Disclaimer: This story is intended for adults. If it's illegal for you to be reading this, please leave now.
Your feedback is greatly appreciated, as always! Please send me your comments, I love hearing from you!
Please consider donating to the Nifty Archive at https://donate.nifty.org to keep it going.
Thanks for reading, B
Chapter 17
[February 27th, 2015 - Double up]
"I have the house to myself this afternoon <3" read the text from Abby.
That alone was enough to make my pants start to bulge and I had to readjust it in my seat during sixth period Social Studies. It wasn't unusual for her to be home alone, but it was usually at night during the weeks, as her mom had to nurse at the hospital. So this time it was her sending the horny invitation. Not that she hadn't made horny proposals before, but it was at her place now.
I had a hard time getting to the end of that period without being lost every couple of minutes in my thoughts of what I would do with Abby once I got to her place. But once it was over, I walked over to seventh period Math class and met Jordy at our usual double seat.
Once I saw him my mind kind of wandered off my upcoming date after school and I stared at him while he pulled out a book and sharpened his pencil.
The last couple of weeks have been a whirl in my head, actually. Ever since I let myself go and made love with Jordy at his place, it has been unclear for me where I stand with him.
It was him who voiced out his feelings for me that day, but it simultaneously put words to what was in my mind. So I got scared. I realized it was there and it was growing, often making me forget about Abby. And I thought I could let it rest for a while and try to come to terms with it. But the fact that he made it obvious and reciprocate, pushed it on my face and I shied away.
I made it very awkward for us to keep talking that day after I didn't say it back to him. It didn't help that I started acting funny, so in a few minutes I had excused myself and I was on my way home. Knowing Jordy and his ever good nature, he didn't bring it up again, maybe to avoid making me uncomfortable, and I acted like a jerk by ignoring it for several days.
When I got the courage to mention it to him, he'd just brush it off before I could finish any clear sentence, showing me a reassuring smile that I was starting to see through. It was last year all over again, except now there was a lot more happening between us and more and more, I felt like I should be making a decision. This wasn't just him telling me he had feelings for me. I had shown him that I was also attracted to him, got very close, had sex just the two of us. So now he had more reason to believe that I could be more receptive, even if I was secretly praying that he didn't notice my real feelings.
In his eyes, he'd made me uneasy by telling me he loved me and I'd left. I guess he had no clue what was going through me, so he just put some distance between us again and we hadn't done anything sexual. Him maybe out of respect, me out of fear.
What scared me was I didn't know what to do with it and what it meant to my relationship with Abby. I mean, I knew I loved her, I'd told her so. She told me she felt the same. But what I did with Jordy, felt like it was augmented somehow. I was still trying to come to terms with it. Was this real love? Was what I felt for Abby less than real love then?
I was starting to notice that the longer I stayed quiet about it, the more Jordy hurt. So it was time I grew some balls and talked to him about what's going on inside me. But for now, I was just too confused and chickened out.
Luckily, we were able to go back to normal during school hours and I resumed going to his place for homework this past week, even if things were purposely cold between us and we just kept it to just homework.
I think he was still getting together with Aaron, since I had no reason to believe that changed. I just didn't talk to him about anything sex-related.
Also, I hadn't been able to get together with Abby or Aaron in the past two weeks, so saying that I was very horny was a huge understatement. Which made Abby's message today all the more exciting for me. It must have been obvious since Jordy looked my way a couple of times during class and smiled.
When the day was over, I said my goodbyes to him and checked my texts to find out that Abby had already left for her house and said I should be there in an hour. It was enough time for me to go by my house and shower first.
As I was walking in through my main door, I got a text from Aaron.
"All ready for today?"
I got curious what he meant, since we hadn't made plans.
"what r u talking about?" I sent.
"Abby's place? At 4?" I got from him.
So it struck me that she'd invited him as well. I was a little surprised as it caught me off guard, but it's not that it was totally unexpected. Just that I'd pictured it would be just the two of us.
Suddenly I noticed my cock shot up inside my pants at the idea of another threesome with her and Aaron. After all, these experiences where the hottest I'd had up to that point.
It did leave me with a strange taste though. This was further from the loving feelings I got from having sex with her alone and definitely far from what I felt with Jordy a week ago. But it undeniably made me very horny and the thought of fucking her together with Aaron actually drove me crazy.
I forgot about the conflicts I'd had in my head the past hours and gave myself to the lust that my friends were offering me.
"yeah! see u there?" I sent to Aaron.
"Ofc, can't wait for the surprise" was his reply, which immediately got me going.
"what surprise?"
"it wouldn't be a surprise if I told ya lol"
I didn't reply anymore. But instead hurried through my shower, my cock standing up all the time. I wasn't feeling jealous of the fact that he knew more than I did about what was going on today. Had they been getting together without me? I guess I could expect that, it happened before. A few weeks ago, that wouldn't have been the case. But things have changed between us and I felt so at ease with everything, that I felt safe to just give in and enjoy the sexy things we did. Although I wasn't sure whether this was helping my situation with Jordy or actually making it worse. But I'd worry about it later.
I rushed to Abby's place and sure enough, when she opened the door for me, Aaron was standing behind her to receive me. He must have sprinted through since he lived farther from Abby than I did. Or maybe he went straight from school? I couldn't remember what he wore today, so I couldn't tell if he'd changed or not. Also Abby left before me and I didn't see him anywhere outside school.
"Heeeyy!" she exclaimed and jumped to me.
All my thoughts were cut short as her scent filled my senses and I wrapped my arms around her.
"Hey you!" I replied just as excited as I kissed her. We stood upright but the kiss lingered.
I could feel she was hornier than usual, if that was even possible.
"Hey man." came from Aaron and I hugged him as well, only no kiss.
"Hey, so... what is the surprise?" I couldn't wait to be told.
Abby turned to him and said "What did you tell him?"
It got a little suspicious, but again, I was beyond being jealous. So I came in to save him.
"Just that there was a surprise." I said.
"Oh! You'd better." she said to Aaron with a smile. Then to me, "You'll find out soon enough."
We pretended it was a normal visit at Abby's for as long as we could, which wasn't much. She offered us drinks and we hadn't really had as much as a sip before both of us were all over her on her mother's couch.
I pulled her shirt up and off while she was facing Aaron and sucking on his lips. My hands went straight to her bra and to her bare tits once I'd unhooked it. It was all I could do keeping my cock as soft as possible on my way here, but now it was back to full mast and my pants were very noticeable.
She turned to me and I leaned into her, making out heavily as her breasts pressed to my chest. She started fumbling with my button and zipper and soon her hand was inside my boxers stroking my six inches.
"Uhhh." I moaned into her mouth.
I caught Aaron pulling off his own shirt and revealing his hard cock, his pants open and boxers hooked under his balls.
Abby turned back to him and immediately went down on his hard seven inches. I took the time to remove my shoes and pants completely. While I was looking for a chair to throw them at, I saw Aaron's backpack on the seat. This meant he'd come straight from school with her. My mind was racing with thoughts of what the two of them could have been up to. Have they done this before? What is that surprise I don't know about?
I snapped back to reality when I heard Aaron moan out her name and I looked to see she had his whole cock in her mouth and throat, down to his balls. His hand was on her head, holding it as she swallowed him. I felt a hot rush through me at the scene before me, and I decided to pull her pants and panties off as fast as I could, before tugging at her thighs so she would get on all fours on the couch.
After she did, I dove into her exposed pussy and asshole. I was so horny I couldn't get enough of both of her holes. I couldn't decide which one I wanted. I would lick and suck at her pussy lips and hear her muffled moans, then I'd move up to her little hole and poke my tongue in it only to hear her moan even louder. I kept this up while I rubbed her hardened clit and felt her juices start to flow into my fingers and tongue.
All the while, moans were coming from Aaron, mixed with her gagging from having his cock so deep in her throat. I was holding back from touching my own cock because I thought I wouldn't last long before cumming. So when she sat up I looked at her and wondered what she had in mind.
"I want to ride you." she said to Aaron. "Ethan, give me your cock."
I was a little surprised by her attitude, but she was very decided on what she wanted, and who was I to deny her, especially when it meant I get to fuck her mouth after so long!
I stood up in front of her as Aaron finished removing his pants and was looking for a condom. She'd started licking my shaft up and down and once it was all wet, she held my gaze as she opened her lips and wrapped them around my cock head.
"Oohh fuck." I uttered while looking into her lustful eyes.
She went down taking half of my cock before going back up and start bobbing her head on it. Her eyes going between my own and my trimmed pubes before her.
As Aaron finished putting a condom, he called out to her.
"Come here, I'm ready."
She pulled off my cock and straddled Aaron, who had scooted his ass closer to the edge of the couch. In one swift movement she took his whole cock in her wet pussy and, with her hands on her knees, motioned me over.
I stood in between Aaron's legs and hers, trying to get close to her face as she leaned forward. She opened up her mouth and I got the cue and, putting my left hand in the back of her head, aimed my cock using my right hand and pushed it in between her lips.
I didn't stop there and pushed as far as it would go. It seems she wasn't ready yet to take my whole cock, as it bottomed out at about three quarters. But I started pulling out and fucking her face, her lips now clamped onto my shaft and her tongue rubbing the underside.
"Ahh yeah." Aaron exclaimed as she started slowly bouncing off his lap, his hands at her hips probably helping her leverage her weight.
"Mmmm fuck." came out of my lips as I watched her mouth stretch around my cock.
I kept fucking her mouth steadily, the hot wet feeling bathing my shaft. I realized she was getting used to it and I was able to get deeper until I felt my glans push past into her throat and my balls hit her chin on every thrust.
I couldn't believe how good this felt and how readily she was giving herself to both us boys. She started bouncing harder off Aaron's lap, his thighs being hit with a loud clap every now and then. I placed both my hands on her haid and, tucking her hair back, I held it as I started long dicking her mouth steadily.
"Fuck, suck my cock, yeah..." I let out in a fog of lust.
Her moans got muffled and mixed with her gagging noises as she took my cock in her throat time and again. I couldn't handle all the stimulation and I felt my cum rush up through my cock and into her mouth.
"Fuck I'm cumming!" I said as I pulled back a little and fucked only half of my cock through her tightened lips.
"Aaaarghhhh!" I kept unloading in her mouth as she swallowed.
She slowed down her moves on Aaron until I was not spewing any more cum, then she released me and smiled up at me.
"Sorry, I couldn't hold it." I said feeling bad that I'd finished so soon.
"Don't be, that was so hot." she replied while she started bouncing hard on Aaron again. "Besides, we have all afternoon."
I stroked my cock idly as I stood there watching her fuck herself on Aaron. She'd sat back on him and he was fondling her tits. Soon she was lying on him, her face turned to kiss him, while his hips started moving to send his cock up into her cunt.
She reached down to rub her own clit and I couldn't believe how hot this whole thing was. I knew we'd done all this before, but it still amazed me how well we worked together, now also including Aaron.
I'd long forgotten about my confusion, my questions about love and Jordy. My cock was leading the way here and it actually hadn't gone down after cumming. It wasn't as sensitive as it had been two minutes before but it was still hard. That's when Abby asked if I was ready for the surprise.
"What is it!?" I'd forgotten about that as well.
"You're still hard so, put on a condom and sit here." she explained. "Let me ride you."
I did as she said and grabbed a condom from my pants pocket. I rolled it on my cock easily and she waited until I was sitting beside Aaron, before climbing off him and rolling onto me.
She straddled my legs facing me as she guided my cock to her wet pussy and finally sat down on it.
"Mmmm..." I moaned as I felt her pussy again around my cock after so long.
It sucked my cock inside and she sat still.
"So..." she started.
Up until now there was nothing I could really call a surprise, since all of this, we'd done before.
"I was thinking... since you've already fucked my ass..." she continued. "I thought maybe both of you could fuck me, but..."
I could tell she was nervous and beyond aroused by this, but I waited for her to finish.
"...at the same time. I pictured both your cocks in me and ever since, I can't get this idea out of my head." she said.
She must have felt my cock twitch inside her as she finished telling me.
"I want to try it today. Do you?" she asked in a teasing tone.
I knew about this, seen it countless times and even saw it once with Aaron while working out. It was the trigger for my fantasies of a three way with us and Aaron. I couldn't believe it was her who was bringing it up now.
"Fuck, I..." I looked to my side and Aaron was beaming. "Did you know this?"
"Yeah, she... kind of asked me if I'd be into it." he explained, his smile fading.
I realized I sounded like I was mad at him.
"I'm..." they both looked at me. "I want to do it. Really bad, actually."
The words came out nervously as I was overwhelmed with the whole thing.
"Are you sure?" Abby sounded apprehensive.
"Yeah! It's... actually a fantasy of mine." I added.
Both their smiles returned to their faces and she squeezed my cock with her pussy, which elicited a loud moan from me. I realized Aaron was about to fuck her ass and I briefly wondered if this was the first time. He'd never done it in front of me, she even saved it only for me. But the feeling that they'd been sharing more with each other lately made me think they'd maybe gone further than I knew.
Anyhow, I didn't feel bad at all. In fact, I was glad I was going to be a part of this, a fantasy becoming real. Again, my cock was leading the way and I wasn't worried in the slightest. I just wanted to fuck Abby so bad and with Aaron no less.
I saw Aaron reach into his backpack and pull out his lube. The same tube he'd brought over to my house on Valentine's. I hadn't used that with Abby before, but I figured it was better than just spit and we could really use that now.
Abby leaned forward onto me until her tits were pressing on my chest. Aaron sat on the couch beside us and started stroking her back. I joined him, stroking her sides and up to her neck.
She started moaning as I felt Aaron was pressing his finger to her butt, but it actually felt right next to my own cock! I couldn't believe the wall in between was so thin. Also I couldn't wait until it was his cock in there next to mine!
I kept stroking her back as he worked his fingers in her ass and planted kisses on her. I was thankful he was experienced with anal sex, maybe more than I was. I left it to him to do it right so she wouldn't be hurt.
"How are you feeling?" I asked Abby, trying to make sure she wasn't in pain.
"Great so far." she replied, her eyes closed.
She cuddled her head on my shoulder and buried her face in my neck as I felt Aaron start using more fingers in her, judging by the sensations on my cock. After some minutes, he declared she was loose enough.
"Do you want to try this?" he asked.
"Yes!" we both said in unison, then chuckled.
"Okay, okay!" he laughed. "Me too!"
Please drop me a line if you liked it or if you didn't. I really appreciate it.
B