Summary: Paulie turns Cory Wharton and Nelson Thomas into his muscle bitches.
"You sure no one's around?" Nelson Thomas whispered as he was led into one of the bedrooms of the Challenge house. "Yeah, told you, everyone else is outside by the pool" replied Cory Wharton, yanking his friend into the room and pressing him against the wall, "I got you all to myself." With a sexy grin Cory leaned in and brought his lips to Nelson's, passionately kissing him and slipping his tongue inside. Both studs ran their hands all over each other, groping and massaging their ripped bodies.
"Mmhmm" Nelson moaned into Cory's mouth, letting his friend take control as usual. These two muscle hunks had been hooking up on the low for years, trying to keep it as discrete as possible while dating the women on the show. No one could make Nelson moan like Cory did and they took every opportunity possible to find an empty room and fuck like animals.
"Fuck I've been wanting that fat ass all day.." Cory whispered as he pulled off the kiss and brought his hands down to Nelson's glutes, aggressively groping his beefy butt. "You been teasin me for too damn long, I'm takin what's mine" continued Cory, smacking his lover's ass before shoving him down onto the bed. Both studs ripped off their own clothes until they were completely naked, muscular bodies on display for each other.
Nelson leaned back on the bed, flashing Cory a sexy smile as he reached down and pulled his legs up, exposing his hot asshole, "Well come and get it then.."
Cory licked his lips and dove onto the bed, burying his face into his friend's beefy ass. His tongue went to work, expertly playing with Nelson's pucker, teasing the walls of his ass and prodding at his prostate. "Mmmphhphph" Cory groaned deeply while giving his friend the tonguefucking of his life.
"Oh fuck yeah Cory eat that ass" moaned Nelson in heat, grinding his beefy glutes back on his friend's handsome face. Hooking up on the show was difficult but back at home when they had time Nelson would plant his ass on Cory's face and ride his tongue for hours.
"Mmhm tastes so good Nelly but I got somethin even better for ya" Cory said as he pulled his head away and crawled up on top of Nelson, lining his hard cock up with his friend's wet hole. Staring Nelson in the eyes, he thrust forward, slowly driving his prick inside while watching his lover's face fill with pleasure. "Damn I'll never get tired of this ass ughhh" moaned Cory while thrusting his hips at a steady pace.
"Arghhh give it to me Cory, fuck me ughh!" Nelson cried out while grinding his ass back on his friend's cock. Damn there was nothing better than this. Looking up at Cory, he leaned forward and pulled him in for a kiss. "Mhmm" both studs moaning into each other's mouths while rocking back and forth. Nelson and Cory were lost in their lust when they suddenly heard the sound of a phone camera taking a picture. Breaking the kiss, both beefy hunks turned to see Paulie standing at the end of the bed with an evil grin on his face.
"Paulie?! Yo what the fuck are you doin here?!" Cory yelled as he pulled out of Nelson and reached down to cover his crotch with his hands. Nelson did the same, both naked studs lying awkwardly on the bed with a deer in headlights look in their eyes.
"I told you I'd get you back for sending me into elimination Cory.." laughed Paulie before he looked down at his phone to see the pictures he just took, "Damn these are some good pics, can't wait to show everybody how cute you two are together." The Big Brother star let the threat hang in the air for a moment while the two veterans tried to process what was happening. "Unless...you two give me a good reason why I shouldn't leak these to everyone I know?"
"Ay you better not show anyone that shit" barked Nelson, trying to act as tough as possible for someone who was moaning like a bitch for cock just a few minutes earlier. He turned to Cory and exchanged a concerned look, both knowing how fucked they were. Nelson and Cory had both maintained reputations of being ladies men and they couldn't risk this getting out, "Ughh...what the hell do you want Paulie?"
"You know what I want Nelly?" Paulie said confidently while yanking down his pants exposing his rock hard 9in cock, "I want you and your lil boyfriend here to get on your fucking knees in front of me. Now."
"No fucking way" Cory shot back, turning to Nelson for words of agreement only to see his friend staring right at Paulie's crotch. Before he could say anything else, Nelson slowly got up from the bed and walked towards the rookie. "Nelson are you for real? You really doin this shit?" questioned Cory, trying to think of a way out of this. Watching as his friend kneeled in front of Paulie, realizing that he had no choice. With a sigh Cory lifted himself off the bed and hesitantly moved towards both of them. "Yo this shit is wild.." he said under his breath before arriving at Paulie, slowly lowering himself down to his knees next to Nelson, looking up at the Big Brother star with angry eyes.
Paulie soaked in the sight of having both naked studs on their knees in front of him. "Good boy already taking orders well" he sneered down at them while gripping his erection and slapping it across both of their handsome faces. The smaller man's mind was already racing thinking about what he was going to do to these two hunks, neither Cory or Nelson was known for being smart and it was time someone turned them out into the slutty Himbos they were meant to be. "I think you both know where this is going, time to worship daddy's dick, open up Himbo whores!" Paulie exclaimed
"Ay watch your mouth-arghh" Nelson blurted out defensively before Paulie cut him off with another cockslap. He looked over at Cory, sharing a look of hopeless frustration before turning back to the big dick just inches from his face. The musk from Paulie's cock was strong up close and it was already messing with their brains. Nelson couldn't resist, slowly leaning in while sticking out his tongue, running it up the shaft, "Mmphhh".
Cory was seething inside watching his lover slurp on another guy's prick, Nelson was only supposed to do that to him! "Nelly come on you gotta fight it ughhh" he groaned, the musk was really starting to get to him as well. Just when he was about to turn away, Paulie pulled out his phone and showed him the pics as a reminder of the threat. "You won't get away with this.." scowled Cory in response before letting out a sigh of defeat, inching his face closer to the dick and sticking out his tongue until it made contact. "Mmmphh" he slurped, not wanting to admit that it tasted good while the musk took more of an effect. Both studs began to lick the juicy shaft more and more until their tongues collided which just made them hornier. "MMphh Nelly mpphh" Cory moaned before he started to hungrily slobber all over Paulie's cock and Nelson's lips.
"That's it boys worship my cock" Paulie barked as he reached down and gripped both Cory and Nelson by the hair forcing their heads into his crotch while he thrust forward, driving his shaft between both of their big lips. The rookie did this for some time, enjoying the slobbering sounds coming from the kneeling hunks. Wanting to switch it up he pressed Nelson's head down to his heavy ballsack, letting him slurp all over his nuts. "Open up Cory, I'm gonna ruin that throat" ordered Paulie, thrusting forward as his big dick entered Cory's mouth, spreading his lips to their limits. Cory looked ridiculous trying to take the whole thing, cheeks ballooning wide, tears forming in his eyes, drool dripping out his stretched lips.
"GURGGGGLFF" Cory choked hard in response from Paulie relentlessly fucking his throat. He previously had sucked Nelson's dick a few times but it was never this aggressive. "MMPGRGUGGLFFF" the muscular ladies-man wretched again, more slobber leaking down his chin, humiliated at the noises he was making while he tried to keep up with the Big Brother star's pace. Wanting to give his throat a break, Cory pulled off with a slurp, coughing to the side and breathing deep as he held his sore neck. "Ughhh cough I'm done with this shit, I'm not anyone's fuckin cumwhore" he said before lifting himself off the ground to stare Paulie face-to-face, wiping away the tears and drool that coated his cheeks and chin.
"Oh, is that so? Guess I'll have to show the world that you and Nelly here are a whole lot more than just friends" Paulie shot back, already seeing Cory's resistance waiver from the reminded threat, "Not sure your ladies-man reputation will survive once this leaks." Cory sighed and hung his head in shame, knowing that he had no way out of this. Paulie took the stud's silence as his answer, "That's what I thought, looks like I'm gonna have to break your will the old-fashioned way, by bitching out that hot ass of yours." With a quick move, the smaller man pushed Cory down onto the bed, leaving the muscular hunk lying on his back. "At least one of you knows how to take orders.." Paulie continued while looking down at Nelson still slurping hungrily on his sweaty balls. "Get up slut, I want you on the bed too, both of you on all fours. Now. I want to see those muscle glutes presented to me like the sluts you are."
"Mmmphh" Nelson groaned, pulling his head from Paulie's crotch and crawling up on the bed next to Cory. Both studs got on all fours facing away from the rookie, propping up their beefy asses for display.
"Mmhmmm this is what I'm talkin about!" exclaimed Paulie as he crawled onto the bed behind them, licking his lips in hunger. He turned to Cory and brought his hand down hard on his right asscheek making the muscle stud yelp in pain. SMACK "Cory you might be a top for this slut over here but I'm gonna turn you into a total power bottom bitch you hear me?" the Big Brother star sneered while continuing to spank the ladies-man, making Cory's fat ass jiggle with each hit. SMACK SMACK SMACK Wanting more, Paulie ran both of his hands over each set of glutes before sliding a finger inside each hole. Nelson and Cory immediately groaned in response to the intrusion while the Big Brother star fingerfucked them. Nelson took it pretty easily, already warmed up from his friend's dick, but Cory was struggling much more, never having been fucked in his life. "Damn Cory you're tight as fuck, been waiting on a real man to pop your cherry huh? Well you found one!"
"Oohhhhh fuckkkk" Cory whimpered, unable to believe this was happening. His thick beefy thighs were already quivering while Paulie fingered his tight hole. To make things worse, he could feel his own cock hardening in response, his brain starting to tell him that he wanted this, "Uughhhh."
With both studs moaning like crazy, Paulie knew it was time to take it up a notch. He reached down into his bag on the side of the bed and pulled out a large 9in vibrating buttplug, holding it up for the two muscle hunks to see. Cory's eyes twitched when it came into view, his beefy body quivering with nerves. "Ha don't worry Cory, this one's not for you" the Big Brother star laughed before quickly shoving the entire length of the buttplug up Nelson's loosened hole. Paulie smirked hearing Nelson moan loudly from the intruder before he reached down into the bag and pulled out a remote with a dial on it. "That plug is about to go crazy in your hole Nelly, and I know you want it" the smaller man taunted as he turned up the dial on the remote making the buttplug immediately start to twitch & vibrate inside. While Nelson's deep moans filled the room, Paulie turned back to Cory and lined up his own cock with the stud's virgin hole, slowly pushing inside, "Get ready, your Top days are over, from here on out you're just my big muscle bitch bottom!"
Cory yelped as Paulie's cock broke through his tight asslips and drove in deep, "Ughhhhh oh fuckkk its so big Paulie what the fuck arghhhh." He tried to keep composure but the feeling was too overwhelming, whimpers and moans escaping the stud's lips. The Big Brother star began to thrust in and out making Cory groan like a bitch every time his prostate was hit. Cory could feel his mind starting to break as desire and lust filled his body, "Damnnnn this shit is crazy ughhh"
Paulie enjoyed the sounds of both beefy hunks moaning like crazy, turning to Nelson, "Ay Nelly watch your 'Top' boyfriend take my dick, told you I'd turn him out good." The rookie railed into Cory even harder, thrusting the full length of his shaft in and out of the bigger man's guts, "So how does it feel Cory? How does it feel to be a bottom bitch?"
"Ughhh..it feels...it feels..." whined Cory in response as his brain struggled to find the words, every thrust broke him down more and more until he couldn't resist anymore, "..IT FEELS GOOD ughhhhh." He sighed out in defeat while his eyes rolled back from the pleasure, knowing he'd never be the same after this. "Just shut up and fuck me Paulie, fuck this fat ass!" Cory continued before starting to grind his beefy glutes back on Paulie in heat.
"Don't gotta tell me twice" Paulie laughed while continuing to thrust hard into the bigger man. He kept it up until Cory was a blabbering mess, moaning nonsense and twerking his butt on the rookie's dick. Wanting to see the broken look in his new bottom bitch's eyes, Paulie flipped the stud over onto his back, spread his beefy thighs and shoved his prick back inside. The rookie almost came at the sight of ladies-man Cory Wharton with his eyes rolled back, mouth open and tongue hanging out, moaning like an absolute whore for cock. "Ughh fuck this might be the best Challenge ass I've had so far, what would all the women you've slept with say if they saw you now, bitch?!"
Nelson was still on all fours moaning like crazy while the vibrating buttplug went wild in his hole, sending shockwaves throughout his muscular body. His hard cock was leaking and desperate to cum as he looked over to the side and watched Paulie turning Cory into a total bottom whore. Nelson couldn't believe that his friend was acting like this but he couldn't look away, cheering his former 'Top' on, "That's it Cory, slut out on Paulie's dick!"
"Mmhmpphh oooh fuck me Paulie! I need that cock pleasee ughh" Cory moaned deliriously while thrusting his muscle ass back on the rookie. He couldn't believe he waited this long to get fucked and now it's all he wanted, totally accepting his new role as a bottom bitch. "Arggg you own this ass Paulie, I'm just a big ol muscle bottom for your cock mhmm fuckkk. FUCK ME PLEASE!" whined Cory, his hard leaking dick bouncing with each thrust.
"Haha another Challenge buck broken, all you studs were built to take my dick!" Paulie barked down at his new bottom. Cory's asslips were clamping down so tight on his cock that he knew he was about to burst. "OHH FUCKKkk once I pump you full of my alpha cum you'll never Top again ughhh Ohhh FUCKKKKK" the rookie screamed as he finally came, filling the bigger hunk to the brim with his seed. Cory and Nelson both came at the same time as well, moaning like whores while their cocks spasmed and burst. "Damn this is definitely the best ass on this show, gonna get a lot of use out of this haha" grunted Paulie, pulling his prick out and taking in the sight of Nelson and Cory both lying there totally exhausted and used. The plug was still vibrating in Nelson's hole while the hunk groaned deeply on the bed in a puddle of his own cum.
With a smirk, Paulie reached down into his bag and pulled out another vibrating buttplug. Cory was too mindfucked to notice, grumbling and breathing heavy with his abused muscular body sprawled across the bed on his back. The Big Brother star quickly shoved the plug up the veteran stud's gaping wet hole, "Can't have my cum leaking out now can we bitch?"
"Oooooohhh" Cory whimpered in response, exhausted body spasming while moaning in heat.
"Listen Himbo sluts, both of you must keep those plugs in you at all times" he barked down at them, "If I ever see you without them, those pics leak you got that?"
"Uughhh yes sirrrr" Nelson and Cory grumbled together on the bed, totally broken.
"Good, we'll have more fun soon bitches" Paulie said as he left the room, reaching down to the remote and turning up the dial. He immediately heard the sounds of Nelson and Cory moaning like sluts from the vibrations while he walked down the hallway with a big grin on his face.
-----------The Next Day (Purge)
The day had come for the next Daily Challenge so the cast geared up and headed towards the location. When they got there, the host TJ Lavin informed them that instead of a typical Daily Challenge, it would be a Purge. A Purge was an altered version of a Daily where whoever came in last would be sent home without an elimination. TJ informed the cast that the bottom two competitors in this event would be removed from the game completely and then he began describe the rules for this Purge.
While TJ was going through the rules, Paulie was having his own fun by playing with the dial on the remote that he brought with him. Every twitch of the dial made the two buttplugs lodged up Cory and Nelson's holes vibrate, driving them crazy. Both studs stood there trying to keep composure, biting their lips while their legs slightly quivered.
"Ooohoh mhmmh ohhhh" Cory whimpered out loud, unable to keep it in. TJ and the whole cast paused to look at him in confusion as he stood there awkwardly with a strange look on his face. "Ughhh sorry guys ill stop-mhmm" he said as best he could while trying to stifle the moans.
"Uh...okay anyways, those are the rules, everyone get to the starting line of this Obstacle Course" TJ ordered before the cast nodded and got in their places. When everyone was ready, TJ blew the whistle and the cast took off.
Cory and Nelson got into game mode, shrugging off the lustful haze stemming from the vibrations in their used holes. Their muscular bodies were built to dominate games like this, easily making their way through the Obstacle Course faster than anyone else in the cast. The two studs arrived at the final stage of the Obstacle Course, a climbing wall with the finish line just over the other side of it.
"We got this Cory!" Nelson cheered out with excitement as both hunks prepared to climb the wall. All of a sudden their bodies tensed up when they felt the vibrating plugs start going crazy in their stretched assholes. Paulie was coming up right behind them with the remote in his hands, and he turned it to MAX power. The sensation was overwhelming and both studs collapsed to their knees in front of the wall.
"What...OH FUCK ARGHHHH" Cory moaned loudly feeling the buttplug vibrating intensely against his battered prostate. Uncontrollable lust ran through his body as he fell to the ground clutching his beefy ass while Nelson did the same. Both their muscular bodies spasming on the ground while their hard cocks leaked through their Challenge uniforms. "Mmhmmphh it's too much ohhhh fuckk...ughh...FUCK ME mphph" whimpered Cory, his brain turning to mush as the vibrations took control of his whole body.
"Almost made it boys!" Paulie taunted when he caught up to them, enjoying the sight of the two Challenge hunks moaning on the ground and gripping their asses in total heat, "All you have to do is not act like total cocksluts for a few more minutes and you'll finish this on time, which must be your biggest challenge yet!"
Paulie quickly climbed the wall and finished in first while the other competitors trailed in behind him until everyone besides Nelson and Cory had completed the Purge.
TJ stood in front of the cast, "Congratulations, you all made it through the Purge. Looks like Cory and Nelson are going home, where the hell are those two by the way?"
The feint sounds of Cory and Nelson still moaning like crazy behind the wall could be heard in the distance. Two more hunky Challenge stars broken down and sent home by Paulie.