This is fiction not reality. Please donate to nifty so we can keep writing stories for you all to read.
After what had happened between Eli he couldnt stop thinking about Rafe fucking him... Evan had forced himself on him. But Rafe... Turned him on... Made him cum...
He was surprised when he went to a sex shop and bought a small butt plug. The man behind the counter assured it would do the trick. Eli looked at the man. Dont worry man... A lot of men like anal play he assures him. Eli hides the item in his pocket and rushes out before being seen... He wasnt looking where he was walking too and bumped into Rafe. Sorry man he says. Your making a habbit of this says Rafe jokingly. Eli laughs weakly. Whats wrong asks Rafe? Eli looks panicked. Hey... Relax man says Rafe. You dont fucking get it do you Rafe says Eli before rushing off.
All day he had been off and short with Rafe. Kissing Lani whenever he could to still prove to Rafe, anyone looking and to himself that he was still straight. That he wished he didnt love Rafes cock in his tight ass. Was he getting feelings for Rafe...? He tried to shake him out of his system but he couldnt. Finally Rafe pulled Eli aside and asked him what the hell was going on. If he needed to pull him out of the field. No... Just leave me alone man says Eli frustrated. Look. I apologized, i thought we were past this says Rafe. You dont fucking get it says Eli. What! Explain it to me then says Rafe. I... Cant says Eli about to leave. Tell me whats going on or im putting you on leave says Rafe matter of factly. Eli looks at Rafe. He looks terrified. Your my problem says Eli. Tears were filling his eyes. Rafe looks confused. I cant... I cant stop thinking about what you did... To me... While i fucked Evan... I was making love to Lani last night and all i could think about was your dick up my ass. I woke up this morning dreaming of it again. What the fuck is wrong with me. Im not gay. I love women. I love pussy. But... I cant stop thinking about you fucking me... How good it felt. How i didnt want it to end... The way you were playing with my nipples. Kissing my neck, licking my ears. Fucking me slow. I cant fucking stop thinking about it says Eli frustrated. Rafe looks at Eli. Do you want it to happen again asks Rafe? Yes... Ok... Yes says Eli emotionally. He lunges at Rafe and kisses him on the lips. His hard cock poking Rafe in the groin. Rafe returns the kiss briefly before pushing him away. Not here says Rafe. Meet me after work at my place says Rafe before taking his leave...
Rafe made sure to shower, so did Eli. Lani wondered where Eli was going he just said he needed a couple of beers. Saying that he still couldnt believe what shed done to help Kristen. But that he would be home later. Lani stayed back with her tail between her legs. When Eli arrived at Rafe with a six pack he suddenly got nervous. What the hell am i doing here he asks? He wants to leave but he also needs to be here. He was about to knock when Rafe opened the door in a towel. Eli nearly dropped the six pack. Come in says Rafe... Im running late. I was on the phone says Rafe. Eli walks in. Eli puts the six pack on the table. He sits at the table. His palms sweaty. His dick was hard at the sight of Rafe half naked. At the thought of getting fucked by Rafe. His hole was puckering and ready to be fucked. He made sure he douched. Something he really didnt like doing but was necessary. He remembered once... He fucked a girl in the ass... And it wasnt pretty. The next times he demanded they douched. Finally Rafe walks in. Opens a beer and tells Eli to follow him to the living room. Eli does. Wheres David asks Eli? At a sleepover close by says Rafe. So... Were alone asks Eli? Yeah we are says Rafe smiling. Eli chucks down the beer quickly. Want another asks Eli taking off before Rafe could answer. He went to the kitchen and downed another beer. Before takingn another out. He looked in the freezer and grabbed the vodka. Rafe looks at Eli confusingly. Rafe was still on his first beer, while Eli was on his third and now taking swigs of vodka here and there. We dont need to do this says Rafe. Eli just looks at Rafe, he dosent say anything. He downs another beer. He gets up and brings the other three beers before emptying another one. Rafe grabs a second and drinks it slowly. The room got quiet for a while. Eli could start feeling the effect of the booze. Soon he finished the last beer and took a couple more swigs of vodka. Feeling good. Tipsy. He looks at Rafe. He gets up and stumbles. He paces before finally deciding. How could Rafe make him feel like this... He didnt know but he knew right then he needed the hunks dick in his ass. Eli gets onto Rafes lap and kisses the police commissioner. Rafe was a little taken aback but quickly kisses Eli back. They could taste the beers and vodka. Eli could feels Rafes hard cock. Soon the clothes came off. Rafe was on top of Eli and between his legs. Elis muscular legs wrapped around Rafes waist. Rafe breaks the kiss. Lets go to the bedroom suggests Rafe. Once in the bedroom they start making out again. Eli breaks away. We dont have to do anything you dont want too assures Rafe. They look at each other... Eli pushes Rafe onto the bed and straddles him. Rafes big pre cumming leaking cock rubbing all over Elis hole. They start kissing again. Soon Rafe flips Eli onto his back as they make out. Eli pushes Rafe away. This didnt feel right... Being on his back... Legs in the air waiting to get fucked... For him... This is the position a woman has... Or a gay couple.... But this wasnt the situation. After a few moments Rafe attacks Elis neck. Eli starts moaning and almost crying in ecstasy. Rafe licking and gently bitting Elis ears. Fuckkkk moans Eli. Rafe kisses his way down Elis muscular body... His nipples, chest, abs... Pubes... By passing Elis cock and balls. He lifts Elis legs and shoves his face inside eating the life out of Eli. Eli is screaming in ecstasy. He loves having his ass eaten. Rafe was driving him nuts. Elis cock remains untouched. Eli too affraid hes shoot as soon as he touched it. Rafe had been eating Elis hole for a good ten minutes before Eli begs Rafe to fuck him. Fuck me man... Please fuck me begs Eli. Rafe smiles, grabs the lube and lubes his cock and Elis tight hole. He gently shoves a finger inside making Eli moan in pleasure. His cock twitching. Rafe slowly finger fucks Elis hole before adding a second finger making Eli moan even louder in pleasure. Put it in... Fucking put it in begs Eli unable to wait any longer. Rafe gets into position. Elis eyes on Rafes cock. Eli closes his eyes tightly afraid of the pain. Hey... Eli... Look at me orders Rafe... His cock kissing Elis hole. Relax ok... Breathe... Push out ok says Rafe gently... Eli tries. Just look at me... Breathe... Youll love this promises Rafe before pushing inside Eli. Elis eyes grow like saucers. His mouth fully open about to scream. Breathe Eli... Breathe... Push me out says Rafe. Rafes cock finally penetrates Elis tight hole. Aarrrgghhh groans Eli. Fuuuckkkkk moans Rafe... Eli grabs Rafe head and bring it to his face as he kisses Rafe hungrily. More of Rafes cock penetrates Elis hole making him moan loudly in Rafes mouth... Inch by inch... Slowly does Rafe burry all of his dick inside Eli. Elis cock still hard leaking precum. Rafes cock finally hitting Elis prostate sending Eli into a frenzy of pure lust as his cock shoots his cum all over his abs and flying all the way to his chin. His body convulsing, Elis screaming as his orgasm hits him. Rafe smiles. Well... Thats a first admits Rafe with a laugh. Eli looks at Rafe in shock and pushes him off him. He gets up, tears filling his eyes. What the fuck... Im sorry... Im so gay says Eli freaking out. Rafe gets up and turns Eli around and assures him that all is fine and that hes still straight. Look... I hit your prostate you were fucking horny... Massaging your prostate makes you cum says Rafe matter of factly. Eli looks mortified. Rafes cock is still hard... Eli got onto the bed on all fours and told Rafe to fuck him again. Youll be really sore i shouldnt say Rafe. Just fucking do it... You need too cum to says Eli feeling bad because he came so quickly. Rafe ads more lube to Elis hole and his dick and slowly slides his cock back inside Elis tight fighting gripping asshole. Aaarrrggggghhhh groans Eli in pain and pleasure. Rafe takes his time. It was painful for Eli. Not as painful as when Evan took him roughly. His cock suddenly got rock hard again. Fuck Rafe... Im... Hard again says Eli in disbelief. Rafe smiles. I think i found myself a good steady bottom thinks Rafe to himself. He slowly picks up the pace. Ooohhhh moans Eli. Rafe found Elis prostate once again and was hitting it the right way and it was driving Eli crazy. He changed directions and began to fuck Eli even harder and deeper and faster. Slapping sounds could be heard in the room. Fuckkkk mannn... Dont stop moans Eli. Rafe begins to fuck Eli even harder. Eli was bitting his knucle... The bedsheets are Rafe turn his hole into mush. His dick was leaking like a faucet of pre cum. Your ass is so fucking amazing moans Rafe kissing Elis sweaty back. Rafe begins slapping Elis ass a couple of times. Rafe brings Elis body uo against his. You like me fucking you asks Rafe. Just fuck me says Eli deliriously. Rafe stops... Noooo... Keep going man please begs Eli. What asks Rafe? Please fuck me Rafe dont stop begs Eli under Rafes spell. Rafe smiles and begins to fuck Eli again. Eli leans against Rafe sweaty chest. He turns his head around signaling Rafe to kiss him and he does. Eli didnt know what was happening to him but all he could think of was that Rafe was giving him the best pleasure of his entire life. Rafe begins to hit Elis prostate once again making Eli moan and scream louder in pleasure. Must to their shock Eli screamed once again as Rafes cock kept hitting his prostate and he began shooting cum all over Rafes bedsheets. His body shaking and convulsing in pure ecstasy. Elis hole going crazy onto Rafes cock... Eli collapses weakly into Rafes arms... Fuck... Moans Eli exhausted. Did you cum asks Eli? I was so close admits Rafe. They pull away from each other... Without saying another word, Eli got onto his back and told Rafe to cum and cum quickly. Rafe smiles and reinserts himself into Elis now relaxed and warm wet hole. The pain came back but it went away even faster than before. Eli looks up at Rafe. Do you like my ass man asks Eli? You know i fucking do says Rafe. Rafe starts playing with Elis nipples driving Eli mad with lust. Is it still tight asks Eli worriedly. Yes... your wetter than a pussy says Rafe. You want me to cum in you dont you asks Rafe? Eli just moans. Rafe chokes Eli and fucks him harder. Fuuuckkk fuuuuckkkkk fffffuuuuckkkkkk yells Eli in ecstasy. His cock brick hard once again. He couldnt believe it. Rafe couldn't either. Our little secret whispers Rafe. Such a good ass ads Rafe. Rafe plays again with Elis nipples... He was close. He hoped Eli wouls cum again but he wouldnt think it happen again. Why does this feel so fucking amazing moans Eli shaking his head side to side moaning like a bitch in heat. Eli pulls Rafe down to him and they kiss sloppily. Both men drenched in sweat. Their bodies sticking together... For another five minutes Rafe plowed Eli good hitting his prostate over and over and over again making Eli scream like a bitch. Im gonna cum soon promises Rafe... Cum man... Do it... Cum begs Eli. Rafe leans down and attacks Elis sweaty neck and plays with Elis nipples. Fuckinnnggg shittttt yells Eli cumming for a third time. His body shaking violently as his third orgasm hit him like a ton of bricks... Rafe couldnt take it anymore and yelled... Im... Cumminnnggggg... Shooting seven ropes of hot thick cum deep inside Elis quivering hole. Rafe falls on top of Eli. Both men exhausted and drained. After a few minutes Eli got up to leave but Rafe convinced him to take a shower. His hole was so full of cum. As he took a shower flashes of his orgasm played in his mind. He couldnt stop thinking about it. His cock began to get hard again. He had to turn the water onto icy cold to get it down. He washed all of himself but kept Rafes cum deep inside him. When he walked out Rafe was laying on the bed. Best sex of my life admits Rafe making Eli blush. Eli gets dressed and takes another big gulp of vodka he had brought upstairs. Eli looks at Rafe. Rafe kisses Eli gently. Anytime... My door is always opened for you... And that sweet ass of yours says Rafe. Eli dosent say anything and just leaves.He couldnt believe what had just happened. He went to the Brady pub and had another beer before heading to JJs appartment where he now lived with Lani. But before he went in he made sure no one was around and put the butt plug into his sore cummy hole, keeping Rafes cum in him.
Lani was asleep when he got into bed in just his tight black briefs. When she felt him she was all over him. His dick got hard... Because of the toy... Lani... Thoughts of Rafe... They made love and he came once again for a fourth time that day. His butt plug never leaving his ass...
The next day the butt plug was still there, but he had to remove it...
When he got to work, he tried to be proffesional...
Thank you so much for reading. I always like comments and feedback. Remember to donate to nifty... Stay tuned... More to cum...