It Couldnt Be True

By Joe Gutierrez

Published on Mar 2, 2012

Gay

Disclaimer: If you are not 18 you shouldn't be here, but you know how it goes. All places, people and events are fictional. Nothing of the sort ever happened. And all sexual acts are complete fiction. If you are looking for a quick get off story you are looking at the wrong story. This is a long term relationship between two boys.

This is my first time ever writing a story. So please bear with me at times thanks :)

I was sixteen years old. It was a cool October day. My friend James and I were watching some dumb YouTube videos. Such as "Dumbass winter drivers", Ha! I tell you some people are so dumb when it comes to driving in snow and ice. So as we were getting a bit bored with the videos, we decided to to head over to the mall. We walked around a bit and were looking at some of the shoes at Champs and Foot Locker.

Then James said "Let's go to the Cinnabon by the Sears, those cinnamon rolls are too good."

James is 16 5'7" slightly long light brown hair, kinda curls up at the ends. He's really cute, he also has blue eyes. I had a crush on him for several years since we first met in the 6th grade.

So we walked over to the Cinnabon and we ordered what we wanted. Then we sat on the bench over by the Sunglass Hut. We were sitting there eating and talking about muscle cars and trucks when this really hot girl came over and started talking to us. She paid a little more attention to James than me. Not that I'm not cute or anything, I'm 5'7 really short dark brown hair and charcoal eyes. So the girl made her way between us and sat down with her back towards me which kinda made me mad. She was talking to James and while she was talking to him James kept looking at me over her shoulder.

The girl said " Hey so whats your name?" James told her his name and she said "Oh that's a cute name it really fits you, so... do you wanna maybe hang out later, maybe go see a movie?" James had a chance to be with a really hot girl, and go see a movie and possibly get a kiss out of it.

James replied to her question with a simple "No thank you."

Both the girl and I looked at James with a confused look. She replied hastily " Why not? Aren't I hot enough for you?... Or are you some sort or faggot?"

Then James said "Yes I am."

I looked at him in disbelief. And wondered to myself, is he really? Or is he just trying to shoo her away? Then he looked at me over the girl's shoulder and gave me an evil grin. I couldn't figure out what it meant. The girl stood up and yelled at him with some foul language. And walk away pissed off.

When the girl left, I asked James in a low voice " Is it true?... Are you... gay?" He looked at me with a sad look and grabbed my arm and pulled me through Sears out the entrance out to my truck and said "Get in".

I opened unlocked the doors and we got in. He started crying, which is very unlike him. He never cries, so that's when I realized he was serious.

I asked "Dude, why are you crying?" in a concerned voice and hugged him and held him tight.

He looked up at me helplessly with teared up eyes and said " Because Joe... I'm ... g-g-g-g-gay." His voice was so shaky. "Please don't be mad, It's just..." His voice trailed off. " I don't want to hide it from you anymore."

"Dude I'm not mad, not at all." I added quickly.

"You aren't?" He asked with a confused look.

"No, because... I think... I'm gay too." I squeaked.

"Really?" He asked happily.

"Yeah, I kinda been crushing on you since I met you" I said.

"Dude, I really can't believe it. I've had a crush on you too." James added.

We hugged for a few moments... he started sobbing. "What?s wrong?" I asked.

"Well... it's just... I have always wished that you were gay too, and now it came true. Now I have somebody to talk to about all this, somebody that will understand how I feel. Not everybody is welcoming to a person being gay. I know if my dad found out..." He took a deep breath. " ... he would probably kick my ass."

When James said that about his dad, I was crushed because I knew his dad. It was true, he would kick his ass. I tried my best to comfort him. I told him that his dad won't have to find out. It will be a secret forever. I was wrong. I asked James if he would like to get something to eat and sit and talk in the truck. He agreed happily. I started up my Ramcharger. God I loved that truck. It was Black and Grey two tone. It had straight pipes and sounded like a monster. I had KC lights all over the truck on top and in the front of the truck. So I asked him what he would like to eat. He mentioned Lotaburger which is a burger joint, with the best burgers in town. I agreed and we sped off. The ride over was quite, none of us mentioned a word. As we pulled in to the drive thru I asked him what he wanted.

He replied "I would like a Lota Combo and a Dr. Pepper."

I got the same. He reached for his wallet and I told him that I would pay for him, he tried refusing but I had already paid for the food. We went over and parked under an old oak tree in the parking lot. I shut off the truck, but left it in accessory mode. I searched through my iPod playlists and put on some soft rock music. We ate and he asked me what my mom would say to all of this.

I replied "I don't know, I hope she is ok with it, I mean she has to be ok with it. What can she do throw me out over this."

"Well I don't know what my dad is going to say, you know he hates gay people with a passion. He is always calling them queers and no good for nothing perverts." James said.

I could see the hurt in his eyes.

"Every time he mentions something bad about gay guys it hurts. I always think, what would he have to say about me? Is he going to call me a worthless FAGGOT?"

He broke down into tears. I pulled him over the center counsel and hugged him in tight, showing him the love I had for him. He turned to look at me with those blue eyes and he stared at me for a few seconds and asked "Do you love me Joe?"

"Yes I do James -- with all my heart; I will never let anything happen to you. I will kill for you James." I said while a stray tear fell down my cheek. He smiled and said ?I love you too Joe! I will never leave your side."

"James if anything happens between you and your Dad I will be there! I won't ever let him hurt you in any way!"

"Thank you Joe, that means a lot!" We sat there huddled up together, just enjoying each other's embrace. I looked into his gorgeous blue eyes and we both stared into each other's eyes for a few minutes. We both moved in and our lips touched. He then parted his lips and felt his tongue touch my lips. I parted mine. I had never kissed anybody but kissing him felt like total instinct. I believe he felt the same way. We lip locked for about 5 minutes just trying to show each other our total affection. We separated and we both said "THAT WAS AMAZING" in unison. We went in for another kiss that was complete ecstasy. I had never felt so in love in my entire life. We held each other for a few more minutes, and then he said. "I love you so much Joe, I really do!"

"I love you so much too James!" I replied

Then he jumped suddenly with great fear. I asked what the matter was. "My Dad! I was supposed to be home by 5pm. It's 6 o'clock!"

"Why?" I asked. "Because I'm grounded and I wasn't supposed to go anywhere after school. He's going to be sooo mad!"

"Dude why didn't you tell me?"

"Because I wanted to be with you, I love being with you, it makes me so happy to be with you!" He said. I brought him in for a quick kiss. It seemed to calm him down a little. I scooted him over to the passenger seat and fired up my truck and raced to his house. We saw his Dad's Ford Excursion parked in the drive way. I parked on the other side of it. I was about to get off and James told me to stay in side and leave before I see anything bad. I told him "James remember what I told you in the truck earlier? I Love you and I will never let anything happen to you."

"Ok Joe but don't do or say anything that we'll both regret unless you have to." He said. We both walked up the French Doors and we could see him watching NASCAR on the big screen. I saw James's trembling hand reach for the door knob when his Dad just so happened to look at the door and saw us standing there. We both almost shat our pants. He got up off the Lay-z-Boy and stormed to the door. This guy is a big guy standing at around 6'4" and he had a build on him that will scare any MMA fighter shitless.

Ok so here is the first chapter of the story. There is much more to go! But if you would like to send me a comment about the story, if you liked it or not. Write me at sd70ace01@yahoo.com

Next: Chapter 2


Rate this story

Liked this story?

Nifty is entirely volunteer-run and relies on people like you to keep the site running. Please support the Nifty Archive and keep this content available to all!

Donate to The Nifty Archive
Nifty

© 1992, 2024 Nifty Archive. All rights reserved

The Archive

About NiftyLinks❤️Donate