This experience started back when Craigslist still allowed M2M posts. I'll do my best to give an accurate picture of how it happened.
For some time I had a fantasy of being caught by a stranger while doing something that would embarrass me. Thought of a few situations and prepared a CL post but always chickened out at the last moment and did not do the required steps to post. One day decided I either had to follow thru with it or give up the fantasy. Following is what I remember writing and then posting.
Catch Me
"Naked and alone in office /warehouse watching computer porn. Multi-tenant building but private and safe, with door locked won't be disturbed. You walk in and `catch me'. I'll protest and ask you to leave but you threaten to inform my neighbors unless I agree to your demands. Your age, race and cock size not important, just be clean, DDF, HWP and cut. I have condoms and lube here, safe only. Respond with basic stats and when you can be here. I am located near the Newspaper building."
I went thru the verification process then hit the post icon before I had time to change my mind. Took about 30 minutes before seeing a response, then over the next 15 minutes had six. Only two had the requested info and I picked the one that could arrive soonest. I went back and forth about what I should do. I knew it was dangerous and maybe that part added to the excitement of the fantasy. Anyway I had gotten this far and didn't want to back out again.
I wrote a reply giving the address, telling him the key was in the door and to lock it when he entered. Said if he did not arrive in 45 minutes I would lock the door. Nervous, apprehensive and aware that what I was about to do was wrong but by then I was already excited and erect. Hit the send button and immediately regretted it but told myself I needed to get ready.
Took everything off my desk except the computer and condom/lube packets. Put the key in the door, found a gay porn video and then stripped. After that I waited and worried. Afraid someone, delivery driver or solicitor, might come in. No idea what I would say if that happened. As the time passed I got even more nervous and almost put my clothes back on to lock the door. Kept telling myself to wait another minute, then another minute.
I heard the front door open and pretty sure my heart stopped, then heard the lock being turned. He came to the office door and stood there looking at me. I asked who he was and why he was there, he replied "I'm Juan and I'm looking for my friend". We went through the `me telling him to leave and him refusing then threatening me before I gave in.'
I'll cut this part a little short, ended up with me on my back on the desk and my legs over his shoulders while he fucked me. When he finished he thanked me and quickly left. Not sure how I felt, I enjoyed the experience but now worried that a stranger knew where I was and what I was willing to accept. So concerned that for the next couple months I kept the door locked except when I had a scheduled delivery.
I don't remember exactly when I began leaving the door unlocked but as time passed I stopped worrying and didn't give it much thought. About 6 months later I was working in the warehouse and I heard the bell indicating the front door was opened. When I went to the reception area I saw two men standing there. It was common to have people coming in by mistake, looking for one of the other businesses in the building. I asked if I could help them and one answered " yes, you can lock the door". Confused I asked who they were looking for and the guy said "you". At that point I recognized him.
I knew it was Juan and I told him I was not interested and it would be better for them to leave. He gave me the same answer as the first time and I knew I was in trouble. I told him I was serious and did not want to do it again but he told me to do as he said or they would go to the neighbors. I was afraid he was serious and couldn't think of anyway out so in the end I agreed and locked the door.
Juan explained that he told his friend `Jaime' about me. He said Jaime had never been with a man but wanted to try it. I told him I did not want another guy there but he said it was not up to me. He said we should go in the office and get naked. Soon we had stripped and were standing there looking at each other. Juan and Jaime talked but Jaime did not speak English so I didn't know what they were saying.
I think Juan was convincing Jaime to go first and telling him what to do. Jaime came close to me, took my hand and put it on his cock. I rubbed it a little then he hugged me close and to my surprise kissed me. I tried to pull back but he held me tightly and even tried pushing his tongue into my mouth. I turned my head away and he put his hands on my shoulders and pushed me down to my knees. It was obvious what he wanted and I did me best to get him off quickly. He was too forceful at first and made me gag. I kept pushing him away until Juan said something to him and then he stood still and I was able to control the depth. When he came he put his hands on the back of my head to hold me on. As soon as he let me go I grabbed a paper towel and spit into it.
Before I could do anything Juan said something and Jaime pushed me over to the desk and then forced me face down on it. He tried to get his cock inside me but it was soft and I did my best to keep him out. Finally he gave up and stepped back.
I could see that Juan had rolled a condom on and knew what was coming. He told me to get on my back on the desk. He pulled my legs up over his shoulders and then applied lube to my ass and his cock. Probably because his friend was there watching, he forced his cock into me in one stroke. I yelled and tried to push him away but he wouldn't allow it. He fucked me so hard and fast that I almost started crying. I begged him to slow down and gradually he did. It was still painful but less and I tried to just hang on and get it over with.
He continued to fuck me slowly but occasionally he would stop to stroke my cock. To my amazement my erection returned. This went on for some time and I was beginning to enjoy it. Before long I told him I was about to come and he stopped jerking me off. I thought he would wait a while then begin again but instead he used his hand to slap my cock from side to side. It was not a gentle slapping, it was a little painful but for some reason it was very exciting. Didn't take long before I felt my balls pulling up and I had a powerful ejaculation. I had never experienced that extreme a climax before. He continued slapping as I came and it splattered over both of us.
When I finished he began fucking me again and quickly went from slow to hard and fast, each thrust all the way in. When he came I could feel his cock pulse with each squirt inside me. As soon as he finished he pulled out and used a paper towel to clean himself. Jaime had already gotten dressed and Juan only took a minute or so.. I was still laying on the desk when they left without saying a word.
After that I considered keeping the door locked again but decided to leave it unlocked. As time went by I started wishing they would show up but it's been more than a year and Juan has not returned. I know it's best that he doesn't but the desire is still there.