WARNING: This fanfiction contains "spoilers" up to episode 4, season 5 of Glee and some hot steamy man on man sex (eventually) so if you're not down with any of those things, don't read any further.
DISCLAIMER: Glee and all of it's yummy men are property of FOX and Ryan Murphy and all sorts of other people who are not me.
Sinister Schuester
Will Schuester sat in the back of the theater, watching his glee club performing Roar with an unbelievable set. However, the set wasn't what Will was focused on. He had his eyes on his four shirtless boys and he had his hand rubbing his hard cock through his khakis underneath the table. He had managed to get his boys this far and this naked. Now, he had to get them to the next stage in his plan.
EARLIER IN THE WEEK
Will was frustrated, sexually and creatively. Emma wasn't putting out at home and when she was, she wasn't satisfying his carnal needs. He considered himself bi but only because women appealed to him conventionally. However, he really craved the guys. It was the whole reason he started the glee club. Years ago, he was bored and looking for some man-candy to use for jack material as he was scoping out the boys in the locker room and happened to hear Finn in the shower. Inspiration hit him then. He could start a glee club. It was a sure way to lure the already-gay boys in and path to turning the self-identified straight guys flexible in their sexuality, like a gateway drug. At least that's how it had been for him when he was in school.
So he started the glee club. Initially he was very disappointed in the turnout. Artie and Kurt didn't do it for him. Finn was okay but Puck became the object of his fantasies. Will got tired of glee about the time that Finn and Puck were set to graduate but he decided to see how far he could get with Blaine once Kurt was gone. At the start of the next school year, Jake got his attention in auditions so he sought him out. Then he saw a spark between Sam and Blaine and believed he could get both of them. He still needed a little more sausage in the group though so he cruised the football practice and sent Finn out to bring in Ryder. Now this was a bunch of boys he could get behind.
Will was fine with eyeing the guys and dreaming about what he would do to each and every one of them. He found himself jacking off to the thoughts of them constantly and barely giving it up to Emma. Then they came out with the calendar and Will nearly exploded. He went through several copies as his pages kept sticking together. He knew he had to get them nearly naked more often and eventually seduce each of them. And then Tina brought up Gaga yet again.
Opportunity had knocked loudly. Gaga does naked or at least scantily clad often and she does it well. Will was going to suggest that they all do Gaga but then this three vanilla boys, Ryder, Blaine and Sam identified as Katys so he had them swap to Gaga. Katy also shows some skin but Will really liked the idea of his boys wearing nothing but police tape bikini bottoms. It was a shame that Jake didn't want to join them but three out of four isn't bad. Will would surely find a way to get the little kinkster to strip down later.
When it came time for the Gaga group's performance, Will initially thought that it was going to be some runway bit. "Fuck," he thought, "Sam never needs an excuse to take his shirt off. He's probably doing to come out in a black leotard. Still, at least it will be tight." Once the curtain dropped, Will turned that frown upside down. "That's my little whore," he thought as he saw Sam had thankfully (though unnecessarily) excluded a shirt from his wardrobe. He looked as though he was in bondage gear. Later that night, Will would be jacking off to the thought of Sam in a sling.
And Ryder was in a cage. Will was a little disappointed to see that he was somewhat clothed and in heavy makeup. Still, Will could work with those exposed pecs caged up. He was a bit confused by Marley's outfit. He got the reference that she was dressed up like Gaga in a green sequin suit jacket and awful hair but why did she bind her breasts? Then he saw Marley prance on stage in her ridiculous Katy outfit. It initially confused him and then he realized that the person he previously thought was Marley was actually Blaine.
"What the fuck?!?" Will thought. He had heard Sam talking to Blaine about a bikini earlier in the day and just assumed that Blaine would be wearing it. However, it was actually Marley that was supposed to be wearing it and she didn't even do that. He had never seen Blaine look more unattractive. To add to his growing disappointment, Artie came to the middle of the stage with his big dumb inflatable pillow, blocking Will's view of Sam, the only saving grace of this entire performance.
After the performance, the guys immediately turned on Marley. Will was pissed off at the costuming fail on Ryder's and Blaine's part and the obtrusiveness of Artie's "costume" so he joined the guys in yelling. However, he couldn't get mad at them publicly for his sexual frustration so he took it out on Marley.
Will thought that he had failed and lost out on a great opportunity to have the boys strip down an it only got worse. Before the Katy performance, he had seen Jake in the hallway in his ridiculous lion costume. Jake looked at him pitifully and Will just lowered and shook his head. Were these boys trying to permanently kill his boner? "Don't worry. We're going to go acapella for our performance. No costumes, no gimics," Jake said.
"Good," Will said, "You all seem to be needing a little...assistance with your wardrobe lately." Will said. During the Katy group's performance, Will sat with the boys and came up with the solution. He would have them do Katy's Roar as a group in as little clothing as he could get away with in a high school.
Before going into give his closing lecture for the week, Will stopped by the costuming department. He needed to make sure the boys weren't going to mess this up with their proven poor costume choices. He found four loin cloths for his four favorite boys. Artie would never agree to go shirtless so he grabbed a safari outfit to appease him. Will threw together some nonsense for the girls in order to keep up appearances but it didn't matter since they would pick out their own costumes anyway. He just wanted to make sure the boys were wearing next to nothing.
He grabbed the crotch of one of the loin cloth bikinis. It was leather. He put it up to his nose and took in the musty scent. He hoped one of the guys would go commando in it. Out of impulse, he licked it slightly. It tasted salty already. He could imagine how it would be damp with sweat after their upcoming athletic performance.
Suddenly, Will saw movement out of the corner of his eye and heard footsteps walking away. He dropped the costume and quickly followed the steps out to the hallway. When he got there, he saw Bree, Sue's latest trampy henchwoman. She was heading right to Sue's office. Will knew this would be a problem.
When Sue came into the choir room during Will's final speech, he wasn't surprised but he was dismayed. He was wondering what Bree saw, what she told Sue, and what Sue was going to do about it.
Sue declared that costumes were forbidden. "Fuck," Will thought. "Bree must have saw everything and reported it all to Sue." Sue was coming off as a killjoy but she was probably just concerned about what Will had planned. Will stared her down to remind her that he had dirt on her as well. If she was to report him for inappropriateness, it would be mutually assured destruction for the two of them. But Sue knew how to play the game. She suspended each of the kids. Will saw his plans flying out the window and nothing but the palm of his greased-up hand and a vision of Sam in bondage to keep him company for the foreseeable future. Fortunately, his group was stubborn and willing to put on one more performance before leaving the school which brings Will to the back of the theater again, where he liked to sit and stroke underneath the table when the boys were at their sexiest.
And they were perfect. Sam had pulled his hair back so it didn't flop around his face. Blaine swung on the ropes upside down and Will got a little peek under the waist of his loin cloth. Ryder and Jake joined the two upperclassmen and looked developed beyond their years. And all four guys were barefoot which just delighted Will. He didn't necessarily have a foot fetish but if anything was going to lead to one, this was it. He'd already told the guys he wanted to talk to them alone after the performance. Artie had excused himself from the situation, saying he had to leave with Kitty. Will knew that already but he acted disappointed. But with his plan finally coming together, he was finally hopeful for the first time in a long time.
To be continued...
*Thanks for reading and I hope you liked it. I plan to write more and the future stories will definitely have sex. I just thought that this whole episode felt like foreplay. Any comments or suggestions can be sent to crisintel(at)yahoo.com. Xoxo
P.S. Please consider donating to nifty to keep this archive of stories going strong http://donate.nifty.org/donate.html