He Stole My Heart

By John Nail

Published on May 21, 2018

Gay

I would love to hear comments at slutbttm4u@yahoo.com

We got up in the morning and I decided it was time for me to get in the shower. Mike said," You know we could have showered together."

Now it was my turn to flip the table and surprise him.

As I walked by I rubbed his crotch and said," I might have to take you up on that offer."

The shock in his eyes was priceless when he said," Really, or are you joking?"

I smiled and said," You will have to keep this friendship to find out."

I walked in and turned on the fan then the water in the shower. I chuckled how I surprised Mike then I quit laughing was all of a sudden wondering what kind of feelings was I getting for Mike. Was I really falling in love with him me a straight man?

I finished up lathering myself up then I went over to the sink and shaved and then started drying myself off and after I put the deodorant on I walked out of the bathroom.

Mike asked," Were you just joking?"

I took a deep breath and said," Partly but to be honest I am getting some feelings for you I am not sure about so we will have to appreciate the friendship we have for now. If I know I do have deeper feelings for you I will tell you because I will admit meeting you has got me questioning my sexuality or sexual preference or whatever you want to call it."

Mike looked at me and said," Wow, I have heard of this happening but didn't think this would happen with me. But I do love our friendship."

I said," Me too, I don't usually feel this comfortable with anybody this quick."

Mike said," Let's get ready and go eat breakfast because it is getting mushy in here and I might grab you and start kissing you."

I looked at him and said," Ya and I probably won't turn you down at the moment."

Mike laughed and said," I get it you are joking with me."

I said at least half seriously," We will have to stay friends in order for you to find out."

We went downstairs and sat down and looked at the menus.

As we were looking he cleared his throat and said," Excuse me, this is new territory for me not being gay but someone questioning their sexual preference for me. You aren't playing with my heart are you."

I paused for a minute and said," To be honest with you, I started questioning my sexual preference the first day we me When I first saw you I couldn't keep my eyes off of you and there is a part of me that wants to act on it and have your hands all over me and finding out what your lips feel like if I kiss you. The only thing that is stopping me is asking myself if I regret it and so what we will have to do is retain our new friendship and see where it goes from here. If we do fall for each other I know I won't resist but let's not force it OK. "

He smiled and grabbed my hand and gave me a big bro hug and said," You know that is the best answer I can look for from you at this time. For now, this friendship is wonderful to go with."

He said," You want to see my fishing boat?"

I said," Ya."

He took out his wallet and flipped through the pics and got to his boat.

Af first I laughed and said," You are a typical guy aren't you. You have a pic of your fishing boat."

He laughed and said," You flip back you will see my gun collection."

I laughed and said," You are really trying to make me fall in love with you aren't you." I looked at it and said," How big?"

He said," 19 foot I got a great deal but I had to do a lot of work on the motor."

I said," Well, I am impressed and can't wait to go fishing on it."

Our breakfast arrived at our table and we started to eat and if you were at another table you wouldn't know one man was gay and the other one was questioning his sexuality.

As we were eating he said," We have driven for about a total of 8 hours I think we should arrive at my ex-boyfriend's house by lunch or if we choose a little after lunch. I think we should be there in 4 or maybe 5 hours I think."

I said," Cool."

He said," You might change your mind once you meet him."

I said," If he doesn't pick up a plate I should be fine."

Mike snickered and said," Wow, you sure put a low standard don't you."

I laughed and said," I learned about dealing with exs not my own."

He laughed and said," Fair enough."

Before we knew it time flew by and we made it to town and Mike asked," Are you hungry?"

I said," As a matter of fact I am."

We stopped at this restaurant and walked in and the hostess sat us down.

As Mike looked at the menu he said," You know after lunch the fireworks will start Jody is a real drama queen."

I said," That is the first time I heard you call him by name."

He said," That just shows you hostile the breakup was."

The waitress came over and said," MIKE I can't believe it is you where have you been?"

He said," Oh, Rochelle I moved to Bozeman. Are the prime ribs still as good ever?"

She said," Dearie yes they are."

He said," Bring John and I two prime rib lunches."

She asked," You want baked potatoes or fries."

Mike said," Bring me your baked potato."

I said," The same. and salad with blue cheese dressing."

Mike said," Salad with blue cheese dressing."

She took our orders and left.

I said," You lied to her."

He said," I know, that is because I am well known in this town and when we leave here I don't want word getting back to Jody. I have been to Bozeman and I know how big it is and he will waste a lot of time trying to figure out where exactly."

I asked," You think he will try to find you?"

He said," I know he might try to and I don't want to take a chance."

I laughed and said," Now, I will be exposed to a deranged ex-boyfriend wow I am lucky."

He laughs and says," First an ex-girlfriend and now my ex-boyfriend you attract them."

We both laughed at our statement knowing what we were in for.

The waitress came with our order and she asked," Wow who is your friend."

He said," John but it doesn't matter we won't be coming back after I get my boat." She asked," Do you know he is gay?" I said," Yes, he did and we are friends it doesn't bother me. Heck, we will be going fishing."

She snorted and said," Ya, he will probably pop that ass of yours.'

I feigned surprise and said," I didn't know many women's minds going to the gutter that fast. We both like fishing and other outdoor activities. When you go with a female friend does it always mean you will be using a dildo on each other?"

The look of anger on her face was priceless as she spun around to give our order. He laughed and said," You sure put that slut in her place. When I say slut believe me she is. I couldn't have done better myself."

We slapped high 5s with each other laughing.

Our orders came with a different waitress.

She said," I am sorry for Rochelle she is still mad you turning her down."

Mike said," Even if I was straight I wouldn't touch that I know she probably has every V.D, known to man."

She laughed until she had tears in her eyes and said," You are right."

Mike said," Thanks, Lucy."

I said," I am impressed."

He laughed and said," Don't be I grew up here and I was a regular in this restaurant."

I said," OK I got your point."

Twenty minutes later our order came and this time the manager came.

He said," Mike I am sorry for Rochelle she is terminated."

Mike said," Oh don't fire her that was entertainment especially with how my friend John handled it. Don't fire her please she probably won't do that anybody else."

The manager said," OK Mike if you insist but she will be on probation."

We finished our meal lunch and paid for it and headed to the pickup.

As we drove to the house Mike said," Let the fun begin."

I said," Let's go for it."

I asked," How long did it take this town to figure out you are He said," Probably about 2 years after high school people started to put 2 and 2 together and most of this town came to peace with it. Now, most of my friends didn't come to peace with the fact I was with Jody Jody is like you falling head over heels with a skank and everybody knows it except you."

I said," Well, I understand you exactly so looks like skanks come in either sex."

He laughed and said," They sure do." We got out and Mike said," Shit looks like Jody's dom's car is in the way of the boat."

We approached the house and Mike rang the bell.

A slender very feminine looking man answered the door and Mike said," Jody I came for my boat."

Jody said," I gave it to Rick."

Mike said," You know damn well that isn't your boat to give because I had that boat before we got together. Why don't you move your prick's car out of the way or I will move it out of the way myself."

Jody sighed and asked me," Is Mike fucking you now?"

I wrapped my arm around Mike's arm and said," I am neither confirming or denying if he is because it is none of your concern since you opened your ass for Rick behind Mike's back."

You could see Jody going into a silent rage with that response and he huffed out and moved Rick's car.

Mike laughed and said," That was entertaining to watch you sure know how to put sluts in their place. Besides I didn't tell you Jody and Rochelle are friends."

I said," I am not surprised sluts have to stick together."

Mike said," Indeed they do."

Jody came back and said," Rick isn't going to be happy but you can get your shitty little boat."

We went out and I spotted Mike back to his boat and lowered it to his hitch and secured it plugged the lights to the trailer to the truck and secured the safety chains to the hitch.

I jumped in and Mike said," Are we all ready?"

I said," Yes we are."

He said," Great, now we have to go to the grocery store."

I asked," Why?"

He said," A friend of mine has a cabin by the lake and he said I can stay anytime just make sure it is cleaned up before we leave and bring our own food."

I said," Sweet" We drove to the grocery store and he had the truck and boat parked in a way that he didn't have to back out and we started walking into the store.

As we got to the doors there was a voice calling for Mike.

We turned around and Mike said," Yes."

The man got so close you could see their chests almost touching.

The man said," I don't know if you realize it but I don't like Jody touching my car."

Mike smiled and said," You may be able to get away with bossing around your little slut but that doesn't go for me. I came back for my boat."

Rick said," Who says that boat belongs to you?"

Mike was still smiling and brought out a title and said," This title says its mine I got it out of my safe deposit box before coming here. Now, if you don't want to get hurt I suggest you step aside I am not Jody." Rick said," Well, you could have waited for me to return home."

Mike said," I was surprised you weren't your car was there. I saw your car after I came back out it wasn't damaged so everything is good."

Rick said," I don't like things done behind my back."

Mike was smiling and said," If you don't step aside I will kick your ass while you are facing me, will that make you feel better?"

The man stepped aside without saying a word and we went inside. I said," I was a little afraid there was going to be a fight."

Mike said," Oh, I wasn't there was a bully in school just like him and you faced him cool like that he would back down in a hurry. You see he is just good at intimidating when you face one down you are able to quickly spot them."

I said," OK I have faced a bully but I actually had to fight him."

We got our groceries and as we were getting the last of the groceries rang up the manager came smiling and gave Mike a big hug.

Mike said," We used to play football together. This ugly guy is Steve."

Steve said," This is coming from a guy who decided to live with a slut."

Mike said," Touche."

Steve said," I heard a lughead and his friend was making waves in this town and I knew it had to be you. So what are you doing besides causing trouble?"

Mike said," I came to get my boat and then John and I will do some fishing before heading home."

Steve asked," Where is home?" Mike said," You aren't telling Jody?" Steve said," Are you kidding me? After you put Rick in his place?"

Mike said," How do you know that?"

Steve grinned and pointed to the monitor and said," You were on camera. Just no audio."

Mike said," Ya that prick tried to intimidate me over Jody moving his car out of the way of my boat and hell he tried to claim the boat was his until I showed him the title. I am living in Livingston now Rochelle thinks I live in Bozeman."

Steve said," You have your bases covered don't you." Mike said," I learned with Jody you have to."

Steve said," Good point."

Steve said to me," You have a good friend in Mike there."

We grabbed the purchases and headed to the truck.

I asked," Did you ever fuck him?"

He said," No he is happily married."

After we got the groceries in the cooler in the back of the truck and we climbed in Mike turned to me.

He said," Steve did suck my cock some before he got married and he did swallow and he said he loved the taste of my cum."

I couldn't contain myself I laughed so hard I had tears in my eyes.

He said," I gave him my phone number if he is ever in Livingston. Since he has sucked my cock I know he will keep his mouth shut about where I live when it comes to Rochelle."

I asked," Why won't he say that?"

Mike said," Well, that fact he finds embarrassing for some reason now So just keep that bit of information between us."

I said," My lips are sealed."

As we drove I saw that I was definitely getting feelings for Mike and still wasn't sure if I was in love with him.

We got to the cabin and backed the truck and boat up and we got out and we headed into the cabin.

We started to put the stuff away and that took some time

We looked at the time and it was already 6 and Mike said," Why don't we make some dinner and clean up and go to bed early tonight like 9 and eat breakfast and hit the lake by 7?"

I said," Sure that sounds good."

I sliced up a tomato while he cooked the hamburger patties on the stove and heated up the buns and cooked the fries.

Within a half hour to 45 minutes the fries were done and we were topping the burgers putting mayo on the buns and ketchup and lettuce."

He got out 2 beers and we sat down for dinner.

He said," You know when I came to Livingston I didn't know how long it would take me to make friends. But then you were mowing your yard and we became pretty fast friends."

I said," You seemed like you would make a good friend."

He asked," Do I still make a good friend?"

I smiled and said," More than you know.". We ate dinner and cleaned up everything and we sat down on the 2 recliners.

I was sitting in mine for about a half hour in deep thought when Mike yelled for me I guess 3 times.

He said," Hey, what you thinking about?"

I said," Nothing much just my feelings for you. I can't put my finger on it and I am not sure but I may be falling for you. I am not rushing into it but like when we were at Jody's house and I wrapped my arm in yours just to irritate him it felt a little comfortable and I never thought before today that I could feel this comfortable with sharing an arm with another guy. Don't count us an item yet just something to think about."

Mike looked at me with surprise and asked," How long have you been thinking about this?""

I said," Off and on since we have been on this trip. Like at the motel I had a waking moment where I was tempted to crawl into bed with you. Not necessarily have sex mind you but to cuddle up with you and I have never felt this way about a man before. I am not going to rush this friendship relationship but I will not fight it either if our relationship does evolve into something more than just friendship."

Mike said," You were serious when you said you are questioning your sexual preference."

I said," Yes, I am and I am afraid if I don't rush this I will make a big mistake."

Mike kneeled on one knee in front of me and he took my hand and said," Don't you worry we won't rush this, for now, we will just be friends and we won't sleep together in the same bed."

He got up and he leaned forward and kissed my forehead and said," We have a very unique friendship." I nodded and said," Yes, we do."

He went back to his recliner and he smiled reassuringly at me.

He said," To be honest with you I have been wanting to sleep with you and to snuggle and maybe make love to you. I resisted that temptation."

I didn't say it to him but the fact he wanted to make love to me was like music to my ears.

Before we knew it, it was 9 and I found one bedroom and he found another and he looked at me.

He said," Good night dear."

I said," Good night hun."

I went in and stripped to my underwear and crawled into bed.

I laid there contemplating everything and well I didn't know it for sure but yes I was falling in love with Mike and before I knew it I was going to be in his arms. After about 45 minutes of thinking about my feelings for him I finally fell asleep.

l

Next: Chapter 4


Rate this story

Liked this story?

Nifty is entirely volunteer-run and relies on people like you to keep the site running. Please support the Nifty Archive and keep this content available to all!

Donate to The Nifty Archive
Nifty

© 1992, 2024 Nifty Archive. All rights reserved

The Archive

About NiftyLinks❤️Donate