Taking Down The Challenge Champs

By John Lerman

Published on Jan 20, 2024

Gay

Summary: It was time for the Final Challenge and in order to win the money Paulie would have to take down his toughest competition yet, Challenge legends Darrell Taylor and CT Tamburello.


The day had arrived for the Final Challenge.

After weeks of brutal Daily Challenges and Eliminations, three men were left standing in the game - Paulie Calafiore, Darrell Taylor and CT Tamburello. They all woke up ready to do whatever it takes to come in first place and win the prize money. CT and Darrell were both Challenge Champions and two of the most respected veterans in the game. They were around 40 years old but kept their bodies in top shape with their tall muscular frames towering over the smaller rookie Paulie. The three competitors arrived at the starting line of the Final and stood there waiting for the host TJ Lavin to appear and set things off.

"All comes down to this boys, you're about to see why I'm a 4x Champion," boasted Darrell as he looked over at the other two. He was certain that he could beat both of his competition here, especially Paulie. His muscular body bulged through his shirt and shorts showing everyone what a perfect physical specimen he was. While Darrell was stretching in preparation, Paulie's eyes were glued to his fat ass, thinking all sorts of nasty thoughts. The cocky veteran turned to the rookie and caught him in the act, rolling his eyes and speaking up, "Like what ya see Paulie? Don't worry you'll have plenty of time to stare at it when I'm way out in front of you winning this race."

"Mhmm that's not all I plan to do with it," smirked Paulie in response, "And we'll see who comes out on top.."

Before any other words could be exchanged the host TJ Lavin appeared and stood in front of them. "Well boys, welcome to the final Challenge!" he announced with enthusiasm, "This will be a two day event. The first day will start with a long footrace which will end at a puzzle, once the puzzle is done you'll begin the bike race portion which will take you to the tent you'll be sleeping in tonight. When you wake up tomorrow you'll begin your steep hike up the mountain, first person to get to the top wins the money!" TJ finished reading the rules and the three Challengers nodded their heads while getting in place at the starting line. With a smirk TJ pulled out his whistle and brought it to his lips, blowing into it to signal that the Final had begun.

All three men launched forward and began the footrace, racing down the path as fast as they could. Darrell lived up to his reputation and quickly took the lead, bolting ahead while the other two got a good view of his muscular glutes jiggling in his tight shorts with each move. It wasn't long until he was out of sight but Paulie and CT managed to match each other's paces, eventually arriving at the Puzzle area and noticing that Darrell had already completed his part before they had gotten there. The two Challengers ran to their Puzzles and tried to solve them as quickly as possible with CT finding the solution right away. Soon Paulie was left alone in last place, sighing with relief when he finally finished his Puzzle. The rookie jumped on his bike and set off on the final section of the day's race, racing through the path hoping to catch up to the veterans. Unfortunately for Paulie, he was so far behind that he never encountered the other two on the bike race, eventually arriving at the tent and seeing that both of their bikes were lying outside while they slept.

"Ughh finally.." Paulie sighed out as he dismounted the bike and entered the tent. Both Darrell and CT were fast asleep inside, lying face-down with only their briefs on, their beefy asses bulging through the material. The rookie licked his lips at the view before a lightbulb went off in his head, if he wanted to win this Final he would have to play dirty. Paulie decided that he would sleep for a few hours and then wake up before the other two to set his plan in motion. With a smirk the smaller man lied down between them and closed his eyes, these cocky veterans had no idea what they were in for.

"Mmph," grumbled Paulie as he woke up at the crack of dawn, feeling sore from the day before. Remembering his plan he sprung into action, there wasn't much time and he had to work fast. Paulie carefully maneuvered CT and Darrell's bodies into a new position so that they were lying on their sides in opposite directions with their faces in eachother's crotches. Luckily both veterans were so worn out from the first day of the Final that they continued to slumber as they were repositioned. Paulie then grabbed some rope and wrapped it around their muscular frames so that they were tied in place to one another. The rookie could've stopped there but he wanted to fuck with them more, yanking down their briefs and then carefully guiding their soft cocks into the others' mouth so that they were now 69ing each other. "That should keep you guys busy while I win this Final. But just to make sure.." Paulie whispered at the sleeping studs while he reached down and pulled out two vibrating buttplugs, bringing one over to Darrell's beefy glutes with an evil grin on his face.

"MMMMMPHHPHHHHRGHHH!" Darrell yelped into CT's crotch as he immediately woke up from the buttplug's intrusion. He went to move when he suddenly noticed that he was bound in place and had someone's cock in his mouth. The vibrating plug was spreading his asslips wide and buzzing away inside sending shockwaves throughout his muscled body. "MMurggpppff!" Darrell grunted out while squirming around, looking down to see that the cock in his mouth belonged to CT.

"Ughrghhhhmmm," groaned CT as he was stirred awake by Darrell's movement. Before he could react, Paulie quickly shoved the other buttplug inside his meaty ass making the veteran yelp in shock while it vibrated inside him. CT grunted and thrashed around in anger which just made his fat cock thrust farther into Darrell's mouth. To make things worse, he could feel his dick beginning to harden from the sensation while the buttplug ravaged his butt, "MMMPHHHHFFF!"

"Sorry didn't quite hear that, mind saying it again?" sneered Paulie from above, enjoying the view of the two muscular fathers bound and forced to 69 eachother. The rookie had grown up watching CT and Darrell on the show and always dreamed about breaking in their beefy glutes. Now he had the two alpha studs writhing naked on the floor with vibrating buttplugs lodged up their tight holes. "Now if you'll excuse me...I have a Final to win," Paulie continued, taking one last look at the humiliated faces of Darrell and CT before he turned and left the tent, beginning the mountain hike to the finish line.

"GUGHMMMPPFFF!" Darrell shouted back around CT's cock, eyes wide and fuming with anger. The buttplug was already messing with his head and every vibration made his dick stiffen even more. He could feel CT's fat cock growing in his mouth until it was fully erect, spreading his juicy lips to their limits. "MMMmmpHH," gurgled Darrell, trying to yank at the ropes hopelessly while drool dripped down his chin. To make things worse, CT was getting more and more into it, beginning to thrust his bound thighs forward driving his fat cock deeper down the other man's throat. Darrell's eyes rolled back as he was forced to deepthroat the fat prick, gags and retching sounds escaping his stretched lips. It wasn't long until the alpha veteran was whimpering on the floor, squirming his fat ass around while the buttplug went crazy inside. Darrell's eyes went wide when he felt CT's cock pulse, knowing it was about to cum, he shook his head and tried to pull off, "GURGMGMMMLFFF!!!"

-----------2 hours later

Hours later Paulie was climbing the mountain with a big smile on his face thinking that he had already won. Beaming with pride at the fact that he started this game as one of the only rookies and somehow managed to take down all of the so-called "alpha" veterans in the most humiliating ways. His mind flashed with images of his conquests - Bananas begging for cock, cucking Jordan, turning Cory and Fessy into muscle bottom sluts, forcing Darrell and CT to 69. Paulie's erotic daydreaming was cut short when he suddenly heard the sound of footsteps behind him. His heart stopped, there was no way the veterans had managed to escape and catch up to him, turning around to see the large frame of Darrell lunging at him.

"Got your ass Paulie!" Darrell yelled as he tackled the smaller man to the ground, pinning him while he stared down at Paulie. "You thought you saw the last of me didn't you?" the veteran continued before smacking the rookie across the face, "I told you motherfucker, I'm Darrell, the best there is, nothing can bring me down!" It had taken him some time to escape the ropes, long enough for CT to have cum multiple times down his throat, but he eventually broke free and set off with more motivation than ever. "After I win this Final, you're gonna pay for that shit! You know how much of CT's cum I had to swallow back there?!" Darrell ranted as he coughed some more up before wiping it from his lips in anger.

Paulie grunted on the dirty ground while looking up at Darrell. He tried to thrash around and knock the bigger hunk off him but it was no use. Realizing that he couldn't out-muscle the Champion, Paulie thought fast and lunged his hand around Darrell and forced it into the older stud's shorts. He ran his fingers down the muscular glutes until they arrived at the hole, playfully twiddling the abused asslips. Paulie could feel the damage the buttplug had done as the once-tight pucker was still struggling to fully close. "Oh yeah?! What if I do this?" the rookie sneered while he quickly forced two of his fingers inside.

"What are you doin-AGHHHHHHHHHHH!" Darrell yelped in shock, feeling his whole body give out when Paulie's fingers prodded his battered hole. He collapsed to the side, trying to focus his brain and fight back the moans that wanted to escape his lips. The vibrating buttplug had awoken something inside the veteran and now his body was betraying him in the worst way possible. His muscular frame was built to handle anything but it was helpless to Paulie's touch, Darrell groaned out "Ohhhhhh you have to stop..ummmphhh, I have to win the Final mmhmhm..I have to win the fin---oohhhh fuck meeee."

"That's right bitch, give in. You're the only one that can stop me from winning this Final but you'd rather get your pussy played with isn't that right Darrell?" sneered Paulie from above, aggressively thrusting his fingers in and out of the bigger man's swollen asslips. He twiddled Darrell's hole until the hunk was a moaning mess, lying there on his back with his legs spread. With the veteran stuck in a horny trance, Paulie took advantage and ripped off his shorts, briefs and shirt until the stud's muscular body was totally naked. The rookie grinned as he leaned down and spread Darrell's muscular thighs wide to expose his gaping pucker. "Ohhh fuck look at that ass, all those years acting like a Challenge alpha when you should've been showing that big butt off like the slut you are," mocked Paulie before he thrust his big dick inside the larger man's glutes.

"Ughhhhhhmmhm," Darrell squealed as Paulie's cock spread his asslips and sank in deep. The veteran's mind went blank and his eyes rolled back from the sensation, no one had ever made him feel like this. He tried to snap out of it but the lust took over his brain until he was moaning uncontrollably while Paulie slammed inside of him. Darrell could feel the Final slipping through his hands and he didn't care any more, he just wanted cock. Giving in to the feeling, the Champion began to grind his ass back on the smaller man's prick. "Mmmh damn Paulie, fuck me with that big dick ughhh, bitch my ass out!" Darrell moaned while slamming his glutes down wanting as much dick inside him as possible.

"Mhmmm don't gotta tell me twice muscle slut," replied Paulie as he picked up the pace, aggressively thrusting inside of the older man. There was nothing hotter than seeing a man like Darrell with his legs spread wide moaning like a total whore for cock. The rookie's new strategy for winning the Final was to fuck this stud so hard that he could barely walk. Paulie reached down and began to pinch and prod at Darrell's beefy pecs until his nipples were puffy and swollen. Brutally slamming inside of the bigger hunk until his cock was pulsing for release, Paulie moaned and continued to talk shit, "The Big Bad Darrell is really just a big cockslut isn't he? I'm gonna destroy your whole reputation that you've spent years building up, and you're gonna beg me for it!"

Darrell's eyes rolled to the back of his head from sensory overload while the rookie groped his pecs and slammed in deep, every thrust was driving the bigger hunk into a state of mindless all-consuming lust. He looked up at Paulie through dazed eyes and moaned out, "Ohhhhh fuck yeahhhh, I'm just a big muscle slut for your rookie cock!" The veteran slammed his beefy glutes back on the Big Brother star, feeling it pulse inside him on the verge of bursting. His moans turned into quivering whimpers, "Ughhh don't stop Paulie, wreck my Champion hole, you own this ass!"

Darrell's slutty begging was enough to drive Paulie over the edge, moaning out as his cock flooded the veteran's stretched pucker. Load after load pumped inside of the muscular Champion until Paulie collapsed down on top of him. "Damn bitch, your ass was even better than I imagined," he groaned, enjoying the sight of Darrell lying there in a state of sexual overload, glazed over eyes and tongue hanging out of his mouth. The rookie snapped back to reality and remembered he still had a Final to win. Paulie quickly threw on his clothes before turning back to the mindfucked veteran still lying on the ground exhausted. The Big Brother star grabbed Darrell's discarded shirt and used it to tie the bigger man's arms to the tree behind him, keeping him in place. With a smirk he left the bound Champion and raced down the path, ready to take first place in the Final.

-----------30 minutes later

"Ughh come on Darrell you gotta snap out of it, you can't let that punk win," Darrell groaned to himself as he squirmed his muscular arms around in the bondage. His brain was finally coming down from the lust-filled daze even if his beefy body was still weak. The veteran let out a sigh when he looked down and saw that his cock was still rock hard and dripping pre-cum onto his abs. As he was yanking on the tied up shirt that was keeping him bound to the tree, he heard the sound of footsteps coming closer. "Mhmh shit is that CT? Fuck he'll give me hell for this, damn whatever as long as he lets me go," Darrell muttered to himself when he looked up and realized that the footsteps were coming from three of the show's camera men who were trying to keep up with the action to film the Final.

"Holy shit..is that Darrell?!" the lead cameraman shouted as they all ran over in shock carrying their recording equipment. They couldn't believe what they were seeing, 4x Challenge Champion Darrell lying there naked and bound dripping cum.

"Ughh listen you guys gotta get me out of here, I can't let Paulie win this thing!" Darrell groaned, red with embarrassment that other people were seeing him like this. His muscular body squirming slowly, hard cock continuing to leak freely.

"Hmm I got a better idea," the first cameraman said as he winked at the others, "We've been wanting that hot ass of yours for years Darrell, and now it's ours." Two of them walked forward and each grabbed one of the Champion's muscular legs, lifting them and bringing them back towards his upper body. Darrell squirmed weakly as they did this while his legs were spread to their limits, exposing his gaping and leaking asslips. The lead cameraman smirked and aimed his camera at the veteran's hot ruined muscle ass, "God damn wait until the audience at home sees that Darrell is nothing but a cumhungry muscle bitch." He continued to film the groaning stud's glutes, capturing the swollen pucker quivering open and close, leaking cum with each movement.

"Ughh..no..you can't do this to me fuckkk.." Darrell groaned while he helplessly watch two of the camera crew lift his muscled legs into the air and raise them back. His face flushed red with humiliation when the camera came into view, knowing it was getting a good view of his dripping mancunt. He couldn't believe this was happening and worst of all his dick was still leaking, once again feeling that lustful haze fill his brain.

"Oh shut up slut, you'll take any cock you can get won't you?" the lead camera man sneered, still filming as he reached down and ran his hand all over the Champion's muscular glutes. Molesting the meaty buns before his finger crawled down into the crevice and slowly circled his swollen asslips. The camera guy tickled and prodded the quivering pucker until his fingers finally sank inside of the wet hole. Darrell was groaning the entire time, weakly squirming his beefy legs around in the other men's grips. The camera was still aimed at the action, showing the fingers easily thrust back and forth inside of the muscular man's ruined mancunt. "These fingers aren't enough for your bitch ass are they? You need to be treated like a total fucking cumdump don't you?" he barked as he aggressively fingerfucked the once alpha Challenge Champion.

Darrell did his best to muffle the groans but it wasn't long until the broken stud was moaning like an absolute slut. "Ughh fuck it feels too good man mhmm," he moaned, feeling his body once again give in. Paulie had broken something inside of him and he could never go back to what he was. The Challenge Champion began to whimper shamelessly while he bounced his glutes back on the camera guy's fingers, hard cock slapping his abs, "More mmhmm I want more ughh fuck my muscle ass please, make me your bitch ughh!"

"God damn what a cockhungry pig you are Darrell, I've been filming this ass for years and now I get to fuck it!" the lead camera guy announced while he pulled out his fingers and replaced them with his hard prick, slowly pushing into the gaping hole. His cock easily sank inside of the sloppy mancunt and sloshed around as it thrust in & out. The other two camera guys each held Darrell's legs with one hand while using the other hand to pull their cocks out and smack them across the Champion's handsome face. "Fuck this hole feels good, you were born to be a muscle slut Darrell" the lead moaned, slamming his cock in and out of the broken stud, "Suck their dicks now bitch, we're gonna have you leaking cum from every hole you got!"

"Ughh..wait...ughhmmh fuck feels so good ughh," Darrell groaned deliriously, feeling their big cocks smacking his face, smelling their sweaty musk. Totally mindfucked, the Champion sighed and opened his mouth, taking one of them inside and slurping all over it. "Mmhm mhmhhm," Darrell moaned around the big prick stretching his lips while thrusting his beefy ass back on the others' crotch. He switched back and forth between the two dicks in his face, slobbering all over them and deepthroating each one. "GURGGGLFF MHMHM GUFLF" the Challenge Champion choked, looking like a total slut with his lips stretched wide around dick, cheeks ballooning and eyes wide.

"That's it bitch, this is the best Final Challenge yet! Wait until the audience back home sees the biggest stud on the show being filled with cock!" the lead cameraman exclaimed while slamming his prick deep inside of the veteran Challenger. He made sure the camera caught all of the action, getting a close up of his dick thrusting into Darrell's battered hole before guiding it upwards to show the muscled hunk choking and slobbering on the two cocks in his face. With the camera aimed at the Champion's face, the camera guy barked orders, "Now tell the audience what a big slut you are!"

"GURGGLGFFF," Darrell choked on the huge cock filling his throat as he looked up at the camera through glazed over eyes. Knowing that this video would soon be broadcast on TV for all to see, wrecking his reputation as a respected Challenge Champion, just made Darrell hornier. He popped his mouth of the prick with a slurping sound and spoke at the camera in his face, "Mmhmm fuckkk, it's true, I'm just a huge muscle bitch for cock like all the other Challenge Champions ughhmmh please don't stop fucking me arghhh." When Darrell was done speaking he immediately took the other dick back in his mouth while thrusting his beefy glutes back on the prick filling his guts, totally consumed by lust.

-----------Elsewhere in the Final

"There's the finish line, I see it!" Paulie exclaimed to himself as he finally completed his ascent to the top of the mountain for the Final. The rookie was exhausted but filled with pride when he saw the Challenge host TJ Lavin standing there beside the flag. With CT and Darrell nowhere in sight, Paulie jogged down the path leading to the finish line, crossing it with his arms in the air, cementing his victory. "Hell yeah! That's how it's done!" the rookie exclaimed in celebration, he had taken down some of the Challenge's biggest legends to get here, and now the money was finally his.

"Congratulations Paulie, you've won the Final and the cash prize," TJ announced as he walked over to the rookie, putting his hand on his shoulder, "That officially makes you a Challenge Champion, welcome to the club."

Paulie grinned when the host called him a Champion, "You're damn right I am TJ, the best there's even been!" The Big Brother star reached down and gripped his crotch while staring at the Challenge host, "Now why don't you cement my victory by sucking my cock like all of the other Challenge sluts?"

TJ's eyes went wide for a second before they looked down at Paulie's impressive bulge. Unable to resist, the host sank to his knees right there at the finish line, staring straight at the new Champion's crotch. TJ couldn't believe he was about to do this but something felt so right as Paulie fished out his hard sweaty cock and rubbed it all over the face of the show's host. With a sigh, TJ gave in and opened his mouth, letting Paulie fill his throat, "MMMRGUGLFFFF," he groaned out trying to take it all, slobbering like a pig all over the big dick, "MMMphhhmmmm."

-----------30 minutes later

"Did you really have to fuck me before you untied me?" Darrell said to CT as he stumbled behind him on the mountain trail. He was thankful that he was finally free from the bondage, but that was only after all three camera guys and CT blew their loads inside of him. His clothes were too ripped up to wear so the hunk was forced to finish the Final totally naked, an endless stream of cum dripping down his thighs from his ruined hole.

"Come on you know I couldn't resist that big ass," CT laughed before reaching down to smack Darrell's exposed ass, watching the bubble butt jiggle from impact. Both men finally reached the top of the mountain and saw the finish line with no sign of anyone else around. Using their last bits of energy they bolted towards the flag as fast as they could desperate to win. Darrell normally would've won but his muscular body was so worn down that CT easily took the lead and made it to the finish line first. "Fuck yeah, I won!" CT exclaimed, laughing as Darrell finally caught up when he suddenly realized that TJ wasn't around like he usually was. "Hey where the hell is TJ-oh my god..." continued CT before he stopped dead in his tracks when his eyes suddenly noticed that TJ was nearby, down on his knees enthusiastically sucking Paulie's cock.

"Hey losers," Paulie laughed while thrusting forward into TJ's mouth making the Challenge host gag. He reached down and gripped TJ's hair, forcing him all the way down so that his throat was totally filled. "There's a new Challenge Champion in town, time for you two to show me some respect," the rookie barked at CT and Darrell, "Now get over here and worship my cock like this bitch right here!"

"Damn, he got you too TJ..." Darrell sighed before turning to CT and exchanging a defeated look. Paulie had won, he had proven that he was better than all of the previous Challenge alphas. Both veterans hung their head in shame as they walked forward and slowly lowered themselves to their knees in front of Paulie. Giving in to their new roles as bitches, CT and Darrell immediately stuck out their tongues and ran it all over the smaller man's cock while TJ slurped on the head. All three of their tongues collided with one another's until all of their handsome faces were coated in saliva.

"That's right bitches, from here on out this is my show!" smirked Paulie, taking turns throatfucking each of his new sluts. It didn't take long until his cock was ready for release, pulling out to shower the three men in cum. Darrell, CT and TJ all stuck out their tongues in heat, letting Paulie cover their faces and mouths with his seed. A nearby camera man got in close, directing his camera at the three broken Challenge studs, getting a perfect shot of their cum covered faces and glazed over eyes. Paulie laughed and slapped his wet cock against Darrell's face before turning to the camera, "Hope you enjoyed the show folks...see you next Season!"


Rate this story

Liked this story?

Nifty is entirely volunteer-run and relies on people like you to keep the site running. Please support the Nifty Archive and keep this content available to all!

Donate to The Nifty Archive
Nifty

© 1992, 2024 Nifty Archive. All rights reserved

The Archive

About NiftyLinks❤️Donate