made the effort to reach out to them any more.
Heading down to the lake, Josh saw a group of four boys kicking a football around. He immediately recognised three of them – it was Greg, Tim and Warren. The fourth boy he had never seen before. He considered just carrying on walking, not quite sure what he'd have to say to the boys, but that turned out not to be an option.
"It's Josh!" Tim called out, pointing over to him as he saw the familiar face.
Greg and Warren looked round too. As Warren eyes made contact with Josh's, both boys froze in place. "Come on." Greg said, nudging Warren as he and Tim ran over. The mesmerised boy followed shortly behind, with the fourth boy following after him.
"Hey Josh." Greg said happily as he reached him.
"Hey guys, you okay?" he said timidly, thinking back to the embarrassment he had endured in their company yesterday. The feeling intensified as Warren reached them. All Josh could think about was standing face to face with Warren on the back road, both of them naked and nervous. He gave a shaky smile to the boy, who returned it awkwardly.
"We're good." Greg replied for them all. "Thanks again for yesterday. I don't think we'd have had anywhere near as much fun without you there." Josh cringed a little, knowing the boy just meant that it had been an entertaining day, but feeling like he was referring only to Josh's humiliating moments.
"You're welcome." he said, recovering slightly. "I hadn't been there in years, it was fun."
The fourth boy had now joined them and stood to Warren's side. He was quite a short boy, around Tim's height. He had a very slim build and short golden brown that hair was messy, but intentionally so. His small size and delicate features made him look much younger than the other three, although Josh suspected he was a similar age.
Greg saw Josh looking at him. "Oh, sorry, Josh, this is Sam. Sam, Josh." he introduced them.
Josh was about to say hello when Sam grinned devilishly. "You're the speedo guy, aren't you!"
The older boy looked thoroughly deflated. "Oh good, I'm glad that's spreading." he said through a fake smile.
The four boys laughed at his reaction. "Sorry." Tim said, "We've only told a few people."
"Don't worry about it." Josh said, shifting uncomfortably as the embarrassment was starting to arouse him. "Anyway, you should get back to your game. I was just looking for someone."
The boys said their goodbyes and ran back to kick the ball around some more while Josh continued down to the lake, starting down the path that surrounded it. The path was lined with tall trees, which had grown over to hang above the lake, making the route Josh walked nicely shaded from the blazing Sun.
He had been walking for a couple of minutes and had yet to pass anyone, this was clearly a less popular part of the park than the main area. Suddenly he heard a voice behind him. "Hey, Josh, wait for me!" He looked round and saw Warren running towards him. He felt like his heart had just jumped up into his throat as he saw the boy approaching.
"H... hey Warren." Josh stuttered nervously. He didn't know why the boy had this affect on him. When Warren reached him, he stood facing the older teen in silence. "You... okay?" he asked, curious as to why the boy had followed him.
Warren looked down at the ground, his hands starting to shake. Josh stepped forward, placed his hand under Warren's chin and tilted it up to make the boy look at him. "Warren, are you okay?"
The young teen's mouth quivered, obviously trying to stop himself from crying but it didn't work. He whimpered slightly before he completely burst into tears. Josh pulled the boy into a hug, Warren's arms wrapping around him and return, squeezing tightly. Eventually he stopped crying, but continued to hold on to Josh.
It was the older boy who eventually let go, prompting Warren to do the same. He looked round and saw a bench a short distance down the path. He put his arm around Warren's shoulders and lead the boy towards it. They sat down and Warren stared nervously down at his hands.
"Is this about what happened yesterday?" Josh asked quietly. Warren nodded. "Oh God, did I hurt you? Or make you do things you didn't want to?"
Warren quickly looked up at Josh in response to the question. "No.!" he said emphatically. "When I told Benny I'd seen your boner, he said he'd let me see it up close if I wanted. He let me do those things because I asked him to. What you did... felt amazing. "
Josh almost laughed with happiness as he heard the boy say that, but his distressed state was enough to keep his emotions grounded. "So what's wrong?" he asked, gently stroking the boy's arm.
Warren pulled his phone out of his pocket. Josh had a feeling he knew what he was going to see, as well as who was behind it. 'Benny. What did you do now?' He was right. Warren pressed a few buttons then turned the phone to show Josh a video of the two of them.
"Benny filmed us." Josh said, tearing up again. "And he says he'll show this to everyone if I don't do everything he tells me."
"I'm so sorry." Josh said, reaching up to push the hair aside from the upset boy's face. "Benny's... a little out of control. It's not just you he's doing this to."
"He's got you too, hasn't he. That's why you did everything he told you yesterday." Warren said.
Josh just nodded. 'But in my case, I like it!' he thought to himself, but didn't let on to Warren. "Look, this whole 'doing whatever he wants' thing, it sounds scary, but so far he hasn't done anything that's really nasty. I think he's mostly just playing. I don't think he'd do anything that would really hurt you."
Warren looked at him hopefully. "Really?" he asked.
"Yeah." Josh replied. "In fact, he's only told me to do things I really wanted to do, that I ended up enjoying." He couldn't believe this. He was essentially confessing to enjoying being Benny's personal bitch. He was confessing something else too without realising it.
"So... the stuff with me... you wanted to do that? You enjoyed it?" Warren asked, almost smiling now.
Josh considered playing it cool, but decided to take the chance to try and cheer the boy up. "Doing things with a hot little guy like you? Who wouldn't!"
"You think I'm hot?" Warren asked, the smile now fully formed.
"Scorching." Josh grinned back at him.
"Thanks." Warren blushed.
Josh thought for a moment, unsure whether to try and change the subject or ask what was really on his mind. His curiosity got the better of him in the end. "Yesterday, after you'd... erm, cleaned me up, I got the feeling that... maybe... erm, you might have been about to... kiss me."
Warren nodded. "I was. I don't know why, I was just there, and you were there and I felt this urge and..."
"And then Benny interrupted." Josh finished the sentence. 'It always comes back to Benny.' he thought.
"Yeah." Warren said, "He interrupted. If he hadn't, though... would you have... kissed me back?"
Josh stared at the boy. He knew the answer, but decided to show him instead of saying it. He leant forward and kissed him. Warren opened his mouth slightly to let Josh in. The kiss only lasted a few seconds before they both pulled back.
"Well that answered that." Warren said, smiling. "So I'm guessing you're probably gay then?"
Josh smiled, thinking back to yesterday's revelation. "Actually no. As it turns out, I'm bisexual."
"Cool." Warren smiled at the answer.
"And how about you?" Josh asked.
"Me? I'm thirteen. I'd probably get off with anyone who offered. I don't need to pick a side yet, I've got years." Warren explained. Josh was amazed at the level of self-awareness the boy had. It was something Josh had never had at that age, and probably still didn't today.
"So is that what I am? Anyone who offered?" Josh asked, pretending to look hurt.
Warren gently punched him in the arm. "Afraid so."
"And here I thought you was gonna sit here and confess your undying love for me." Josh said, only partly joking.
Warren's face turned serious for a moment. "Actually, if I was three of four years older, I probably would." Josh stared, stunned as Warren spoke. "I know six years isn't a huge age gap, ya know, for an adult, but nineteen and thirteen, that's just not gonna work."
Josh felt like he had been punched in the stomach, his feelings for Benny suddenly jumping to the forefront of his thoughts as reality set in. At the same time, he was secretly disappointed at Warren's lack of interest in him.
Warren was worried by the pained expression on Josh's face. He would have liked to flatter himself by thinking it was because of him, but he figured was something else going on there. Not wanting Josh to get too lost in thought, he reached over and stroked Josh's cheek, then said, "Look, I may not be in love with you, but you're the first guy I was ever with. That's always gonna make you special to me."
Josh was broken from his thoughts by the truly sweet comment from the boy. He was lost for words until Warren added, "Well, at least until someone fucks me, then you'll be long forgotten." Both boys laughed, but stopped as their eyes met.
"Do you... want someone to fuck you?" Josh asked nervously.
"I was just kidding." Warren smiled. "But now that I think about it... well I've never tried it. Do you want to... do it?"
Warren's arse. Was Josh actually being offered Warren's arse? That perfect, round little butt. That was it, instant boner. He couldn't answer. Warren looked down at the tent in Josh's shorts. "Wow, you REALLY want to fuck me, don't you?"
Josh blushed bright red. Wanting the boy so much was embarrassing, having him know it, having him see it show so openly was a hundred times worse. "Sorry." Josh muttered.
"Don't be. It sounds hot." Warren smiled.
Josh thought back to yesterday, when he had made Warren cum. He had slipped a finger into his hole, but it was so tight. "Have you ever put anything up there before?"
Warren shook his head. "No, nothing. Well, except your finger." He quivered with excitement as he remembered it.
"Then... no, actually I don't want to do it."
"What? Why not? It certainly looks like you do." Warren demanded, confused.
"You're so much smaller than me, and my cock is pretty big..." Josh started.
Warren reached down and squeezed the boner. "Yeah, I can see that."
Josh almost jumped out of his seat in surprise. "What I'm saying is, I think if I tried to fuck you I might actually hurt you, or cause some kind of damage."
Warren understood. Putting the boy's well-being before his own, very obvious, horniness seemed like a very sweet gesture. He smiled at the nervous, aroused young man then leaned over and kissed him gently on the cheek. "I see what you're saying."
Josh couldn't believe he had just talked the boy out of it. His cock might never forgive him, especially right now as it felt harder than it had ever been in his entire life, a fact that Warren definitely took notice of.
"For being so nice, I think maybe I should help you out with this." he said, stroking his hand down the constrained erection.
"What, here?" Josh asked, looking round nervously. The path stretched quite far either way, eventually curving round a corner, while the far side of the lake was too distant to make anyone out clearly.
"We've been here a while and nobody's passed yet." Warren pointed out. "Go on, get it out."
Josh quickly complied, undoing his shorts and pulling out his cock. The boy quickly took hold of it and started stroking it up and down. "Ah, yeah." Josh gasped with pleasure.
Warren pulled at Josh's shorts and boxers, so the older boy raised himself slightly off the bench to allow him to pull them down to his ankles. "T-shirt off." Warren instructed as he continued playing.
Nervously, Josh looked both ways down the path, terrified that someone could appear at any moment. Seeing nobody either way, he pulled his t-shirt up and over his head, dropping it to the floor next to the bench. Being naked now just turned the young man on even more, his cock oozing streams of pre-cum as Warren stroked it. As the boy continued, his hand getting more and more slippery, he leaned over towards Josh's chest and took a nipple between his lips. Josh grunted with delight.
The stroking continued as Josh edged closer and closer to release. His breathing started to speed up and his whimpers of pleasure slowly turned into yells, not caring if anyone heard as he started to shoot. Warren watched in amazement as Josh's cum-explosion began. The first shot cleared the path and splashed into the lake, while the following ones left a gooey white trail leading from the water to Josh. The last few dribbles oozed out and slid down Warren's fingers. Looking at Josh, he raised his hand to his mouth and tasted it.
Coming down from his orgasm, Josh suddenly felt very exposed. He stood and pulled up his shorts, then slipped his t-shirt back on. He didn't really need to rush as nobody had appeared yet, still leaving the two of them alone. "Fuck, that was good." Josh said happily.
"Yeah, I noticed." Warren said, looking at the cum that was slowly melting into the path.
Josh looked round at the boy, seeing the he, too, was hard. "Your turn?" he asked, gesturing towards the bulge.
"You're not getting me naked here!" Warren insisted.
"Who said anything about being naked?" Josh smiled. He stood up, making the boy stand with him, moved behind him and wrapped his arms around. His hands began rubbing the boy's body through his t-shirt, working up to feel the stiff little peaks of his nipples. As he did it, he buried his face in Warren's neck, kissing and licking his way around to the back, then on to the other side.
Warren was amazed at the feelings. The bigger boy's strong arms around him felt amazing, the fingers teasing his nipples sending jolts of pleasure straight down to his rigid dick, while the kissing around his neck felt like nothing he had experienced before.
Josh pulled one of his hands back round and wet a finger with his mouth before reaching down the back of Warren's shorts. He felt his way down the crack of the boy's flawless arse until his slicked finger found the hole. He slid his digit back and forth across it a few times. Warren's legs shook, but the arm wrapped around him by the bigger boy helped him remain standing.
Josh started to push his finger inside as Warren gasped in astonishment. The finger went in all the way. Josh thought about the fingering he had received from Benny, remembering fondly that first moment he had touched the prostate. He searched round for Warren's, quickly finding the target and pressing his finger gently into it.
That was all it took. Between the neck-kissing, nipple teasing and prostate stimulation, Warren began shooting a load inside his underwear, the warm wetness slowly engulfing his entire cock as the cum soaked in to the fabric. Josh gave one more quick press on the prostate, prompting a yelp of pleasure from the boy before he slid his finger out.
Warren turned to look at Josh who looked exceptionally pleased with his work. "See." he said. "I didn't even need to get your cock out."
"You fucker." Warren said angrily but smiling, then reached down to adjust his wet package. "That feels so weird."
Josh chuckled to himself. "So how did the finger feel?"
Warren's eyes widened. "Fuck, that was intense."
"Yeah." Josh nodded, then raised his finger. "Look at the size of my finger. Now think about my cock. See now why fucking you would have been a bad idea?"
Warren gulped and nodded. "Y... yeah, that thing woulda split me in half. I think I need to practice on my own first before I could take that." Josh's mind raced as he imagined what the boy meant.
"Come on." he said, putting his arm round Warren, leading him back towards the park. "You need to go and find your friends. What do they think you're doing anyway?"
"Talking to you." Warren answered casually.
Josh was a little worried, curious to see what conclusions the other boys might jump to. They found them in the same spot they had been earlier, still playing.
"What have you guys been up to?" Greg taunted them as they approached.
"Have fun with your boyfriend?" Sam added.
"Yeah, he gave me a blow job. It was amazing." Warren replied. Josh almost choked.
The boys all started laughing and Josh realised they knew Warren was just joking. If only they knew how close he was to telling them the truth.
"Yeah, like anyone could actually find your tiny dick." Tim replied, prompting a quick kick in the shins from Warren.
"See you guys later." Josh said, walking away.
"Bye Josh." Greg and Tim called out, while Sam just waved.
He looked back and saw Warren watching him. They both smiled as Josh turned and walked on. Josh's visit to the park hadn't gone quite the way he expected, but it had definitely been enjoyable. He suddenly remembered what had triggered the conversation with Warren in the first place... Benny.
What was the boy up to? He already had control of Josh, now he had his claws into Warren. He thought about Nick. During the conversation he had with Benny about Nick's video, he had just asked his master to make his brother delete the video, but might he have had other plans there too? He headed home, wondering exactly what the boy had in store for him.
Nick got home just in time for dinner on Saturday evening. Josh attempted to get him alone before they ate, but he didn't get the chance. After dinner, Nick sat with his parents in the lounge watching TV and playing on his phone. Figuring the best way to talk to him was by text message, he sat with them in the lounge and pulled out his phone.
[HEY, ARE YOU OKAY?]
[YEAH, I'M FINE. WHY?]
[AFTER LAST NIGHT. I THOUGHT YOU MIGHT BE PISSED AT ME]
[WHY WOULD I BE PISSED, IT WAS FUN]
Josh was confused. Had Benny not sent him the message? [WHERE HAVE YOU BEEN TODAY?]
[SEEING MATES]
[YOU DON'T HAVE MATES]
[FUCK YOU]
[MAYBE LATER ;-)] Josh immediately cursed himself for his automatically flirty reply. He had sent it without even thinking.
[YOU'RE SO FUCKED UP]
Josh hesitated before he replied, looking up at Nick. [I KNOW]
Nick looked back, seeing his brother's pained expression. [SORRY, I DIDN'T MEAN THAT]
[IT'S TRUE THOUGH. I REALLY AM]
[THEN SO AM I. I ENJOYED LAST NIGHT AS MUCH AS YOU DID]
Josh thought back to the morning, when had promised himself that the thing with Josh was just a one off. It would have been so easy now to continue it, but he had to remain strong. [YOU KNOW IT CAN'T HAPPEN AGAIN, DON'T YOU?]
[WHY NOT? WE'RE NOT HURTING ANYONE]
[I KNOW, BUT IT'S WRONG]
[IF IT'S SO WRONG, THEN WHY ARE YOU GETTING HARD?]
Josh looked down, terrified of what was showing and that his parents might notice.
[MADE YOU LOOK!] Nick's next message teased.
[THAT WAS MEAN]
[AWW, HAVE I BEEN A BAD BOY? DO I NEED TO BE PUNISHED?]
Josh stared at his little brother and gulped, unable to respond.
[OR MAYBE YOU'VE BEEN THE BAD BOY. DO YOU NEED LITTLE BROTHER TO PUNISH YOU]
[STOP IT] Josh really was getting hard now.
[BUT YOU'VE BEEN SO NAUGHTY. NAUGHTY BOYS DESRVE TO BE PUNISHED. I THINK YOU NEED A GOOD SPANKING]
[SERIOUSLY, STOP IT, WE'RE NOT DOING THIS]
[JUST IMAGINE BEING STRIPPED, BENT OVER MY KNEE AS I SPANK YOUR BARE ARSE]
"Josh, are you okay?" his Mum asked, looking round at him. He was breathing heavily and had turned very pale.
"Yeah." his voice quivered. He cleared his throat. "Yeah, I'm fine."
Nick struggled to contain his laughter.
[THIS IS JUST TOO MUCH FUN] Nick sent
[YEAH, FOR YOU]
[I CAN MAKE IT FUN FOR YOU TOO]
[NO, I TOLD YOU, WE'RE DONE. YOU CAN'T MAKE ME DO ANYTHING WITHOUT THAT VIDEO]
[NOT TRUE, I CAN MAKE YOU GET HARD]
[STOP IT]
[I CAN MAKE YOU CUM]
[NOT IF I DON'T LET YOU]
[BUT YOU WILL LET ME. LOOK AT YOURSELF. TELL ME YOU DON'T WANT TO DO THIS]
[OF COURSE I WANT TO DO THIS. MY POINT IS THAT WE SHOULDN'T]
[I KNOW, AND DOESN'T THAT JUST MAKE IT MORE FUN?]
Josh paused, taking a moment to fight every natural urge. But his brother was completely right and he knew it. [YES]
[THEN LET'S DO IT]
[PLEASE NICK, I CAN'T]
[YOU CAN AND I THINK YOU WILL, BUT I'M BORED OF TRYING TO CONVINCE YOU. IF YOU WANT TO DO IT AGAIN, COME TO MY ROOM AT MIDNIGHT. DON'T COME AND I'LL NEVER MENTION IT AGAIN]
Nick got up out of his seat. "I'm bored, I'm going to my room." he said, heading out to the hallway. Josh remained seated until his erection has subsided enough for him to get up and leave too, he had some thinking to do.
It was 11:55. Nick sat on his bed, staring at the door. He knew his brother would come, he just had to. He saw how turned on he was during their text messaging. He thought about what Josh had been saying, about it being wrong. He knew his brother was right, but frankly he just didn't care. Fun was fun. So long as everyone consented... eventually, then no harm done.
11:59. It was nearly time. Listening carefully he heard Josh's bedroom door open and careful footsteps creeping down the hall. The door opened and Josh appeared.
"I knew you'd come." Nick teased.
Josh shook his head. "Sorry bro, I only came to tell you it's not going to happen." Josh said flatly.
Nick sniggered at the poor attempt at resistance. "You could have come in here any time to tell me that, or sent a message, but you're here, now, exactly when you got ordered to. You can't help yourself, you just have to do as you're told."
Josh wanted to argue back, but he couldn't.
"Okay, take your clothes off." Nick said, getting up from his seat as Josh undressed.
As the older boy stood there, naked and hating himself with every second, Nick took hold of his arm and lead him towards the bed. He made his big brother lay down and raise his hands together above his head. The younger boy reached down to the floor and picked up his school tie, then bound Josh's hands together, looping the tie around part of the headboard. He pulled at Josh's hands, ensuring they were secure before climbing back off.
Josh had already been hardening before, but as his brother bound him he grew to full stiffness.
"How does that feel?" he asked, smiling.
"I don't know." Josh said weakly, "Good I suppose. What are you going to do?"
"What would you like me to do?" Nick teased, gently running his fingers across Josh's chest.
"Are you... going to punish me?" Josh asked cautiously, not sure whether he was trying to avoid it or suggest it.
"Well that's not really up to me." Nick smiled, walking away. Josh watched as he headed over to the computer and pressed the power button on the monitor. "It's up to him." he added as Benny appeared on the screen.