Summary: With Johnny Bananas out of the picture, Paulie aims his sights on another cocky Challenge Champion, Jordan Wiseley.
The Challenge castmembers returned to the house following the elimination ceremony.
"Damn, can't believe Bananas is already gone.." Jordan Wiseley said to his girlfriend Tori Deal. The two Challengers had been dating for a couple years now and they were hoping to come onto the show and win it together. Like Bananas, Jordan was a Challenge Champion and one of the most respected competitors in the game. Knowing that he had a target on his back, and that rookies were already making big moves, Wiseley was determined to get some power and turn the game in his favor. Turning back to Tori, he reached down and gripped her hand, "One of us has to win the next Daily."
The day arrived for the next Daily Challenge and despite the best efforts of their competition, the power couple managed to come out on top with Tori finishing in first place. She would be choosing the next two castmembers to fight it out in elimination. Jordan was pumped that his girl pulled it off, excited to get back and start strategizing with her.
"You killed that shit today, that's my baby!" exclaimed Jordan to Tori as the cast arrived back at the house. He wrapped his hands around her and pulled her close, their lips meeting in a passionate kiss. The power couple made out with each other for some time, lost in their own world until a voice brought them back to reality.
"Ahem" blurted out Paulie, smiling as the couple broke the kiss and turned to him with annoyed looks on their faces.
"What the hell do you want Paulie?" Jordan said while rolling his eyes before turning back to Tori, "Can't you see we're kinda busy here?"
"Of course, I just wanted to congratulate Tori for kicking ass today." the rookie replied, reaching over to put his hand on her shoulder, "I know we don't know each other but I'd love to talk game with you. I think we could help each other out."
Jordan scowled when he saw Paulie's hand on his girl's body, quickly reaching up to shove it away, "She doesn't need your help, she's got me, and you can't do better than that."
Tori put her hand on Jordan's chest to calm him down but secretly she was turned on that he was defensive of her. "Relax babe, we don't have many allies in this game, I want to hear Paulie out."
"Seriously?" Jordan scowled before sighing, "Fine, but I'm going to be part of the conversation.."
"Why? Don't think Tori can handle herself?" shot back Paulie quickly with a smirk on his face, noticing the annoyed twitch in Jordan's eyes.
"Don't worry I'll fill you in later. What's the worst that could happen?" Tori said to Jordan calmly, letting go of his hand and walking towards the nearby side room. "Let's make this chat quick Paulie, I don't want to keep my man waiting!"
"Of course not!" Paulie grinned following behind Tori, turning back one last time to wink at Jordan. "Don't worry I'll be a real gentleman!" the rookie said before closing the door behind him leaving Jordan standing there alone.
---An hour later
Jordan was sitting on the bed in his room wondering what was taking Tori so long, a strategy conversation with a rookie shouldn't be more than a few minutes. Just when he was about to go check it out, Tori walked in the room with a strange look on her face.
"Tori, what the hell took so long? You didn't tell him our plans did you?" Jordan blurted out while remaining seated on his bed.
Tori stood there for a moment before shaking it off and flashing a big fake smile, "Pfff of course not baby, you know I would never get played by some Big Brother rookie." She walked over to her boyfriend and lowered herself onto his lap, mounting him and leaning her mouth in close to his ear, "Why would I play the game with some boy like him when I have a man like you mhmmmphh."
Jordan wanted to question Tori more but her hot breath on his ear and neck lowered his guard. Fuck he couldn't get enough of this woman. Reaching up he gripped her chin and brought her mouth to his, passionately kiss her before pulling off and growling "And don't you ever forget it."
"Mmmhm never will baby" Tori moaned, pushing him down so that he was on his back on the bed with her body on top of him. She ran her hands all over his muscled body while they made out, breaking off the kiss to flash him a sexy look, "You know since I won the Daily that means I have all the power, over the game, and over you."
"Oh yeah?" Jordan laughed, playing along with Tori, "And what are you going to do with all that power babe?"
"Whatever I want to you!" Tori giggled, quickly reaching over to the nearby desk and pulling out some rope. With a quick move she grabbed Jordan's arms and brought them behind him before wrapping them with the rope, tying them to the back headboard. Not satisfied, she reached down and ripped his shirt off before yanking down his shorts & briefs, leaving her muscled boyfriend totally naked and tied to the bed.
Jordan could've stopped her from tying him but he was too turned on to fight it. Usually he was the dominant one in bed so he thought he'd let Tori take control for a change before he reminded her who the real alpha was. His cock was already getting hard just from looking at her, "You got me babe, I'm all yours."
"All ours actually.." a male voice rang out from the doorway before Paulie emerged with a satisfied smile on his face, striding through the room and standing next to Tori as they both exchanged a look.
"What the fuck, Paulie?! Get the fuck out of here!" Jordan barked in surprise, instinctively pulling on the ropes and trying to cross his muscled legs to hide his boner.
"Why would I leave? Tori invited me, isn't that right girl?" said Paulie with a sinister tone while reaching over to grip Tori's ass and pull her close to him.
"Mmhmm it's true Jordan, I did.." Tori giggled and ran her hand over Paulie's chest. Moaning when he pulled her in for a kiss, letting his tongue slip into her mouth and take control.
"Hey get your hands off her! Don't you dare!" Jordan yelled in pure shock, thrashing around in his binds making his rock hard cock slap against his thighs. The love of his life was passionately making out with a Big Brother rookie and there was nothing he could do about it. "What the FUCK is going on?!"
Paulie pulled off Tori and took in the sight of Jordan's angry and confused face. Wanting to fuck with him more, Paulie lowered his hand and slid it down inside of Tori's shorts and panties, groping her pussy, "Mhmm fuck girl it's still wet from our little strategy chat, you like having a real man's cum in there don't you slut?"
"Mmhmm fuck yeah daddy!" Tori moaned while throwing her head back, letting Paulie run his fingers all over her leaking pussy lips.
"Tori...Tori..look at me!" Jordan pleaded, still trying to process what was happening, "You're throwing away our relationship for this rookie asshole?!"
"You better believe it 'Champion' hahaha." Paulie laughed as he continued to finger Tori, "All it took was a few minutes alone with a real man and your girlfriend here was desperate for my dick." Wanting to take this farther, the Big Brother star pushed Tori down onto the bed next to the bound Jordan and then yanked down his own shorts to expose his 9in cock. Tori also ripped off her shorts and panties to reveal her still leaking cunt. With a smirk, Paulie crawled on top of her and lined his hard dick up and sank it back inside her wet pussy. "Fuck yeah girl you can't get enough of this dick can you?" Paulie groaned from above while looking over at Jordan, maintaining eye contact while he thrust inside of the Champion's girlfriend.
"I'll fucking kill you!" shouted Jordan in rage, violently yanking at the ropes but unable to get loose. Here he was, a Challenge Champion, being cucked by a Big Brother rookie. Despite his anger, he couldn't look away, eyes glued to the image of Tori spreading her legs and moaning while Paulie railed into her. The worst part of all of this for Jordan was knowing deep down that he had never made Tori this satisfied, she never moaned like this for him. The complete humiliation was fucking with the cocky veteran's brain, horrified to look down and see that his own erect dick was leaking pre-cum on his abs. Tears of shame began to form in Jordan's eyes thinking about how Paulie brought down his relationship and degraded him beyond belief.
"Oh god, fuck me Paulie, you're twice the man Jordan is ughhh mhmmm!" Tori screamed while desperately grinding her pussy back on Paulie's crotch. Her eyes rolling back with each thrust, totally consumed with lust. She didn't even fight it when Paulie shoved her over on top of Jordan's bound body and continued to fuck the shit out of her. Jordan tried to talk sense to her but his words couldn't get through the lustful haze in her head as Tori continued to moan like a total slut while the rookie fucked her against her boyfriend's torso.
Paulie couldn't help but grin watching Tori bounce up & down while pressed against her cucked boyfriend Jordan. The Big Brother star wanted to cum right there but had bigger plans for these two sluts, pulling out of Tori's pussy with a sigh. "Haha see that Jordan? See how wet my dick is with your girl's cunt juice?!" Paulie sneered while shoving Tori out of the way so that he could crawl up to Jordan and wave his prick in the cocky Champion's face. He smeared his soaked shaft all over Jordan's cheeks, lips and forehead, "Smell your girl's pussy on my dick, you want to taste it don't you cuck?"
"Ughh...get the fuck away from me..mhmm" groaned Jordan while Paulie's big wet cock rubbed all over his face coating it with pre-cum and cunt juice. The smell worked its way up his nose and began to fuck with his head. The Champion's resistance wavering as his body was exhausted from struggling in the rope while his cocky attitude was destroyed from the sheer humiliation of it all. He wanted to taste it so bad. Unable to resist anymore the veteran hesitantly stuck out his tongue slowly until it made contact with Paulie's prick, the taste immediately hitting him hard. Jordan's mind went blank, pausing for a second as the realization set in that all he wanted was more. Giving in, he began to hungrily lap on the big dick in front of him, running his tongue all over it trying to get as much flavor as possible, slobbering like a total cockslut, "MMphhhm mmmphphhh ughh why does this taste so good..mhmmhph mmphh"
"That's it 'Champion', give in to a real man just like Johnny Bananas did earlier. All you Challenge Champions are just secret bitches in disguise" Paulie sneered from above, thrusting forward to push his cock into Jordan's slobbering mouth. The veteran didn't resist, welcoming the intrusion and letting it spread his lips wide as it drove deeper & deeper. With a smile Paulie reached over to Tori and brought her head in close to watch her man slut out for cock. "See that Tori, your 'man' is just a cuck for a real alpha, both of you are my bitches now!" the rookie exclaimed, forcing Tori's hungry mouth to his dick so that the "power couple" were both worshiping it.
"Mmmhmm doesn't it taste good Jordan?" moaned Tori as she licked all over Paulie's shaft while her man slobbered on his big purple cockhead. She reached up and grabbed Jordan's hair before forcing him down hard all the way, filling his throat with Paulie's prick making him choke "GURGGGGLFFF!" Seeing her man Jordan gagging on cock just made her hornier, still gripping his hair and thrusting his head up and down. After a few minutes of the violent throatfucking, Tori finally released her grip letting Jordan come up for air while she leaned in. Both of their tongues colliding with each other while they worshipped the Big Brother dick together. Their faces were covered in saliva as Paulie made a mess of them, driving his cock between their lips.
"Oh fuck, you two really do make a good team ughhh, a true power couple worshipping me together!" Paulie groaned watching the two veterans slobber all over his big dick. There was still one thing left to do to ensure that they were completely broken. Pulling out his cock, Paulie repositioned himself near Jordan's toned legs running his fingers over his thighs. "It's time to cement your position as my bitch Jordan. Help me out here Tori" ordered the rookie while snapping his fingers. He watched as Tori moved near him and grabbed her boyfriend's legs, spreading them out and lifting them back to expose his tight virgin hole. "Thatta girl!" Paulie exclaimed as he lined his cock up with Jordan's asslips and slowly pushed inside.
"Ughh..wait...Tori don't help him ughh..stop..OH FUCKKKKK" moaned Jordan weakly while his girlfriend held his muscled legs up in the air and Paulie thrust inside. A yelp escaped the once cocky veteran's lips from the intrusion, it felt like he was getting split in half but for some reason it just made him hornier. The farther Paulie got inside of him, the more pain & pleasure filled his body until he couldn't think straight anymore. "Ughh oh fuck, it's so big, ughhhh shit I'm really getting fucked by a rookie?! This is so humiliati--uGHRHGHH!"
Jordan's groans were just motivation for Paulie to fuck the Champion harder, slamming inside deep at a rapid pace. "That's right bitch, you take cock even better than your girlfriend!" taunted the rookie while he railed into the veteran's already ruined hole. "You're gonna say that your my bitch just like Johnny Bananas did, you got that?! Say it!"
"Oh fuckkk ughhhhh" whimpered Jordan as Paulie's pace picked up. He couldn't resist anymore, the rookie had bested him in the most degrading way possible and there was no going back. Giving in to his lust, Jordan began to moan uncontrollably like a total slut, "Ughh Paulie fuck me!" he shouted out, "I'm your fuckin bitch, you own this ass!" Those were the only words that Jordan could form before the moaning took back over. His slutty groans got so loud that Tori had to shut him up by planting her wet pussy on his face while still holding his legs in the air. Totally submissive now, Jordan hungrily lapped Paulie's cum from his girlfriend's cunt, slurping up as much as he could.
The admission of Jordan's defeat turned Paulie on just as much as Johnny's did earlier. His big cock pulsed inside of the disgraced Champion's hole until one last thrust made it burst, flooding the veteran with cum. "Oh fuckkk yeah, filling up your pussy just like I filled up your girlfriend's ughh shittt" Paulie moaned out loud as he pulled out, taking in the image of Jordan's destroyed hole leaking out semen. He turned to Tori and pulled her over to him, making out with her again on top of the exhausted body of her boyfriend. "Mhmmm I want more of that pussy, you're coming with me to my bed tonight while your cuck boyfriend stays bound here" ordered the rookie as he stood up and led Tori out of the room leaving Jordan alone in his binds.
"Ughh wait..please fuck me more Paulie...don't leave me here ughhh" Jordan whimpered out in the empty room while the sounds of Paulie's cruel laughter echoed from down the hall.
-----------The Next Day (elimination)
Once again the crowd gathered around the Elimination arena waiting to hear who Tori was sending in. They could tell from the setup that it was going to be a Pole Wrestle elimination where two competitors would grip a small metal pole and try to fight it out of the hands of the other. Jordan hung his head in shame still trying to process how Paulie had turned him into a total cuck. Thinking it couldn't get any worse, he watched his girlfriend step up to make her announcement.
"I came here with Jordan to win this game together but I now understand that he's not man enough to do that." Tori announced to the cast as they stood there in confusion. "Because of that, I will be voting him in against Fessy in this elimination."
The whole cast gasped in shock, no one expected Tori to vote in her own boyfriend, especially against Fessy who stood tall at 6'5 of beefy muscle. Jordan's heart sank, Paulie really had taken everything from him - his pride, his dignity and his woman.
Fessy and Jordan marched into the middle of the arena and gripped the metal pole. The host TJ Lavin sounded the whistle and both men sprung into action, aggressively trying to rip the pole from the other's hands. Jordan was one of the best competitors on the show but even he couldn't conquer Fessy's huge size in this elimination. The bigger man thrashed Jordan around the ring and made quick work of him, easily yanking the pole away. Within seconds the elimination was over and Jordan was lying in the dirt defeated.
The cast stood there once again shocked that another Challenge Champion had been sent home back-to-back. Jordan slowly rose to his feet, turning to the crowd hoping to see that Tori was saddened by his loss only to see her with Paulie passionately making out with him in front of everyone. Paulie looked over at Jordan while reaching down to grip Tori's ass, "Don't worry Jordan, I'll take real good care of her!" he laughed before resuming the kiss.
A single tear rolled down Jordan's cheek as he turned and walked out of the arena to go home. Another Challenge Champion broken.