This story is entirely fictional and not intended to imply anything about the sexuality of the real Nick Carter.
The night had started out like all the others had. I got off of work, went to the subway, and of course the subway was broken down. I found a seat on the bench and was waiting for the train to get fixed when I heard a girl screaming. I was the only one in the depot, so I ran to where the scream came from. I saw this girl down on the ground screaming and this tall blonde guy standing over her. I ran and tackled the guy; I got a few hits in before the girl started to tell me to stop.
"Stop, what are you doing?" she asked.
"I thought that this guy was trying to hurt you." I replied.
"Hurt me, no way, this is Nick Carter of the Back Street Boys!" she exclaimed.
I realized that I was still on top of Nick, and I could swear that I felt a boner in my side. I just dismissed it as his keys or something.
"Oh my god, I am so sorry, I did not realize that it was you." I said to Nick.
"That is okay, I know that it could not have looked good, I was just trying to get her.... Wait, where did she go?" he asked.
"I dunno, I am still so sorry about that." I said.
"That is ok, I should go, she might be finding her friends." He said
"Okay." I replied.
As he was walking off I realized what had happened, I had tackled and laid on the hottest guy in the world, and I made a total fool out of myself. I was thinking about what I could do.
"Wait!" I yelled.
Nick stopped and twirled around.
"What?" he asked.
"Since I tackled you and beat you up, let me buy you dinner, it is the least that I can do," I said.
He thought about it for a minute. "Okay, that would be cool, I am hungry."
We walked off when I was thinking about where we were going to eat.
"You know any good restraints?" I asked him.
"No, I am new to town, I can not even find my hotel." He said.
"Well after dinner, let me take you there." I told him.
"Okay, I am so lost around here." He said.
"I think I know a good restaurant, It is called Tony's," I said.
"Okay, I just hope that no one will recognize me." He said as we were walking onto the street.
"Naw, Tony is a friend of mine, and I will just have him put us in the dark back corner." I said.
We got to the restaurant without any problems. WE also got the back corner like I said we would. We ordered our dinner and I tried to start up a conversation.
"So where is the rest of the group?" I asked.
"They are back in the hotel rooms, I went to visit some old relatives, but they were not home, and I got lost going back to the hotel, and ran into that girl. Fans really are starting to get to me." He started.
We talked for a while, and it seemed like we were really hitting it off. It was long after we finished eating that I looked at my watch.
"Hey you realize that it is already 11:30?" I said, "Tony must have forgotten about us."
"Shit...I need to get some sleep, I have a concert tomorrow." He replied.
"Where is your hotel?" I asked him.
"Somewhere on Manhattan." He replied.
"Damn you are a long way from home." I said.
"How long do you think that it will take to get me home?" he asked.
"Well if the subway is running only about three hours." I replied.
"Shit...that is two long, I need some sleep now. Do you have any hotels around here?" Nick asked.
"None that I know of, but I have some extra rooms at my place that you could use." I told him.
"Cool, thanks, I owe you something, first tackling me, then dinner, and now you are letting me use your house." He said jokingly.
"Are you laughing at me?" I asked.
"Yes I am/" Nick replied smugly.
And with that, I had once again tackled him to the ground. We were wrestling around on the floor of Tony's place for a while before I realized where we were.
"Hey wait, we can do this at my house, lets leave Tony's in one piece." I screamed.
"You were just jealous because you were losing." He said laughingly.
We got back to my place, and he called his hotel and told them what was going on. They said that it was all right.
"Okay so where were we at?" he asked.
"I think you had me pinned." I said.
"Naw, you can be on top." He said.
What did he mean by that?
To be continued...