This story is a complete work of fiction and all characters are copyrighted to FOX. This is in no way a representation of the sexuality of the actors.
Throwdown
Mr. Shue wasn't sure exactly how this whole co-director with Sue would turn out. She immediately started to split up the group, by taking all of the minority students to work on a number for sectionals. Mr. Shue wasn't too excited about the idea, but he couldn't seem to find a way to fight it.
Nothing seemed to be going right for Will Shuester, including his sex life with his wife. She was pretending to be pregnant to keep their marriage together, so Will was never able to be intimate with her because he would discover her secret. He started to work out even more to help deal with the pent up sexual frustration he was having, and since he didn't have a lot of money to get a gym membership, he would often use the facilities at the high school.
Mr. Shue loved showering in the high school gym. He's never showered with one of the students, but loved imagining all of them horsing around with one another, being completely comfortable in their naked teen bodies in front of one another. He missed his days of showering with the guys after pe class when he went to this high school, and had many fond memories of seeing all of his friends in various states of arousal. Finally, after running a few extra miles, he walked into the locker room and quickly took off his shirt.
He was surprised to hear one of the showers still going. Football practice must've ended an hour ago, so he assumed that one of the boys must've just left it on. He quickly took off his sneakers, and slid off his shorts and jockstrap. He threw his towel over his shoulder, and headed over to the showers. What he saw next he would've never have expected, he saw Puck fucking Matt underneath one of the shower heads.
Ever since Puck and Finn team fucked Matt earlier in the week, both he and Matt couldn't get enough. Matt kept longing for more than just sex, but Puck never gave him more than just a "thank-you for the good time" slap on the ass when he was done.
Mr. Shue thought quickly, ran back to his locker, grabbed his cell phone, and went back to start taking pictures that he could use later to blackmail either boy if he decided to quit glee club. He took quite a few, before heading back to put his cell phone back. He was in such a hurry, he didn't realize that his cock was getting hard.
He decided that it was his duty as a teacher to break it up, so he was headed over to the showers when he met Puck leaving the showers with a big smile on his face. Puck was still semi-hard from the fucking, but judging by the smile on his face Mr. Shue knew that he must've just filled Matt's hole with his man seed.
"Hey Mr. Shue," Puck said, as he checked out his naked body. "Looks like you're excited to take your shower," he said, nodding toward Mr. Shue's hard cock. "Remember, no whacking off in school, unless you want me to punish you."
Will just shrugged him off and he entered the showers. Matt was washing himself off, and he looked pretty upset. Will thought that was odd, and thought that maybe the sex between Matt and Puck wasn't as consensual as it should be.
Will tried to think about something else to make his cock soften, but nothing seemed like it would work. He finally gave up, and turned on the shower a few down from where Matt was.
"Hey Matt, how's it going?" Will asked, concerned.
Matt was embarrassed by his boner he still had from Puck fucking him, and tried to hide it. He turned his body away from Mr. Shue and said, "good, just a long, hard practice."
"You don't have to be ashamed about your erection, we all get them sometimes. Look, I have one myself. I know what it's like after a hard work out to get the blowing flowing down there," Will said trying to help Matt feel better. He took a step toward Matt and patted the student on his shoulder, and tried to change the subject, "How are things going with Sue?"
Matt reluctantly turned to face his teacher in the showers. He was surprised on how hot his teacher looked naked, and instantly thought Mr. Shue's cock was beautiful. He never would've thought he would be in this situation, but since he was, he wanted so bad to touch his teacher's hard dick. He knew that would never happen though.
Will noticed Matt checking him out, and jokingly said, "My eyes are up here, Matt."
Matt instantly blushed and quickly went back to facing the wall.
Will chuckled and said, "I was only kidding Matt, it's perfectly normal to check out what other guys have in the locker room. And besides, from the looks of it, we seem to be about the same size. Just try to be a little more discreet next time."
Matt couldn't believe it, but his cock got even harder from talking about cock sizes with his teacher.
"Thanks Mr. Shue. I don't have a dad at home, so I'm sometimes a little lost when it comes to stuff like that."
"No problem, Matt. If you ever need to talk about anything, you know I'm here for you."
After a few moments of mindless conversation, both of their cocks softened. Matt finally built up the nerve to talk to Mr. Shue about his newly founded feelings.
"Hey, Mr. Shue, have you ever had weird thoughts, that you can't exactly explain and can't get rid of?" Matt questioned shyly.
"What do you mean?" Will asked, confused.
"I've been having these feelings about...umm..." Matt started to confess, but he struggled to find his words. He never admitted outloud about his attractions to men, and to do it, naked, in front of his teacher only furthered his embarrassment.
Mr. Shue didn't know what to do, but tried to his best to comfort him without getting too close, since they were both naked. He put one hand around his shoulder, and tried his best to not let their lower halves connect. Matt, really longing for someone to connect with, turned into Will's arms and wrapped his arms around his back.
Will was uncomfortable that their cocks were now touching, but didn't want to make Matt feel any worst. So, he just put his other arm around Matt, and tried desperately to not get a boner. Matt, however, wasn't trying at all, and was quickly back up to his seven-inches.
After a few moments, Matt composed himself and he whispered in Mr. Shue's ear, "I think I'm gay."
Will separated himself, keeping his hands on Matt's shoulders, and said while looking him in the eyes, "and that's perfectly okay. You're at a point in your life that you will start to find out more about yourself, including your sexuality. It's important to remember to keep an open mind, but also, to always practice safe sex. And never forget to not throw your body around like it doesn't matter, sex is more than just physical attraction, it's about sharing something with someone you love."
Mr. Shue, after not getting any from his wife lately, was starting to get hard again. Matt noticed, and thought he would try to find out more about his glee club teacher.
"You never answered my question Mr. Shue, have you ever had these thoughts too?" Matt asked, trying to come across as shy and vulnerable.
Mr. Shue hesitated, then finally said, "First off, you need to understand that just because you are attracted to someone sexually, it doesn't mean you love them. I have never loved a man, but yes, I have experimented with another male before."
"Like what?" Matt said, while soaping up his cock and balls.
"I don't think that's the best idea to discuss now, with our current situation," Mr. Shue said, while grabbing his crotch. "I'm already hard enough, and I don't even know when the next time I'll be able to take care of this."
Mr. Shue was already regretting letting this conversation get this far. He already crossed the line with Finn, and he certainly didn't want to do anything that would jeopardize his teaching career. However, he didn't want Matt to think that he was getting nervous because of his new confessions. He decided he would quickly finish his shower.
Matt, didn't want to come across too strong, but figured he had nothing to lose, so he said, "you can just take care of it here. I've done it plenty of times after practice when no one else is around. Maybe I could even help."
"No, I really don't think that'd be a good idea, you're a student. If someone were to walk in, I could lose my job," Mr. Shue said.
"Don't worry, everyone went home, and the janitors don't come until late at night," Matt said, already slowly jacking off his cock.
"Tell you what, let's finish our showers, and I'll give you a ride home," Mr. Shue said with a wink.
Matt and Mr. Shue quickly turned off their water, went back to their lockers and got dressed. Mr. Shue didn't bother putting on underwear. In a matter of minutes, they both were ready, and were walking out to his car.
Once they were in the car, Matt instantly took his hard cock out of his jeans and started to jack off. He reached over and started to feel Mr. Shue's dick through his slacks. Because Mr. Shue wasn't wearing any underwear, his boner was super obvious. Mr. Shue looked down and could already see a little pre-cum stain mark forming on his pants.
"Do me a favor and take it out. I don't' want to stain my pants with my pre-cum Matt," Mr. Shue told his student while turning a corner. He knew a place a little off the road that was plenty secluded.
Matt did so, and instantly started jacking off his teacher. "Woah there buddy, how about a little spit for lube," his teacher instructed. Matt was uncut, and rarely used lube to jack off. He took this as an invitation to use his spit as lube, and instantly swallowed all of Mr. Shue's cock in his mouth.
Matt has been practicing sucking Puck's dick before Puck would fuck him, so he got to be pretty good. He used one hand to play with Mr. Shue's heavy balls, and used the other hand to balance himself as he was leaning over in the car. Due to his lack of sex, it wasn't long before he reached the point of no return, "Matt, I'm gonna cum," Mr. Shue moaned.
Matt didn't stop, he kept sucking down until he had all of Mr. Shue's member in his mouth. Mr. Shue was still driving, but quickly pulled over just as he started to lose control and shoot his load. Matt tried his best to swallow all of it, but it started to leak out down to Mr. Shue's balls. Matt took his mouth off of his cock, took a big breath and said, "sorry I couldn't swallow it all Mr. Shue, but I'll lick it up for you." Matt licked all around Mr. Shue's crotch until every ounce of cum was gone.
Mr. Shue was in a daze. That was some much needed head he just got. Though, after a few moments, he remembered what he said earlier to Matt about not just having sex with whoever, but rather with someone special, so he decided he wanted to make Matt feel like this was more than just sex.
He lifted up Matt's head to his, and gently started to kiss him. Mr. Shue opened his mouth to let Matt's tongue in, and the taste of his own cum flooded his mouth.
He pushed Matt away, "I'm sorry, but I really should get you home, someone might see us."
Matt understood, and tried to stuff his own cock back in his pants.
"Hey Matt," Mr. Shue said, causing Matt to look back at his teacher. "This really shouldn't have happened. You're a great guy, and I'm sure you'll find someone to explore these feelings with more that is your own age. And I'm not sure exactly what's going on with you and Puck, but I'm not sure he's the right one for the job."
"Thanks Mr. Shue. I understand" Matt said, then started to give Mr. Shue directions to his house.
"Hey Puck, can you stay after class, there is something I need to talk to you about," Mr. Shue asked Puck as the students were leaving the classroom after a glee rehearsal a few days later.
Puck entered Mr. Shue's office, and sat down and asked, "What's up Mr. Shue?"
"I thought I warned you Puck, no inappropriate actions on school grounds. We really can't afford to lose you if you get suspended or expelled. But also, we especially can't have our most feared glee club member turning gay on us" Mr. Shue said while walking over to the office door and locking it. "Now, it's time for you to learn a lesson."
"What the hell are you talking about, I honestly haven't whacked off on campus since that day. And what do you mean turning gay? I get more pussy than any other guy in this school."
"I have proof that you have been having homosexual relations in the locker room showers earlier this week," Mr. Shue said, trying to intimidate the cocky student.
"First off, I don't know what the hell you're talking about. Secondly, I'm a badass. I can fuck whoever I want," Puck defended himself.
Mr. Shue sat down at his desk, and started clicking around his computer. He e-mailed the pictures he took from his camera to himself, and now had them on a slideshow on his computer.
"Come look at these Puck," Mr. Shue said.
Puck walked around his desk, and instantly recognized the scene on the computer.
"Oh shit, how did you..." Puck started to say.
"It doesn't matter how. But now, about that punishment," Mr. Shue said, already rubbing his dick that was already getting hard. "I know you were just using Matt. Using someone that was vulnerable for your sexual pleasures isn't right, Puck. Now, I'm going to give you a taste of your own medicine."
"No. I won't let you. Besides, you do this, and I tell Principal Figgins, and you're fired," Puck tried to sound confident, but the bulge in Mr. Shue's pants was starting to look pretty big, and if anyone knew that a guy with a boner will do anything to put it in a hole, it was Puck.
"You wouldn't dare. It would get out to the school that you let your glee club teacher stick his dick up your ass," Mr. Shue said, getting face to face with Puck. "Now, get on your knees, and make it convincing that you want your teacher's cock."
Puck couldn't see a way out of it, and was soon on his knees, unzipping his teacher's pants. He slowly slide down his pants, leaving Mr. Shue in just his Calvin Klein briefs and his button down shirt. Puck started to outline his teacher's hard tool with his tongue through his briefs, and lifted his hand up his shirt and rubbed Mr. Shue's defined abs.
After a couple of minutes, Puck started to slowly peel down the briefs, freeing Mr. Shue's seven inch cock. He instantly started to suck the head of the penis. Puck has gotten plenty of blow jobs in his life, but has never given one, and was surprised on how tired his jaw was after only taking half of the dick in his mouth.
Mr. Shue could sense that Puck was getting tired, and decided it was time to really get the lesson started.
"Now Puck," Mr. Shue said while playing with his Mohawk, "now it's time to really pound this lesson into you. Turn around."
"Please Mr. Shue, no. I promise, I'll do anything. I'll even swallow," Puck pleaded.
"Like you promised no more funny business at school? Turn around, and I'll go easy," Mr. Shue said, while grabbing some lube that he kept in his desk.
Puck lowered his pants and underwear around his ankles, and leaned his upper body against Mr. Shue's desk, exposing his hairless asshole.
"Wow Puck, you really do shave everywhere, don't you?" Mr. Shue asked, already starting to slowly slide one of his fingers in Puck's asshole.
Puck didn't answer, but just moaned. Mr. Shue took that as a sign that he could add another finger.
After a few minutes of loosening up the hole, Mr. Shue was ready to enter into his student's ass.
"Here comes the lesson boy," Mr. Shue warned his student. He slowly slid in his head, then some of his shaft, then slid it back out. He did this continuously until Puck's moans of pain seemed to turn into ones of pleasure, and his asshole seemed to loosed it's clench around Will's cock.
Mr. Shue started to pick up the speed, really ramming his cock in the virgin asshole.
"Now Puckerman," Mr. Shue said, while slapping his ass, "do you think you understand why this isn't acceptable?"
Once again, Puck didn't answer, but just moaned. He was still afraid that if he opened his mouth, he might yell in pain or pleasure, he wasn't sure at this point.
The virgin ass felt great to Mr. Shue, and the fact he was in total control, fucking the school bully, was really turning him on. It wasn't long before he was about to shoot his load.
He quickly pulled out his cock and aimed it right at Puck's hole. "Here it comes," Mr. Shue moaned, and he jizzed all over Puck's sweet ass.
"Now, I hope I never see you do anything like this at this school again," Mr. Shue said while slapping Puck's ass one last time.
Be sure to e-mail me if you're liking the stories. Also, if you have any pics/videos of either the guys of glee, or maybe something to inspire a story, let me know. Sorry this one even longer than the others. I'm really busy with summer vacation. :]