The Big Mistake

By J C

Published on Oct 16, 2007

Gay

Disclaimer: This story is a work of fiction and contains scenes of gay sex between consenting adults. If you find this offensive, are under the age of 18, it is illegal wherever you are to read this, stop

reading now. Or hide it very well ha ha. If you are offended by harsh language, please exit this page immediately. You have been warned. This work of fiction is property of myself and may not be copied or used in any way without my express consent. All persons in this series are fictional and not real

Big Mistake By ~J~

Chapter 12:

"WHAT THE FUCK ARE YOU TWO DOING?!!!!!!"

I just barely had gotten the door open when to my astonishment I saw Max and my brother going at it on Mike's bed. Max had his 7 inch dick all the way inside my little brother. He was pounding away while Mike was grunting in response.

I won't lie to you and say that the sight didn't turn me on, because, alas, it did. My dick became as hard as a rock taking in this scene. Not from seeing my little brother getting the shit pounded out of him, but by observing another pair of guys going at it!

The two finally noticed me in the doorway, and Max quickly pulled out of Mike with a resounding plop!

"What are you doing home?!" Mike stammered while trying to cover himself.

"Well, let's see!... I think a better question is what the HELL are YOU TWO doing?!" I replied angrily.

"We were UH...!" Max stuttered pulling up his boxers.

"FUCKING! That's what you were doing! FUCKING!... How long has this been going on?!"

"We have been UH!" both responded looking at each other while blushing.

"TJ what happen!... OH! OH SHIT!" Jake said walking up behind me, as he surveyed the bedroom.

"Well?!!! Are you going to answer me?!" I snapped.

"TJ!... You weren't supposed to find out like this!" Jake whispered.

"You KNEW?!... You KNEW that they were doing this?!" I roared.

"Well,... UH,... Yeah!" Jake responded looking distraught.

"Everyone fucking knew!!! And, no one thought to tell me?!! How could you do this to me?!!" I screamed, storming out of Mike's room to my bedroom.

I locked the door before throwing myself on the bed.

Hot tears slid down my face, as I cried into my pillow.

"How could they all do this to me?! I have been in love with Max for years and now this?!" I sobbed and squeezed my pillow closer hoping to muffle my crying.

"How could Mike take him away from me? Did Jake know about this from the beginning?"

My thoughts were interrupted by a soft knock on the door.

"TJ can I come in?" Mike whispered through the door.

"Go away!!!" I bellowed.

"Come on TJ! Please let me in!"

"Fuck off!!!"

"Don't do this TJ!! You weren't supposed to find out like this!"

I leaped off of my bed and threw open my door breaking my lock.

"What?!! You mean find you getting fucked by my best friend!!! The man I love?!!"

"TJ! I- I...!"

Suddenly, we saw a figure looking like Jake rushing past us and down the stairs.

"Shit!!!!" I exclaimed.

I pushed Mike out of the way and ran after Jake!

"Jake wait!!! I didn't mean it like that!!!" I screamed, as he ran down the street.

He turned the corner and was gone. I spent hours looking for him, but there was no trace of him anywhere! I finally walked back to the house exhausted and dreading what would be waiting for me there.

As I walked up the driveway I noticed Max's car was gone and my mom had yet to come home.

Mike greeted me, as I walked through the door and began climbing the stairs to my room.

"Did you talk to him?"

"NO!... He just kept running!... Nowm... I can't find him anywhere!!"

"TJ! I!..."

"Don't!!! Just don't'!!!...This is all your fault!!!"

I stared down at him from the top of the stairs.

"My fault!!!" Mike howled running up the rest of the steps to stand beside me at the top.

"Yes!!! Your fault!!! How long?! How fucking long has this been going on?!!"

"A year!"

Mike bowed his head.

"A YEAR?! A FUCKING YEAR?!" I shrieked throwing my hands in the air and heading toward my room.

"Yeah!!!"

"But he kicked the shit out of me!!!" I said turning around to look back at him.

"I know!! I broke up with him after he did that!!"

"And, what now! You're back together?!"

I threw myself on my bed.

"Yeah! We made up a few days after you forgave him!"

Mike lowered himself to sit next to me on the bed.

"So!... He beat me up even though he was dating you and told me he was straight even after he kissed me?!!"

"Yes!... He said that he was afraid that he's dad would get suspicious and that's what made him...WAIT!... H- he kissed you?!!!" He screeched jumping off the bed.

"And, he told me he was straight!!!"

"That son a bitch!!! He never told me he kissed you!!! When?!! When did he kiss you?!!"

Mike paced back and forth.

"It was the day he came over to apologize, right before you walked in!"

"Just wait till I see the bastard!!!"

"So,... I guess this means were both gay!!"

"Yeah! Poor Mom no grand kids!!"

He returned to sit beside me trying to calm himself down.

"Now I know why you took it so well!!"

"Well I certainly couldn't hate you for it. I would have been a total hypocrite!"

Mike smiled.

"Yeah! But, what I don't understand is why Max told me he was straight?!"

"He, UH, WE were...UH, afraid to tell you about US!"

"Why?! I mean even after I told you I was gay you still couldn't tell me?!"

"NO! I... I was afraid you'd hate me for taking Max away!!"

"Damn!!!" I thought that's exactly what I did.

"Can you ever forgive me?!"

Mike looked at me distressed.

"Well, you're my bro! I have to forgive you! But!! No going after Jake!! Do you hear?!!"

"Not a problem! I only have eyes for Max!! Well, after I kill him for kissing you!!"

Mike laughed.

"Now, what am I going to do about Jake?!"

"He'll come back Bro! He has no place else to go!"

"I know!... I just hate not knowing whether he's safe!"

"You really do love him don't you?!"

"I do! He's the world to me!"

"I'm glad to hear that!"

I heard someone other than Mike say that.

I whip my head around, and there are Max and Jake standing in the doorway. I jumped off the bed and ran over to Jake throwing my arms around him.

"OH BABY!... I'm sorry!! I'm so sorry!!"

I kissed Jake's face.

"Hush! It's OK baby!"

"NO!... I should have never..!"

"Shhh,... it's all right! Max and I talked about it on the way back over here!"

Jake gave me a light kiss on the mouth.

"You... You did?" I asked in astonishment.

"Yeah!"

"He told me how he was your first love. And, that kind of love really never dies. He also said that he would never get between us, because he sees how much we love each other!"

"And, maybe the fact that he's suppose to be dating me!!"

Mike glared at Max.

"What?! What did I do now?!"

"My room!!... NOW!!"

Mike stormed off to his room with a confused Max following close behind him. A few minutes later we here Mike scream.

"You kissed him?! You fucking kissed my brother while we were going out?!"

"No baby! It wasn't like that!... I swear! We were broken up!"

Jake and I heard Max pleading.

"So how many other guys did you make out with while we were "broken up?!!"

"None!! Baby,... I swear!! I love you!!"

"SO, if you love me so much why did you kiss him?!!"

"I... I don't know it was a mistake! That's why I pulled away!"

"And told him you were straight?!!" Mike yelled.

"Yeah!... I had to say something! Or, he would have gotten suspicious about us!"

"OH! So, that's the only reason?! So, he wouldn't find out you were fucking his little brother?!"

"NO!! Baby,... it's because I realized that I loved you!! I swear!!"

After that, there was nothing but silence coming from next door.

Jake and I figured that they were 'making up'.

Sure enough after a few seconds we heard soft moans coming through the walls.

I was surprised when I didn't feel jealous of what was happening next door.

I guess that I was over Max. I now had a wonderful man in my life that I loved with all my heart, and he loved me back!

Hey everyone sorry that It's taken me so long to get this chapter out. Thank you everyone who has been e-mail me with their support. Hope you all are having a great week love ~J~

Next: Chapter 13


Rate this story

Liked this story?

Nifty is entirely volunteer-run and relies on people like you to keep the site running. Please support the Nifty Archive and keep this content available to all!

Donate to The Nifty Archive
Nifty

© 1992, 2024 Nifty Archive. All rights reserved

The Archive

About NiftyLinks❤️Donate