Summary: With two Challenge Champions down, Paulie sets his sights on Theo Campbell, the 6'5 British stud. ----
Theo Campbell lounged by the pool at the Challenge house, his 6'5 lean muscular body was on display in his tight pair of swimming trunks. He was one of the UK reality stars that had joined the show recently (along with Joss Mooney and Rogan O'Connor) and was ready to prove his country's superiority over the American competitors. On top of that, Theo was previously training for the Olympics Track & Field team which meant that he was going to be difficult to beat in the game, especially in the long distance running Final at the end.
While Theo was enjoying the sun in peace he heard the sound of footsteps from someone approaching, turning to see that it was none other than Paulie. "Oh great it's you, try not to make too much noise, I'm trying to relax here."
"Ay I'm here for the same reason" Paulie shot back while walking over to the pool near where Theo was lounging. "And I'd be careful..the last people who tried to give me orders were Johnny and Jordan, and look what happened to them."
"Oh is that a threat little man?" Theo laughed, not taking it seriously, "Sorry Paulie but I'm not afraid of anyone that I can wear as a backpack."
The Big Brother star rolled his eyes before leaning down and putting his hand in the pool. "Come on now Theo I'm just here for a good time" said Paulie playfully while swinging his hand to splash water all over the tall British man.
"Ay! Now you're in for it!" Theo barked with a grin, rising to his feet and grabbing Paulie, towering over the smaller man. "You wanna get wet, how bout this?!" he said while shoving Paulie backwards trying to knock him into the pool. As the Big Brother star fell he maintained his grip on Theo, pulling him down with him, both men crashing into the water together.
The two Challengers playfully wrestled in the pool, slamming against the wall and trying to dunk and splash each other. Theo's height gave him a huge advantage and it wasn't long before he had Paulie pinned down on the submerged steps in the shallow end of the pool. Both men were laughing and exhausted as the taller stud held the Big Brother star in place while catching a breath. Taking advantage of the break, Paulie leaned forward and planted his mouth right on Theo's, slipping his tongue between the British man's lips.
"Mmmphhh" Theo groaned out in surprise, eyes wide from the intrusion. For some reason he went along with it, kissing Paulie back before pulling off to stare down at him, "Is this your way of tellin me you wanna be my slag? Was gonna go for one of the ladies but hey, you're about the same size..ahhhhh". Before the British man could finish, Paulie runs his tongue down his neck and starts sucking on his right nipple while tweaking the other with his fingers.
"Mmhmm do the ladies treat you like this?" Paulie said between licks, prodding Theo's sensitive nipple with his tongue before taking it into his mouth, sucking and chewing lightly on it. Theo was already moaning like crazy, looks like Paulie found another weak spot in his competition. The Big Brother star switched to the other nipple, sucking on it even more until it was puffy and swollen.
"Oh fuck Paulie, that's one crazy tongue you got there damn" sighed out Theo while he let Paulie work his pecs over. Normally he would've pushed him away but the American's mouth felt too good on his sensitive nipples. The British athlete brought his hand to the back of Paulie's head, holding it in place on his chest while his moans got louder and louder. "Mmhmmh god this feels good, not sure what I should thank you for first, this Grade A worship or getting Bananas and Jordan eliminated so that I had a clear shot to the final ughh" Theo groaned, throwing his head back in lust, "Mmhhh, keep working that tongue and I might keep you around as my little cheerleader."
With Theo's guard down, Paulie took advantage and slowly maneuvered the taller man off of him, guiding Theo to sit on the edge of the pool, the lower part of his long legs submerged and resting on the pool stairs while the rest of his body was out of the water. Paulie then crawled up next to him, running his tongue up the British man's neck until he got to his ear, "You know...I did a whole lot more to Johnny and Jordan than just get them eliminated.." As the Big Brother star spoke he ran his fingers down Theo's chest and abs into his swim trunks. Gripping the UK hunk's wet cock, he slowly began to stroke it up and down while whispering dirty talk into the man's ear.
"Mhmmmm oh yea? Did you let them fuck that cute lil arse of yours like I'm about to?" Theo moaned while watching the hand stroke his cock, allowing Paulie to slip his trunks off so that he was fully naked. There was something about the way that Paulie was saying nasty shit in his ear that made Theo feel something he never felt before. He almost wanted to let the smaller man take control. "Ohhh fuckk Paulie you're driving me mad here" the British stud gasped, starting to thrust upwards into the stroking hand while Paulie's tongue darted into his ear.
"Yeah...something like that.." Paulie grinned as he ran his other hand over Theo's chest, "Damn you got one big ass body, think I could use some helping hands." Before the taller man could respond, Paulie reached up and snapped his fingers, "Hey muscle bitches, get over here!" Suddenly the two other hunky British Challengers, Joss Mooney and Rogan O'Connor, appeared from the side and walked over wearing just a tight pair of speedos with the British flag on them.
"Ughhh Joss...Rogan..what the hell are you lads doin here?" Theo groaned, still slowly thrusting into Paulie's hand in heat while the two UK muscle studs got in closer.
"Oh I bitched these two muscle sluts out a while ago, ain't that right boys?" stated Paulie while Rogan and Joss nodded their heads in agreement and lowered themselves to their knees on each side of him, "Now why don't you help me show Theo how I do things around here?" Rogan and Joss understood the smaller American's orders and began to rub their hands all over Theo's body, playing with his sensitive nipples again.
"Mmpphh this is mad, how did you get these two to act like this ughh fuckk?" Theo said between moans, the combination of Paulie's hands on his hard cock with Joss & Rogan's hands on his pecs drove him crazy. All he could do was let them have their way with his body, totally helpless to the clouds of lust filling his head. Theo was too fucking lost in the heat to resist when Paulie slowly began to lift his thighs up from the edge of the pool and expose his tight little asshole.
"You're about to find out big boy" smirked Paulie as he lowered his head and shoved his tongue inside of Theo's virgin asslips. Once inside, he darted his tongue around the inside walls of Theo's ass before finding the prostate, working it with his expert mouth. While this was happening, Rogan and Joss leaned down and each took one of Theo's nipples into their mouths, sucking hard on the already swollen buds.
Theo's eyes rolled to the back of his head from overstimulation, his tongue hanging out of his open mouth. "Ohhhhhh fuckkk yeah work my ass and pecs, ughhh feels so good" the tall British hunk whimpered, fully giving in, grinding his ass back on Paulie's face trying to get as much tongue inside as possible.
"That's it, just give in, you want this" Paulie purred as he pulled out his tongue and replaced it with one of his fingers, slowly sinking it inside of Theo's wet wrinkled asslips. The smaller man fingerfucked the British hunk for some time until Theo was an absolute moaning mess, thrusting his ass back on Paulie's hand. Knowing it was time, Paulie rose up and positioned his big hard cock right at the taller stud's entrance. "Time for me to bring down another British muscle bitch" he groaned while sinking his prick inside.
With eyes wide, Theo yelped from the anal intrusion, feeling Paulie's huge cock slowly spread his tight pucker to its limits. "OH FUCK! Wait..wait..you can't...I shouldn't want this...ughhhhh" the British hunk said through moans. He tried to lift himself away but Rogan and Joss felt his movement and lightly sank their teeth into his nipples. This sent Theo's head into a lustful overdrive, totally wiping out his last resistance as he crashed back down, leaning there with his huge body totally helpless and in their control. Paulie's dick went deeper and deeper until it was all the way inside, pulsing against the once tight walls of the taller man's ass.
Paulie could see Theo's mind breaking in front of him, giving in more and more with each thrust. Wanting to cement Theo as his new bitch, Paulie grabbed both of the UK hunk's long legs and brought them over his shoulders while he railed his cock in and out at a rapid pace. He loved the sight of Theo's massive body bouncing up and down on his dick like a total cockwhore. "Haha another cocky Challenge boy put in his place, you British bitches sure know how to take dick" the smaller man sneered from above.
"Ughh Ughhh fuckk oh...fuck...fuck meeee" Theo cried out uncontrollably. He knew how ridiculous he looked on his back with his large legs wrapped over Paulie's shoulders but he didn't care anymore, he just wanted cock. Theo was too fucking horny that he didn't even fight it when Joss and Rogan pulled their mouths away from his nipples and then put both of their cocks in his face. "Mhmmm fuck me Paulie, fuck my slutty British hole mhmm ughh-mmhmphh" groaned Theo before opening his mouth more to let Joss slide his shaft inside. The taller man bobbed his head up and down on the prick before switching to Rogan's, taking turns sucking on each dick.
The image of Theo slobbering on cock like an absolute cumslut just made Paulie fuck him harder. "Oh yeah bitch? You want me to cum inside you? Mark your pussy as my property?!" the Big Brother star barked from above, knowing that he was getting close.
"Mmmhphh ughh YES PAULIE fill me up, make me your cumdump ughhhmmhh" Theo yelped before taking Rogan's prick back in his mouth.
"Music to my fucking ears!" groaned Paulie as his dick finally exploded inside of the taller British stud, flooding him with American cum. At the same time, Rogan and Joss both came as well, coating Theo's handsome face and throat with their seed. Satisfied with his conquest, Paulie pulled his cock out of Theo's battered hole and shoved the taller man's legs off of his shoulders. "Well done boys, Theo is officially my bitch. Now why don't you two muscle sluts clean my cock off?"
Rogan and Joss immediately dropped to their knees and shoved their faces in Paulie's crotch, hungrily lapping the cum off of his big dick hoping that he would fuck them later in the night.
Theo's big body was sprawled out near the pool with cum leaking down his face and ass, "Uhhmmm give me more of that American cock Paulie ughhhh" he groaned before passing out.
-----------The Next Day (elimination)
The time had come for the third elimination round of the show, and unlike the prior two, Paulie had no control over who was going in. Cory Wharton had won the Daily Challenge and Paulie was too busy fucking Theo, Rogan and Joss to try to make any moves on Cory.
"Well boys, the rookies have had too much power so far, it's time for the veterans to get their revenge!" Cory announced to the cast as they awaited his decision, "That's why I'll be voting Paulie in against Theo, have at it boys!"
"You'll regret that" Paulie barked at Cory as he walked down to the arena with Theo. There was a large box in the middle of the ring that could fit both men inside. TJ Lavin stepped up and explained that for this elimination, both competitors would start inside the box and they would have to solve a puzzle inside to re-open the doors and escape, whoever got out first won. With the rules explained, both Paulie and Theo stepped into the box with the doors closing behind them. TJ sounded the whistle letting them know that the elimination had begun.
Theo tried to focus on the mission at hand, shaking the prior day's humiliating gangbang experience from his brain. As he worked on the puzzle he suddenly felt a hand grab him and push him against the wall. "Paulie what the hell are you--oompphphh" the British hunk blurted out as Paulie ripped off his shirt and started playing with his sensitive nipples. "Ughh not here Paulie come on URGGHGG" moaned Theo.
"Uh is someone moaning in there?" Cory asked in confusion, the whole cast could hear the faint sounds of Theo groaning from inside the box.
After some time, the box door suddenly opened and Paulie emerged first victorious. A moment later, Theo came stumbling out behind him looking like absolute hell, his shirt was ripped off, his pants were around his ankles and his erection could be seen in his briefs.
"I'm not even going to ask what happened in there" TJ said while shaking his head, "Paulie, you won this elimination, congratulations."
"Thanks TJ, it was my pleasure" Paulie smirked looking over at Theo who was red with humiliation. The British stud hung his head in shame as he left the ring, going home empty-handed.
Paulie had succeeded in bringing down another cocky Challenger, and he wasn't anywhere close to being finished.