Paradise Lost
Chapter 4
I Take the Ultimate Insertion
Our paradise became hell again when a new fresh batch of deviates hit the island. The first morning they were up and active Adam and I along with two others were in the gym, naked but working out. We could see a reasonable number of guests sat watching us being served drinks by the waiting staff. Mike was with them holding a mic.
"Jonah, secure Adam's legs to the weight bar with him stretched as wide as you can. Adam suck him until he is rampant and then Jonah you can fuck his brains out."
I didn't want to but I knew Adam would take incredible butt punishment if I didn't. I took a long time opening him up before sliding my cock over his sphincter. I was devastated, I didn't want to fuck my straight friend, I knew that would humiliate him so much but he egged me on so that we wouldn't both be in serious trouble.
"That feels good Jonah, I could get to like you fucking me."
I wanted to cry, I knew he was lieing just to make me feel good, but my orgasm was amazing.
"Pull out and cum all over him Jonah."
I did, so that all of the guests that were watching could see how good it had been for me. I was pleased as well, I hadn't had to cum in his arse which would have been another degradation for this wonderful friend. We went off to shower then while two more of the boys repeated our performance for another bunch of guests. Mike caught us as we came back to the gym.
"I want you two to reverse roles and repeat that at the pool."
Adam looked devastated. "I can't do that Mike, I'll split Jonah's anus beyond repair with my monster."
"You can, and if you split him I have doctor on the island to stitch him up. Your alternative is sewage duty."
Both of us shuddered.
"Do it Adam, I'll survive."
When we got to the pool a sun bed had been placed on a lawn in a cleared area. There was a small table alongside it with a tub of Crisco on it plus a speculum and lots of other lubricants. Two of the other boys from our group were there as well.
"The two boys will hold your legs back and spread wide Jonah. Adam you will direct them as to how you want Jonah placed. I want you to open him up gradually with your fingers before you finally fist him, you can use the speculum to spread him if you are having a problem getting your fist over his sphincter. Use plenty of Crisco for that. Fist him for about five minutes gradually going in deeper. When I give you the nod, pull out and with a well lubed cock take your time but feed him all of it before fucking him to orgasm."
"Do it Adam."
I could see he was going to refuse. I pulled him in close to me.
"I love you Bro, if you love me too you will ignore my screams when you enter me and just do it. We both know you are going to damage me but you aren't going to kill me. I forgive you before you start and I will still love you as my brother when it is all over."
He looked deep into my eyes then and said, "This whole nightmare will have been worth it at the end if only because I have met you Jonah, I love you Bro."
I tried to remain relaxed as Adam started. He was very gentle feeding me well lubed fingers slowly and opening me up at a pace that allowed me all the time in the world to adjust. The boys kept my legs at a comfortable angle and stroked my torso to keep me relaxed. One of them stroked my cock and balls occasionally as well leaning into me and whispering.
"You should get some pleasure from this as well Jonah."
He was smiling and I whispered back my thanks.
The crowd had swelled as we got into this and I felt terribly humiliated looking at all these strangers watching me being finger fucked. I could hear some of the comments which made it worse.
"I am going to fist him and fuck him some time this holiday that looks too nice an arse to ignore."
"I agree, perhaps we can have a threesome because I want some of that cock, I love sucking boy cock and taking their juice straight from the source."
There were other comments in a similar vein which made me feel less than human.
Adam didn't tell me when he was going in with his whole fist. He told me later it was because he knew I would tense up and that would just make it worse. I didn't think it could get any worse, the pain as his knuckles went over my sphincter kept me screaming for ages. I did hear Mike though.
"Keep your fist in Adam, removing it and then doing it again will be much worse for him."
I was crying and begging him to remove it, I thought I was going to die. Eventually of course the pain eased and I stopped screaming and eventually the sobs eased. Then the most amazing sensations started coursing through my body as Adam started wriggling his fingers around. It was like electric shocks as he kept hitting my g spot, but also other nerve ends appeared to be reacting and all of a sudden I was getting hard again. Everybody cheered and Adam looked dumbstruck as he watched my penis grow.
"Sorry Adam, you are doing things inside my arse that I can't control."
He just laughed, fell forward and kissed me full on the lips like I had done to him once.
"I love you Jonah, almost enough to wish I was gay."
He fucked me with his fist for ages gradually adding more arm, all the time adding more Crisco on the in stroke so that I wouldn't get too sore.
"Triano, come and work your magic, I want Adam's cock so hard an iron bar will feel soft." Mike was obviously controlling this one.
Triano came out of the crowd and started working on Adam's cock which was completely flaccid because of what he was doing to me, he was a pro and soon had the required effect.
"When you pull your fist out Adam stand up and turn through 360 as you lube your cock before fucking Jonah. Let everyone see it."
Adam did eventually pull out and while he carried out Mike's instruction Triano put his fist in me.
"I'm sorry Jonah but if I keep your sphincter open Adam will hurt you less than if I allow it to close up."
I realised the sense and just nodded at him.
"Gentlemen, what you are looking at is 13-1/2 inches by 10-1/2 inches of man meat. Jonah is going to take it all and as a reward Adam can cum in his arse."
Everybody cheered and Adam turned back to me, Triano moved away and Adam with tears in his eyes said to me, "I'm sorry Jonah, I'm so sorry."
He entered me as gently as he could but I still passed out with the pain. When I regained my senses Adam eased into me with an inch or so, the pain was unreal and I think I must have been delirious because I hardly felt anything as the extra inches went in. I remember the cheer when Adam whispered to me, "You have it all my lover, you are so brave."
He fucked me with it very slowly with long strokes until I calmed down and rejoined the world, then he sped up a little until he orgasmed. Great gut wrenching thrusts as his animal urges took over and I screamed again as I felt his orgasm exploding inside me. I couldn't believe the force of his jets of sperm, truly amazing.
Adam disintegrated then. I couldn't believe it. He blacked out eventually falling forward onto me. I cuddled him until the medics arrived and he was stretchered off to the infirmary. I could see I was bleeding but I followed Adam with help from the two boys who had held my legs. I was very wobbly but my concern was for my friend. He was already on a drip by the time I got to him and the Doctor assured me he was ok.
"Just mental overload Jonah, that boy has serious feelings for you, amazing for a straight boy. Up on the next bed young man, let's have a look at you."
My two helpers did what they had been doing for the last hour, held my legs up and wide, to little squeals of pain from me.
"You are split quite badly boy, which doesn't surprise me one bit looking at what you have just had inside you. We'll get you sown up and hope for the best."
I was given a local anaesthetic while he worked and then pain killers when he finished. I was out of it until the next morning. My first waking thought was Adam. I rolled over and could see him, his eyes were on me. I smiled and in a very weak voice said, "Hello stud, how are you feeling?"
He teared up. "I love you Jonah, you have no idea how much. Please say you forgive me."
"Nothing to forgive, you did what you had to do. I told you I'll live."
"You don't understand. I had the most incredible orgasm I have ever had in my life. I was an animal at the end. I couldn't help it you felt so good to my cock."
I grinned this time, "I should hope so, if I can't satisfy my best friend, who can I satisfy?"
"But I've damaged you quite badly according to the doctor."
"We guessed you would champ. Don't worry, my future plans were only to use that part of my body for necessary bodily functions, so it doesn't have to look pretty."
That comment was too much for him then, he got out of bed and slipped in to mine taking me in his arms and cuddling me.
"Careful champ your gay side is showing."
He looked deep into my eyes, stroked my face and neck as he said, "I don't care Jonah, I love you and I'm going to go on loving you for the remainder of my life. You are something very special."
The Doc came in then and saw us.
"I don't feel quite so bad for you two now, I thought you were straight guys."
Adam looked so affronted I just giggled like a school boy.
"We aren't gay Doc. But this guy has just forgiven me for fucking him. I love him better than a brother, but I'm not about to make love to him voluntarily any time soon."
Priceless, and better therapy than any shrink could have done for me.
Mike came by later in the day and actually looked contrite.
"I'm sorry Jonah, I didn't think Adam would do that much damage with his penis. A specialist team are flying in today to see what we can do for your bottom. I am also awarding both of you some more bonus money for yesterday's performance. My guests are over the moon."
Like I cared, but the extra money sounded good. I thought I would squeeze this one.
"Thanks Mike, how much do you think a ruined arse is worth? I understand I'm pretty badly damaged back there."
He looked really upset now.
"I was thinking $40,000 for you and another $20,000 for Adam for his distress."
Adam looked shocked and I just said, "I guess that's ok, thanks Mike."
He left then and I said to Adam, "How many times can you fuck me at $20,000 a throw?"
We ended up both giggling, my sweet Adam was ok again.
My arse wasn't touched for weeks but Doc. had me in every day to apply special creams.
"Mike says I have to get your arse as supple as possible because he wants Adam to fuck you again as soon as possible."
I was not a happy bunny at that comment but Doc. told me he doubted I would be split again because he was going to be opening me up with a speculum regularly once I was healed.
We both came back to full health physically and mentally because of each other.
Our next adventure with the guests was a pleasant one compared to the previous one. I had to rim Adam and then fuck him, but not until I had done wonderful things to his cock and balls and taken a mouthful of his love juice. He tickled me pink, full of apologies for cumming in my mouth, as though he had any choice. I had to cum in his arse and I hated it. I knew this took away more of his manhood in his own mind, but at least he knew I did it with love, it was much worse when we got involved in a fuck fest which we did at least once a week, hell almost once a day.
The next day I started my routine with the Doc. Every morning immediately after breakfast I had to go to the infirmary, strip and go doggy fashion on a bed while the Doc. opened me up with a speculum using lots of a cream that he said would help my flexibility, he also used his free hand to stroke around my abdomen. He said it was to relax me and he was probably right, but it did get awfully erotic. He kept that hand oiled and when he stroked my perineum and through to my balls I invariably got a massive hard on.
"Your girl friend must be a happy lady Jonah if you are using this on her, and the boys here, even if they are straight must find this very erotic."
What could I say to that, was he leading up to me making love to him? Wow, wouldn't that have been something. Anyway, about fifteen minutes of this with the speculum getting to an uncomfortable stage before he eased off.
"That's very good Jonah, a little more each day and we'll soon be able to let Adam loose on you."
Not happy, Adam's cock was like a spectre in my mind it was just so big.
Adam was at the pool and I had to go to the gym office.
"Mal has been briefed on what I want Jonah so just follow his instruction. He will tell you exactly where to stand and what to do. Strip now and get out into the gym."
I did and immediately noticed quite a large crowd in the seats on one side of the gym. Mal was working out with Clark our other black guy.
"Hi Jonah, will you come and spot for Clark while he does some bench presses. You don't need to worry he is only pressing about forty pounds, it's just for show."
So I did, pretending to struggle with the weight bar as I gave it to Clark. He had his legs either side of the bench and Mal sat at the end of the bench started to play with Clark's cock until it was hard and then went down on him. After about ten minutes making sure the audience got a good look he told me to stow the weight bar and take hold of Clark's legs, which I did. Mal went off to get things and when he came back we used what he had brought back to secure Clark's legs to the ends of the weight bar which I had locked in so that it wouldn't move. The whole apparatus that we were working with swivelled round so that Clark's arse was pointing at the audience and Mal and I were either side of the bench.
"We are going to play with him and open him up together Jonah and then take turns fisting him."
I looked shocked, Clark was on the small side so our fists were going to hurt massively because both Mal and I had quite large hands.
"I'm sorry Jonah but Mike has emphasised that we are to take turns and that we are to get as much of our forearms in as possible over a period of half an hour."
I saw the big tub of Crisco under the bench but we were still going to cause massive trauma. I stroked Clark all over his torso whispering to him as we started fingering him.
"Try to relax lovely boy, we are going to hurt you but the more relaxed you are the less the pain. We won't bunch up our fist until the pain has eased to give you some time to adjust."
Clark looked at me with his big soulful eyes. "Thanks Jonah, Adam's right, you are a special white boy."
Then he smiled.
I leant forward and kissed his nipples, I thought I could do the same to him as I did to Sam , that would be alright and not really gay. I told Clark and his smile got broader.
"Yeah, I'll be able to tell her how you rate when I see her."
We took our time, while I was fingering him and stroking his body Mal was playing with his cock and balls. When we reversed I did the same but I used my tongue and mouth on his cock and balls as well. Hell I was sucking off strange men on the beach or at the pool why shouldn't I pleasure a friend. It was diverting his attention from an increasing level of discomfort as we got close to fisting him. Mal and I compared fists and decided mine was smaller so I told Clark I was going in first. I kept telling him to relax and stroked him all the time with my free hand. I plunged my fist into the Crisco. I wanted to go in without him knowing precisely when. I almost succeeded but as I was pushing for entry he tensed and I went over a very tight sphincter. Clark screamed, I stayed perfectly still just inside him and the crowd applauded, sick bastards.
He had a really cute butt and it did look incredible with my fist sticking out of it. I started to move my fingers around after a few minutes and I watched the pain disappear from his eyes. I started to gently fuck him adding a little more arm each time I slid in. Mal continued to play with his cock and balls and I stroked his torso with my free hand. I bunched my fist after a while and started a corkscrew motion.
"Oh fuck Jonah, what are you doing, that feels amazing."
I looked at his cock and giggled, "Yeah I can see, that's one very pretty erection. I'm going to suck you dry when Mal takes over from me."
"Huh, promises, promises, straight white boys don't take black boy juice."
"Well this one does, you deserve a reward for taking our fists."
"Thanks Jonah, you're a star."
I went back to concentrating on his arse. I was about two thirds of the way up my forearm when I pulled out gently straightening my fingers before going over his sphincter again.
"Get in now Mal before he has time to close up."
Then Mike's voice, "No Mal, let him close up with the guests watching then you can re-enter."
I said "Bastard," obviously loud enough for Mike to hear because he got me afterwards.
Mal went in and got another scream. I tried hard to calm Clark down and worked my magic on his cock and balls getting him spewing cum everywhere until I managed to get it back in my mouth. I sucked hard then and almost gave him a second orgasm. Mal was told to fuck him after about ten minutes of fisting and that was it.
We showered after that and I cleaned Clark paying particular attention to his anus. I washed away all the mess very gently and after I had dried him entered him again with one finger coated with the cream that I was getting all too familiar with.
"Thanks Jonah, I won't forget this."
As I left Mike grabbed me and led me round the gym to the audience seats. There was one chair set facing the others and Mike sat in it.
"This is the young man that said 'bastard' and this is how he is punished. Strip Jonah and across my knees."
Ten very hard slaps across my butt with his bare hand in front of about twenty guests. I felt so humiliated. As I stood up Mike said.
"What do you have to say?
I knew what he wanted. I turned my red arse to the audience and apologised to Mike.
"Ok Jonah, pool, naked so that everyone knows you have been punished."
More embarrassment.
===========================================================================