This story is about m/m consensual sex between guys of the high school age. If this is inappropriate for you or the subject matter offends you, please go ahead and skip.
There has been some confusion since the last chapter, and I did make a few clerical errors, so I'm going to clarify. I made the mistake of saying the numbing lube came from Matt's brother and from Mr. D, and it did in fact come from Mr. D along with the butt plug that was given to Tony at the end of the chapter. I know that a few of the other facts seem to be a little strange, but there is a reason for it. These next 3 chapters are to give a closer look into the fun that each of them can get into together without being part of a group.
Please help donate to Nifty if you can.
Chapter 9
It was strange walking around feeling something pressing up against that spot inside me that sent tingles throughout my body all throughout the next day. All day it felt like I should take it out, but Matt had already told me it would take some time to get used to, but would make it easier on all of us, he did specifically say he meant me. He had also given me a list of instructions on how to maintain things, I guess is the best way to put it.
Lunch had Finally arrived, and we were all sitting together eating the crappy school pizza, joking around as we always did. Which celebrity would everyone else bang? Of course my answer was a tad different from what the others were, even made Todd have water shoot out of his nose. He laughed so hard. He gave me a wink, and the way he looked at me I made the connection that they had decided, and it was his night. I still was bewildered that all of our parents had decided to allow us to have sleepovers during the week, but considering their grades, and my failures in gym, I guess it wasn't that far of a jump. But after that initial wink, it was back to the conversation as usual. Though, Todd did dare Matt to jump on the table, take his shirt off, and do jumping jacks, which he did without hesitation, giving us all another round of raucous laughter. A warning glare from a nearby teacher did curb our enthusiasm.
Then there was the dreaded bell. Todd and I gave each other the same eye roll, fuckin math. We all took our trays to the trash, and Todd and I separated to head to class. "May I ask you a question?" Todd asked. "That is a question, would you like to ask another?" I said with my best sarcastic tone that awarded me with an annoyed look. I chuckled, and responded, "Of course you can." He looked around to see if anyone was nearby and asked, "Are you still wearing it?" It did take me a second, but I realized what he meant, and I nodded. "Cool." was his only response. After another few seconds of walking he said, "Okay, now a serious question. Do you really understand what she is talking about? I see numbers and letters, and I'm lost." Another laugh as we entered our classroom. "I do, in fact." I responded.
That and the rest of the classes passed fairly quickly. I was chucking my things into my bag after gym when I heard, "This is the boy's changing room, why are you here?" I closed my eyes to prepare myself, turned around, got met with a punch to the face courtesy of Roy's fist. It hurt like hell, but I was gonna try my best not to let him see it. I looked him straight in the eye, before I could say a word, he was on the ground, though he had landed on me, with us both ending up on the ground. Todd was standing over us, angrier than I had ever seen him. "Leave. Him. Alone!" He bit off each word.
He held a hand out for me to take, which I did, and suddenly I was standing beside him, Roy was still on the floor. We both walked out of the room, and without hesitation he gave me a friendly bump on the shoulder.
Todd suggested we take a walk through the park instead of our normal path to his house. I couldn't tell if he was just trying to avoid studying math, or if he was still wound up from defending me. We always walked these paths when we wanted to waste time, especially on the weekends when our parents thought we were being supervised at one another's houses. He joked for a bit, all jokes I'd heard before but I let him tell as if it was the first time I'd heard them. Then just in silence for a bit. We found ourselves at the end of the pier on the creek that we usually ended at.
I found myself looking out at the trees and the light reflecting off of the water. Suddenly he was behind me, and I could feel a very prominent bulge pressing against my ass. "I dare you to let me fuck you right here." he whispered to me. I turned my head to look at him, and the back of my pants had already been pulled down to expose my ass. It was his night, and I'd be damned if I was gonna chicken out of a dare. I'm guessing my smirk gave him his answer, as he pulled the plug out of my ass, causing a gasp.
It was very quickly replaced by that hard cock I had just felt pushing against my pants. I was feeling a rush of emotions at once. First and foremost was that even though the plug warmed being inside me, it paled in comparison to feeling my friend pushing his pulsing cock into me. I moaned loudly, and after a quick chuckle, Todd said, "While we're out here that's fine, but you really can't make that when we're pretending to study." The entire time he was talking his cock was sliding further and further into me. I nodded my head, and even though I felt another moan rising in my throat, I stifled it.
Todd was slowly pulling out, and while it did leave an empty space, his cock quickly filled it again. I turned my head to the sunset falling in front of us. Standing here feeling one of my best friends fuck me in public made me feel something I'd never felt before. A mixture of embarrassment and horniness. I felt myself pushing back with each of his thrusts, and I'll admit a few moans escaped, and somehow my pants had ended up at my ankles. We kept going, and then it happened.
We heard two girls laughing and quickly heading our way, but even before we had started this, we knew the path to take. As usual we headed to jump over the railing, and of course my pants gave me a slight stumble. I pulled them up, jumped over the railing, and was now in knee deep water. Todd pulled me under the docks where we frequently hid to listen to people(for him girls, for me to be with him). While he was looking up to see if they were above us yet, I noticed that his hard cock was still sticking up. So, I wanted he help him out, and I began leaning down, but I'm guessing he noticed my movement and stopped me.
With a finger to his lips, he said "Shhh, turn around, and look up for the drama." I realized he wanted to resume where we had started, and it was a dare. I turned around, leaned over grabbing one of the posts holding the pier up, and my pants slid down on their own since I hadn't zipped up. He was immediately back inside me, and above us I heard the flip flops of girls walking above us. Now was really gonna be a trial for me to keep quiet. He kept hitting that spot with his seemingly perfectly shaped cock. I heard a distinct click of a camera, and my focus was instantly trying to see if they had found us. But the sound had come from behind me, and they were still talking.
Todd had taken a picture. I felt my face flush, and I wasn't sure if it was more embarrassment, or anger. He gave his trademark smirk, showed me a picture of his thick cock in my ass, and nothing more. He leaned down while slowly pulling and pushing out of me. "I only wanted it for myself, but I don't want you to feel uncomfortable. Would you like me to delete it?" I could tell he was sincere, and he had taken on a guy almost twice his size because he hit me first.
"For You only." I whispered. He smiled, and his cock picked up speed, going in and out. I felt him swell, and I could feel he was pulsing inside me, and I did in fact notice some of it floating in the water after it had flowed down my leg. He pulled out of me, and then without a second's break, I felt that plug pushed back inside me. As I turned to look at him and pulled my pants up, he shrugged his shoulders and said quietly, "I Have to learn math later. We're both gonna be bored." We both gave a silent chuckle with each other, and settled into the water to wait for the girls above to leave, as we always had to.