This story includes Seth Cohen (Adam Brody), Ryan Atwood (Benjamin McKenzie), Kaitlin Cooper (Willa Holland).
Others mentioned are Summer Roberts (Rachel Bilson), Marissa Cooper (Mischa Barton), Julie Cooper (Melinda Clarke), Kirsten Cohen (Kelly Rowan), Sandy Cohen (Peter Gallagher).
It is in no way a true indication of these guys as their characters in The O.C. or in real-life.
Kaitlin Cooper waited in the Cohen kitchen for her mother and older sister, Marissa. She'd returned home from boarding school to find her family's former house in the numbered streets had new owners. Although she knew Julie and Marissa were now living in a trailer park, she pretended to be unaware of the situation and decided to visit the Cohen house.
Ryan had answered the door to Kaitlin. He wouldn't have recognised her if it wasn't for the quick story she told of her conversation with the owners of her old house. Seth arrived at the door by this time and could only stare in shock as he realized.
"Oh my God, Kaitlin Cooper?!" he said.
"Weird neighbour kid! Hi!" Kaitlin replied with a smile. But even if all Kaitlin remembered of Seth was that he was strange, she couldn't deny that he was now somewhat attractive. He seemed to have buffed up a bit and had a voice of confidence in him.
"You've grown --" Seth began.
"-- Boobs?" Kaitlin finished off his sentence.
Seth and Ryan couldn't object to that. Kaitlin had definitely grown, and it looked like her breasts had benefited the greatest. The last time Seth and Ryan had seen Kaitlin – no less than two years ago – she was rather flat-chested. Now, her small, petite body looked its age plus a year or two!
Kaitlin came through into the house where Seth offered her a drink.
"Got any beer?" she asked, causing Seth to pause. "Kidding, God," Kaitlin said with a smile. "I'll just have a juice." Seth couldn't help but return the smile. She was an attractive girl, and although Seth had the girl of his dreams – Summer Roberts – Kaitlin's warmth still sent sparks through him. Seth passed her the drink as the three of them sat at the kitchen table, Ryan on one side and Seth and Kaitlin next to each other on the opposite side.
"Thanks," Kaitlin said sweetly. Both boys couldn't believe how nice she was now. Last they'd seen of Kaitlin Cooper she was a replica of her mother and the only difference she had to Julie Cooper was her age. Arrogant, obsessively fashion-driven and self-absorbed were all in Kaitlin's checklist.
Obviously, boarding school had changed that. But the noticeable change for the boys was her physical appearance - Kaitlin was smoking hot! Seth and Ryan compared their girlfriends to her. Ryan and Marissa had love at first sight and Summer was Seth's dream girl, but neither could get out of their heads that Kaitlin may have turned out the most attractive of all three Orange County girls! Silence surrounded the room, but thoughts raced through all of their heads. Kaitlin knew hot when she saw it too, and Seth and Ryan both had ripped bodies and overall attractive physiques. Every minute or so she would shuffle in her chair, crossing one leg over the leg or flicking her hair.
The boys couldn't help but steal a glance when she wasn't looking. Everything about Kaitlin was rather seductive. She was wearing a short, tight skirt, exposing the most-part of her long tanned legs, and a skimpy top, which may not have been the most revealing design, but complimented her curved body and perky, soft tits. Ryan felt himself becoming more turned on by every passing minute. The old Ryan Atwood might try to pick up any regular girl he had this much of an attraction to, but this was Kaitlin Cooper, and he was in love with her older sister, Marissa. The new Ryan (since moving to Newport Beach) wouldn't leave the girl he had loved since first sight! But he couldn't deny he was thinking about it. About Kaitlin. So he tried to distract himself from Kaitlin.
"Hey, Seth," Ryan said across the table, "that special on Hellboy starts soon," he finished, directing his eyes from Seth to the TV.
"Nah, I'm fine, man. I'm sure they'll show repeats tomorrow or something," Seth responded. Both Ryan and Kaitlin were thrown back by this! If there was a second thing Kaitlin Cooper knew about Seth Cohen, it was that he loved his comic books and fair share of nerd-ish television shows. Now Kaitlin thought something was up, and on instinct, she looked down at Seth's pants to see something was definitely up. At his crotch His pant's materials had come to a point as Kaitlin examined his long boner. "Something's got this boy excited," she thought.
Kaitlin wanted to know if it was her that made Seth's cock as erect as a flagpole. But rather than ask him, she decided to have some fun. She took off her top, revealing silky body and tits covered only by the thin, pink bra she had on. "Whoa, is it hot in here?" she asked aloud as the two boys watched eagerly. Kaitlin threw her shirt to the floor and looked again at Seth's crotch. His cock was growing underneath, almost throbbing, as Kaitlin gave the boys a preview.
"It's Winter," Seth said neurotically, still staring, "50° (Fahrenheit) outside." Kaitlin gave a naughty smile as she reached her hands behind her back and unclipped her bra. Seth and Ryan watched intently as she slipped it off, and Kaitlin could only smile with satisfaction at how gob-stricken the boys were by her.
"No, it's pretty hot," Ryan said with a chuckle back to Seth, this time referring to Kaitlin and not the weather!
Kaitlin could only giggle as she lowered herself off the chair until her face met Seth's crotch. His awaiting cocked throbbed hard, anticipating Kaitlin's succulent mouth. Ryan stood up from his chair to get a better view as he watched Kaitlin pull down Seth's pants and begin to work his manhood. She went straight into action, and within seconds Kaitlin was deep-throating Seth's enormous gob, gagging with every intensifying push she made on it. But Kaitlin didn't mind - she loved it when guys would make her gag; and she was already an expert at taking dicks!
Ryan watched on as Kaitlin worked over Seth for a solid two minutes. Seth began to sigh with each passing thrust as he sat back and relaxed to Kaitlin's masterful mouth and soft, innocent moans of a schoolgirl in ecstasy. Ryan thought of the countless blowjobs he'd gotten from Marissa, and this was clearly another thing the two sisters had in common!
"Hang on," Kaitlin said, taking the full length of Seth's cock out of her pre-cum filled mouth. Seth looked down to see what the problem was, as Kaitlin swiftly pulled off her short skirt. The two boys looked over at each other once again, eyes wide open and awaiting, and both undressed, ready for Kaitlin. By this time she had stripped off her size 2 g-string, completely revealing her enticing body. This wasn't going to just be a couple quick blowjobs, Kaitlin was horny and yearning to be fucked... but not before pleasuring Seth some more!
She clenched her perky tits and squashed them between Seth's erect pole. Ryan began to jerk himself as he watched Kaitlin tit-fuck Seth's weary cock with her sweat-glistening, underage body. But neither guys cared how old she was – nor who she was! At this point, all Seth and Ryan knew was that Kaitlin had a killer body that pleasured even bettered than it looked – and if `looks could kill,' they'd be six feet under by now!
After a couple more minutes of massaging her tits on Seth's cock, Kaitlin went back to deep-throating him, her arousal growing as she gagged. She took her right hand from the grasp of Seth's cock and located her honey pot. Kaitlin rubbed two fingers over her juvenile, pink pussy lips, before burying them into her soaked pussy. Seth sat back further in his chair, closing his eyes, his body tingling with Kaitlin's heavenly oral skills.
For Kaitlin, this was all about lust. Her adolescent body was going through the fastest stage of its puberty, building hormones and curiosity! Kaitlin had a definite attraction to Seth, but not so much for Ryan. She noticed him watching her and jacking off as she played with Seth, but as Kaitlin looked in the corner of her eye across the table, Ryan was nowhere to be seen.
"Oh, shit!" Kaitlin shouted with her mouth full of Seth's gob, her petite body in spasm with ecstasy as her ass was reamed. She looked behind to see Ryan crouching there, his thick schlong buried inches into Kaitlin's anal hole, pouring out hot, gooey juices as he came. Now Ryan had her attention! Kaitlin withdrew her mouth from Seth's cock, and with a cheeky grin, prepared herself for Ryan.
"I've never done anal before," she said with a smirk.
"Oh, a virgin in the ass, huh?" Ryan responded playfully.
"Mm-hmm," Kaitlin nodded mischievously.
"Yeah, Marissa was too. She was a bit scared at first, actually," he looked into her provocative eyes, "but I got her to love it," Ryan finished with a humble smile. Kaitlin giggled at his typical boyish pride when it comes to their so-called "sexual expertise".
"Up on a bench?" she suggested, hinting to the kitchen benches for them to spring into action. Ryan didn't have to give it a second's thought, as he walked her over to the side bench where the Cohens would make their daily coffees.
Now Ryan took control. He commanded Kaitlin to rest her elbows on the bench and saddle up. She stuck her alluring ass out, allowing Ryan to inspect her illustrious body for what it was – illegal by law, but craving a good fuck! He thought of what could happen if somebody ever found out. Sandy and Kirsten weren't home, and although they usually weren't home this early, the boys would surely be in trouble
"Come on, I'm horny," Kaitlin said naughtily, but also with a sense of urgency. Ryan snapped out of his thoughts. `Stuff it. God's blessed me with a willing and aroused Kaitlin, surely he wouldn't go stuff it up with Sandy or Kirsten walking in,' Ryan thought to himself with a snicker, even though he wasn't a religious guy... well, obviously! He was having sexual activities with an underage girl! Ryan's hesitation blew away as he opened Kaitlin's butt cheeks, guiding his hard shaft into her virginious hole, and building a rhythm as he pumped her nicely tanned body. Within seconds, Kaitlin was shuddering and whimpering from the sensation, moaning for more.
"It's so tight in here," Ryan told her with a smile.
"Well I am new to this, you know?" Kaitlin murmured sweetly with what little breath she had.
"Oh, yeah," he partially removed his cock from Kaitlin until the head found the tip of her hole's entry, "I know!" Ryan ended, jabbing his cock back fully in, synchronizing his words with his movements.
Kaitlin was grunting within no time, resting her blissful face on the bench in front of her and bending over for Ryan to increase his pounding.
"You want more, huh?" Ryan asked.
"Yes," Kaitlin panted softly, her energy being fucked out of her.
"What's that? You want me to stop?" Ryan teased as he slowed down his penetrations. But he had no intention to stop pummelling Kaitlin – Ryan was having fun with this! He loved fucking from behind; it meant he could watch the girl be worked over to exhaustion and helplessness – and Ryan would have the satisfaction of being the satisfier.
"No! Keep going," Kaitlin pleaded sweetly.
"You like this?"
"Yeah."
"Tell me how much," Ryan demanded.
"I love it," Kaitlin let out softly.
"Huh?"
"I love it," she said again, this time with more vigour, frustrated Ryan was gradually slowing down his thrusts.
"I can't hear you, Ms. Cooper!" he shouted playfully.
"I FUCKING LOVE IT" Kaitlin screamed out, fed up of his talking – regardless that it was playful teasing.
"That's my girl!"
Ryan's cock clenched up and Kaitlin was left swooning in numbness as he came in her ass again, the hot cum pouring out of her and onto the kitchen floor. Kaitlin was worn out, and Ryan's hands around her waist were the only things keeping her powerless body from falling over in exhaustion.
"I bet this why you liked your pony. `Cause you could ride it?" Ryan joked, as a sweat-dripping Kaitlin laughed.
Ryan grabbed Kaitlin by the hair and shoved her face in front of his cock, demanding a blowjob. He couldn't believe how forceful and violent he felt towards her, but Ryan knew it was what she wanted; he just needed to baby her a bit. Kaitlin took hold of his offering and deep throated as much as she could. Seth's dick was the thickest of the two boys, but Ryan's was much longer. Ryan couldn't believe how good Kaitlin was! It would take Marissa five minutes to get him coming from a blowjob, but with Kaitlin, he'd come twice in those five minutes. And she wouldn't even stop to swallow her rewards! Cum ran from her mouth and down her chin, stopping at the mounds of her soft breasts.
After fondling with Ryan's dick some more, Kaitlin moved herself onto the middle bench.
"Hang on, I'll have some of this too." Seth had recovered from Kaitlin's earlier workover and was keen to join in on the fun as Kaitlin lay on the kitchen bench. Kaitlin moaned and giggled as the two guys climbed up next to her, dicks in-hand. Her glistened body was splattered with cum – both stained and fresh – from all three of them.
"Hey boys," Kaitlin said in a saucy voice, "fuck the shit outta me!"
The boys lunged towards her, Seth coming in from the side and Ryan from the top. Kaitlin embraced herself as Seth squeezed his cock into her newly-widened ass and Ryan spread her legs, brutally shoving all he had into her lonely pussy. The double penetration set Kaitlin off immediately as she let out a loud sigh. The boys worked her over like they were riding a see saw - as Seth would go in, Ryan would come out. She didn't have a second's brake in between their thrusts; Kaitlin could only lie back as her body was being rocked and her moans grew louder. She must've come five or six times before Seth and Ryan ended their ten minute fuckfest with simultaneous climaxes, filling her holes to maximum capacity! All three of them lay on the bench for a couple minutes before getting up to change back into their clothes. As Kaitlin sat up, she noticed she had been laying on a bagel. By this time it was lightly squashed and saturated in their pleasure juices!
Sandy and Kirsten had arrived home half an hour later, followed by Julie and Marissa soon after to pick up Kaitlin. No-one suspected a thing of Seth, Ryan and Kaitlin as the Coopers said their goodbyes to the Cohens.
Hours later into the day, Seth and Ryan talked in the kitchen about how incredible Kaitlin was at both sucking and taking dick! They pretended to be studying as they relived the events and her lascivious body, agreeing that she was could take and give more than their girlfriends, Summer and Marissa. Kirsten came downstairs looking for a snack. The boys looked over from their chairs as they saw her pick up a bagel from the bench.
"Yummy," Kirsten said with a smile as she took a bite, "did you guys buy honey flavour?" she asked the boys. They looked at each other in awe, both remembering... `Nope. That's Kaitlin Cooper flavour,' they thought to themselves.
"Yep, that's what that is," Seth said nervously as the two boys nodded.
"Mmm... It's very sweet." Kirsten gave another smile as she left the kitchen, finishing off the obliviously cum-soaked bagel.
The boys grinned. 'Yeah. She was very sweet!'