===*===
The Peach-Pounding Peters of Peterson Hall
Chapter 14: Three's Company
===*===
Shivering through the strong, late-night chill with Buff's phone in my jeans pocket, I managed as best as I could while wandering through the parking lot for a half hour. I'd had to tell campus security that I'd needed to clear my head after driving by to question my whereabouts. I debated whether I should go back inside Peterson Hall to warm up. If only I could see Jerrick or even Twunky.
I sighed. Twunky. I still couldn't believe he had feelings for me. Was he actually in love with me? Was it just a big crush? How did I feel? He was beyond hot and always so friendly and easy to get along with. But was I ready for something exclusive? Well, assuming that was what he wanted.
But Buff. Ugh, I couldn't get him off my mind. What a scary tool he'd turned out to be. I now wondered if it'd been a stupid move on my part to have stolen his phone. What if he reported me and I was searched? At the same time, I really needed to delete that video. I didn't trust that he wouldn't edit it somehow to frame me as a rapist.
An SUV pulled over to my left side, and I instantly recognized it. The passenger window rolled down, and there was Jerrick right there with Twunky in the driver's seat. I'd never imagined they'd be together looking for me.
"It's really cold out," Twunky said in a concerned tone. "Want to camp out in here instead? The three of us?"
That actually sounded like a great idea. I didn't know where else to sleep since I really didn't want to go back to Buff. "Sure, I have nowhere else to go."
"Hop in."
I opened the side door and rushed inside. I closed the door and sat on the laid-out backseat while Twunky slowly drove off. Several blankets were here this time, but the heater was on. I blew a big breath. "What's Buff doing right now?"
"Throwing a rage fit and taking it out on the other Peters," Twunky said. "I had to calm him down and tell him I'd look for you."
"Yeah, Twunky told me it's pretty bad," Jerrick said.
"Yeah, he went total psycho, and I'm honestly worried. He scares me sometimes."
"He scares me too and I hardly know him," Jerrick said. "Twunky and I bumped into each other in the lobby since I couldn't sleep. I took a shower and just hung out alone by the TV until he saw me and asked if I wanted to come find you."
"Well, I really appreciate that, guys. Thanks." Now that I had Buff's phone, I wasn't afraid to tell them the truth. Well, maybe not the whole story. "Just so you know, me and Buff really aren't together. It was an act."
"I did wonder since it seemed so fast and random," Twunky said as he parked the SUV in the parking lot of the residence hall. There was a tiny bit of illumination from the outdoor lamps around us.
I lowered my eyebrows. "We can camp here? Wouldn't campus security get suspicious as to why we're hanging out in here?"
"Nah, it's fine. I've camped out here alone whenever I needed my own space." Twunky got out of the driver's seat and crawled through the middle to reach me, followed by Jerrick. Twunky turned the portable heater on, and he sat down on my left while Jerrick sat down on my right.
"I showered too," Twunky said.
I shrugged. "I...didn't. Well, not after I fucked Buff. Didn't really think about it since it was a long and wild night."
"Yeah, I can kind of smell Buff's ass on your face." Twunky grinned.
Jerrick chuckled but didn't say a word.
"Hey, it was tasty at least," I said unapologetically.
"Oh, I know. I've eaten it plenty of times. Great ass."
"I agree."
Twunky grabbed the box of wipes he'd used when I'd fucked him earlier tonight. "Since you probably have blood on your cock, you should wipe it off soon. Might want to wipe your face too, just so that others won't smell ass all over it."
I nodded. "Good point." Blood. I couldn't believe how stupid I'd been not to consider that a possibility. I'd never been rough before. Well, not like that anyway since I'd pounded Jerrick's hot little butt before then.
Twunky got undressed, followed by Jerrick, and both were naked. Twunky grinned. "You don't mind if we sleep naked, right?"
"Not at all. I might as well too." I got undressed and took a few wipes for my cock and face. "Can't promise I won't get horny at some point, though."
"Isn't that the point?"
Jerrick chuckled but was still largely quiet. What had he been thinking about all this? Given that he seemed comfortable right now, he must've enjoyed the deflowering ritual. What an orgy that'd been. Getting fucked by six Peters. Yep, Jerrick would definitely remember it fondly forever.
After finishing, I dropped the wipes on the floor and scooted back to lie down properly. Twunky and Jerrick joined me on the either side and got under the covers with me.
I sighed. "What a night."
"I'll remember it for the rest of my life," Jerrick said.
I turned to my right to face him, smiling. "Do you regret any of it?"
"Oddly enough, no. It was fun, albeit painful at first."
"It gets better over time."
"It did get better, thanks to you hitting my prostate, or so I assume it was from what I read about it."
"It was. All that pleasure came to you like a flood."
"It did."
Twunky snuggled with me, and because I didn't want Jerrick to feel left out, I pulled him into my other arm to cuddle both hotties.
"Let's run away together and never come back," I said. "The three of us."
Twunky chuckled. "They'll track us down. The higher-ups aren't easy to fool from what I hear."
"Sounds like a nice dream, though," Jerrick said.
"It does."
"Yeah," I said. "Maybe you both can be my boyfriends one day." Had I just said that?
They laughed softly.
"As jealous as I might be, I think I'd go for it," Twunky said.
"I've never had a boyfriend, but I think I'd go for it too as long as it was just the three of us."
I wasn't really ready for anything serious, but if I had been, I'd definitely choose one of these beauties. The more I was around them, the more I liked them. Maybe I really would choose both since poly relationships could be successful. I could probably fall for both, and I already knew Twunky wanted me. Jerrick seemed like he wanted me too. Who knew?
Twunky started kissing me, which prompted Jerrick to want to have his turn until we all took turns sharing our lips, my dick growing super erect. When Twunky and Jerrick made out, it got me even hornier.
Twunky trailed kisses down Jerrick's chin, throat, chest, and flat belly. Then, he took his dick in his mouth and slurped on that monster size that still stunned me.
I made out with Jerrick while Twunky gave him a blowjob. I rubbed my nose against Jerrick's cheek, kissed it lightly, and then moved back to his lips. When Twunky switched to my dick, I rested my hand on the back of his head while I continued making out with Jerrick. Our tongues twirled around, but Jerrick was a little off pace. I was patient and had faith he'd learn how to kiss more. I loved the taste of his mouth, though. He made me horny no matter what he did.
Jerrick gently moaned through my mouth while Twunky blew him, and the more continual it was, the more I wondered if he was going to nut.
I stopped and smiled. "Are you going to shoot?"
"I'm really close."
"Fill his mouth. Nut inside it and give him your taste."
Jerrick breathed harder while his gaze was on mine.
"Yeah, make him swallow it too."
More breathing, and Jerrick's eyes grew heavier. "Oh..."
"Are you there?"
Harder puffs, faster. "I'm coming..."
Twunky's slurping sounded faster, and as Jerrick let out a soft cry of ecstasy while looking hypnotized, I could hear Twunky swallowing all that twink cum. When Twunky switched back to me, I was ready to nut so that I could get some sleep. He worked his mouth, and while Buff would always be the best one to give blowjobs, Twunky's performance was great enough to make me shoot soon.
I kissed Jerrick some more and thrust into Twunky's slurpy mouth. I nibbled Jerrick's chin and leaned toward his neck for a deep kiss and a suck. God, I really craved this beauty here beside me. He was so sweet and kind, beautiful, and sexy enough to make me go hungry so easily.
Twunky sucked away, making me close, and it was just a moment later that I flooded his mouth, grunting while being whacked upside the head by the deep pleasure from the climax.
I threw myself back on the laid-out seat and was ready to fall asleep. I could hear Jerrick giving Twunky a blowjob to make Twunky nut, but I could barely function at this point. Soon, I was out like a light...
The next morning was Sunday, or was it afternoon? I woke up and snuggled behind Jerrick, moaning from the comfort. I kissed the nape of his neck and exhaled through my nose. I didn't want to leave all of a sudden, but I knew I had to. I had to deal with Buff. I couldn't keep avoiding him. I could only imagine he was pissed that I'd never returned like I was supposed to.
Something felt off, though. Nothing from the other side was against me. I turned over and noticed Twunky gone.
Hmm.
"Twunky left?" I asked.
"I guess. I just woke up."
Maybe he had things to do. Maybe he had to stall Buff or something.
I turned back and snuggled with Jerrick some more. I could get used to this, but I knew I had to get back to Peterson Hall. I got up and started getting dressed.
"I really like it when you give me affection like that," Jerrick said as he turned to lie on his back, gazing at me with a warm smile. He looked totally enamored. Maybe he had feelings for me too.
I smiled. "I can be very affectionate when I want to be."
"But you're like that with me a lot."
So I was. After I finished, I reached back to him and kissed his lips, ignoring his morning breath. I made out with him for a while, getting horny again. "Maybe because you make me that way."
"I don't try to."
"It's your charm."
Jerrick let out a chuckle. "Oh, is it now?"
I rubbed my nose against his and just smiled, our eyes boring into the other. Then, we kissed some more. I honestly couldn't get enough of him. I could easily lose myself in him. It was similar with Twunky, but for some reason, it seemed stronger with Jerrick. I couldn't understand why.
Jerrick broke the kiss and asked, "Can I suck and swallow you?"
I could tell he enjoyed sex now that he'd been getting it so much in so little time. It was awesome to witness because I'd only deflowered him hours ago. "Sure." I lay on my back and unzipped my jeans, and he shuffled toward me to hunch over and suck me. Despite still being so new to this, his warm mouth was awesome. I knew it wouldn't be long before I nutted in his mouth. When I did, it felt like a huge relief. Two minutes. A quickie to remember.
Jerrick swallowed all my cum, and he licked his lips and smiled. "Was I okay?"
I stroked his cheek. "More than okay. Was my cum okay?"
"Yeah."
"Really? Not even an acquired taste?"
"I don't know. I was just thinking about it coming from you. The fact that I like you helps. It was the same with Twunky last night when I swallowed him."
"You like him too?"
"I like you both. But I admit that I like you more." Jerrick's face showed it. He was smitten.
"You know, Jerrick, if we weren't in the situation we're in, you know, the club and whatnot, I'd take you out on a nice date."
He looked touched. "I would've liked that even though I've never dated before." What a cutie. He could definitely be someone I'd fall for, and I'd never cheat on him like I'd done with Leah. He had the looks and the personality, and sex with him was amazing. He was exactly what I was looking for in general. Well, Twunky too, which made it tougher because I'd want both if I could. But could a poly romance work out for us if it had happened?
Hmm.
As I lifted myself back up, I remembered that I still had Buff's phone. I felt my pocket, and my heart stopped. Where the fuck was it? I scrambled around the SUV and looked everywhere.
"What are you looking for?"
"My phone." I didn't want to tell Jerrick the whole truth. I no longer felt safe to do so just in case he'd be threatened too. Great. Buff's phone was nowhere here. Could Twunky have taken it? No, why would he? But how could it be missing from my pocket when the pocket was deep and my jeans weren't scattered in a position where the phone would slip out?
Yep. Twunky had taken it. Why?
I grabbed my phone from the other pocket and checked the screen, realizing it was afternoon. There was a message from Twunky and another one from Buff. That meant Buff had his phone back because how else could his contact have texted me?
I sighed.
Jerrick started getting dressed. "Is everything okay? You seem flustered."
"Yeah, I'll be fine. I hope anyway. I just don't want to deal with Buff right now."
"I bet." Jerrick put on his jacket and gave me a kiss on the cheek. "For what it's worth, I'm glad you got to be my first."
I attempted a little smile and kissed his lips for a moment. "Wish I could just leave the club. Maybe take you with me somewhere far away." What the fuck was going on with me? I wasn't even ready to date anyone to be this affection and romantic, and I was already wishing to spend romantic time alone with a guy. Even my heart melted around him for the first time.
"Hopefully these four years will go by fast."
"Yeah."
"Well, I'll see you maybe later today?"
"Definitely." I kissed him once more. Suddenly, I didn't want to let him go. I gazed into his grayish-blue "crystals" for eyes that made my heart flutter like I was turning into a damn fool. One thing for sure was that sex had brought us closer, much closer in a short amount of time. But even if I was ready to date, it would've been pointless because of the Peters club. Would Buff still forbid me to fuck anyone else with as jealous and possessive as he was?
Jerrick smiled one last time. "You make me feel nice. And good."
"Yeah?"
"Yeah. I wish things were different. I would've loved to have known what it feels like to have someone special."
His words were too sweet. God, if only.
"Well, I'll see you later."
"Yeah, see you soon, Jerrick."
He gave me one final kiss on the lips, a peck, and he left the SUV.
I smiled a little harder, and my heart flipped with joy until I remembered I had messages to check. I started with Twunky's. I wasn't shocked that he confessed to snatching Buff's phone away from me this morning while I'd been asleep. He apologized with crying emojis and explained that he'd had to do it because he was threatened in a way he'd never been threatened before, and he was terrified, but he didn't go into any details. I imagined it was Buff who'd threatened him. Who else? The message ended with a kiss emoji and a hug one. While I liked him in general and felt like I connected with him and could've possibly dated him as well had I been ready to date, I couldn't trust him. Not right now anyway. It wasn't so much that he was a rat, but he that was in a situation where he couldn't keep everything a secret.
And it sucked.
Then, I read Buff's text. He said I'd been impressively slick enough to hack into his phone and delete last night's evidence. Wow. Since that obviously wasn't true, could Twunky have hacked into Buff's phone and deleted the video? Or maybe he knew someone who was able to if not him?
What a huge relief, though.
Buff continued by stating that he came to a realization after some deep pondering and that he needed to talk to me ASAP now that the other Peters were currently out, that he wouldn't be angry with me if I at least talk to him. What could it be? He still needed to pay for what he'd done. Despite the video being deleted, I wasn't over the whole crazy drama. I didn't think I'd ever be for a long time. Who knew how many others he'd terrorized the past two years? Who knew if the other two Chosen Ones had been terrorized? Now, Buff and I would talk it out and see what would happen. I only hoped that I wasn't fucked all over again.
In fact, I prayed I wasn't.
===*===
To be continued...
===*===
AUTHOR'S NOTE
Thanks for reading. Want more free stories, published books, and the latest news by Marco May? Visit: https://lovelustlit.wordpress.com
Please show your support and help Nifty out by donating whatever you can so that these free stories can continue to stick around for a long time.
Copyright © 2021, Marco May. All Rights Reserved.
DISCLAIMER: All character names/details in this work are fictitious. Any resemblance to real people, living or dead, is entirely coincidental.