Some credit for this story goes to a friend of mine who helped me with the idea for it. I also have to thank all of you who email me about my stories - I'm writing for you :)
This story is fiction. The characters within this story are copyrighted by Tollin/Robbins and the CW network. This story implies nothing about the sexuality of the actors or characters in One Tree Hill.
This series fills in certain parts of the One Tree Hill storyline that actually happened but never made it to the TV screen.
Season 2
-Lucas Scott (played by Chad Michael Murray) -Nathan Scott (played by James Lafferty) -Chris Keller (played by Tyler Hilton)
Recap:
Chris Keller, a music record store owner, is approached by Peyton to sing at the Tric Club, but in the end he refuses, prompting Haley to sing instead. He then begins a partnership with Haley to give her an opportunity to realize her dream and become a singer. They become closer and closer and eventually kiss.
Revelation:
Nathan was insane with rage. His anger was getting the better of him. Recently, he and Haley had begun to grow apart, as she wanted some independence to pursue a music career, and she was spending a lot of time with Chris Keller. Finally, when Nathan found out that Haley and Chris had kissed, that was the last straw. Chris Keller will pay for this, Nathan kept thinking to himself.
Nathan didn't even know what he was going to do when he'd find Chris. It was just about midnight, but Nathan couldn't sleep. Wearing only boxers and a wife beater, he got into his car and drove off to the motel where Chris was staying. By the time Nathan reached Chris's room, he pretty much figured that he'd end up beating Chris to a pulp. But things changed when he opened the door.
Nathan walked into the room and found Chris lying on the bed, wearing nothing but a tight pair of gray bikini briefs, with his right hand tied to the bedpost by a rope.
"Hey Nathan, nice to see you! I was just having some fun with some pretty thing I met at a bar, things got a little kinky, and it seems like she bailed on me. Oh well, I guess I don't pick 'em as well as I used to. Anyway, that chick must be some sorta expert with knots - I can't seem to get out of this thing. You wanna lend me a hand?"
"You have got to be kidding me! You kiss my wife and then expect me to help you?"
"Dude, I didn't know it was such a big deal. Whatsa matter, are you jealous?"
Nathan didn't know how to respond. He paused to look at the guy lying in front of him. Chris wasn't muscular, but he was very slim and smooth. And even though he was often an arrogant prick, Nathan couldn't deny that he was really cute, especially with his cocky grin. And with all the problems between Nathan and Haley lately, Nathan hadn't gotten any for weeks. He knew exactly what he was going to do now.
Nathan finally answered Chris. "You know what, I guess I am a little jealous. And with you all tied up and looking like you're in the mood, I might as well help you out. But don't get the wrong idea, I don't think you're gonna enjoy this too much."
"What the hell are you talking about?! I was just messing with you! Get away from me! Get me outta this -"
But Chris couldn't get any more words out, because by now Nathan had pulled off his boxers and stuffed his thick cock in Chris's mouth. Chris's attempts to break free were useless. Especially with one hand unavailable, he was no match against the ripped athlete.
Nathan looked down at Chris, whose pleading eyes were looking back up at him, silently asking for mercy. The feeling of total control was such a turn-on. Besides that, Nathan was also enjoying the feeling of Chris's warm mouth and tongue enveloping his cock, which quickly expanded to its fullest size. Nathan continued to slam his rock-hard nine inches down Chris's throat, and finally he got it all the way in.
"Oh, yes! That's amazing! You were born to take cock! And you know you love it! Yeah! Take my entire cock! Feel my pubes against your face!"
Nathan's knees were now pushing down on Chris's shoulders, and his hands were holding on to the bed board behind Chris's head, for optimal leverage. He was still wearing his tight wife beater, which made his body look amazingly hot by showing off the huge muscles on his arms and chest.
Nathan was so engrossed in face-fucking Chris that he didn't even hear the room door open again. Lucas had found out that Nathan drove off and figured it must have been to confront Chris. Lucas was hoping he would be able to prevent an ugly fight. Instead, he walked inside the room and saw Nathan's hot ass at work. Lucas was mesmerized. As Nathan continued his assault, he finally decided to remove his last piece of clothing. Lucas's eyes opened wide at the breathtaking sight of Nathan's muscles flexing as he pulled his wife beater over his head.
Finally Nathan noticed Lucas. Lucas was embarrassed to have been caught staring, but he was speechless. Nathan didn't know how Lucas had found him, but he didn't really care at the moment.
"Lucas, get over here. You're gonna help me fuck this cocksucker. I already got his mouth, so you have the privilege of fucking his ass. And he's gonna like your cock just as much as he likes mine, isn't that right?"
Nathan looked down at Chris's face as he yet again shoved the full length of his hard cock into his mouth. Nathan could feel that Chris wasn't putting up as much of a fight anymore. Chris knew he had lost and simply surrendered. Or was he actually enjoying it now?
Lucas continued to stare at Nathan's hot body in action. His own cock was also totally hard now. Though he wasn't as pissed at Chris as Nathan was, and he didn't have a temper like Nathan's, he was still plenty mad at Chris. So with his cock doing most of the thinking, he quickly pulled all of his clothes off.
As Lucas got onto the bed, Nathan stood up. Nathan then flipped Chris onto his stomach, got onto his knees again, and got back to his face-fucking, now in a new position.
"There's his ass, Lucas, there for the taking."
Lucas had no idea that Chris had such a perfect ass. It was the most perfect bubble butt, soft and firm and perfectly round. Although Lucas was going to have to be rough on Chris, he couldn't help but be partially gentle as well. It was in his nature, besides the fact that he was in love with that sweet ass.
Lucas aggressively grabbed Chris's underwear and pulled it down to his knees. He then put his hands on his prize. It was amazing. He felt like he was dreaming as he squeezed those cheeks as hard as he could. As he pulled them apart, exposing Chris's asshole, his cock jumped up out of excitement. He couldn't wait another second, and it was fitting for his victim to not make this too easy for him. Lucas then placed his huge cock head on Chris's asshole. His heart was racing. He closed his eyes and just focused on the physical bliss of penetrating a perfect virgin asshole. He placed one of his hands on Chris's lower back, for positioning, and the other hand on one of his ass cheeks. As he slammed inside further and further, he slapped Chris's ass over and over. Lucas was now grunting like an animal with pleasure.
Of course, having his ass ripped open for the first time, and with an 8-inch cock, was tough on Chris. But his screams were muffled by the cock that was in his mouth. Chris almost felt like he might pass out. But the truth was that Nathan was right: Chris did eventually get used to cocksucking, and he was loving it. He got pretty pissed off, though, that just as he was starting to enjoy himself, he had to deal with his ass getting plowed. But that too he soon began to enjoy. Chris was indeed a sex maniac, so he couldn't have been that surprised that he'd have a blast being fucked by two hot brothers. Speaking of having a blast, he noticed that his cock, which was being thrown all over, was harder than ever and ready to shoot. He took his free hand and began stroking it, not caring whether anyone noticed.
Nathan and Lucas were now ready to blow their loads. They would have preferred to get Chris all messy with their cum, but they simply couldn't imagine removing their cocks. They were both in heaven. Nathan grabbed Chris's spiked hair by the roots and began forcefully pushing and pulling his head. Lucas threw his whole body on top of Chris's. His hands held onto Chris's shoulders as he lifted his body up and down, shoving his cock deep inside Chris's ass.
The Scott brothers could tell by their screams that each of them was about to shoot. They looked at each other, gave a final powerful push, and screamed at the top of their lungs as they unloaded together. Lucas and Nathan felt so intensely connected at that moment. Before their minds could get back to thinking rationally, they grabbed each other's heads for a passionate kiss. Their hands ran through their hair and faces, and their lips and tongues fought with each other.
As their passion finally died down, they saw that Chris had been having some fun after all. He was madly jacking off. So Lucas and Nathan decided to punish him one last time.
Nathan shouted, "You wanna cum so bad, huh? Well, we'll only let you do it the way we want you to do it."
Then they lifted up his legs over his head so that his cock was positioned on top of his face.
"No, guys, please. You can't do this! You guys are so fucking hot, I need to cum, you have no idea! You can't make me cum on my face. Pleeeease!!!
Lucas and Nathan smiled at each other. They watched Chris's cum-drenched mouth as he moaned louder and louder. At long last, he reached his orgasm, sending blasts of cum all over his hair and face.
Lucas and Nathan took their stuff and left Chris as he was, full of cum and still tied to the bed. He felt so used, so violated. He was therefore shocked when he realized that there was a smile plastered across his face.
Please let me know what you think! Andi at andiarch@inbox.com You can check out my Desperate Hot Guys series too. Enjoy!