Robert stopped the game after I sucked Aaron. Robert said, "I'm hungry, lets go down to town." We all dressed and jumped into the car and headed to town. My guilt had returned. I kept thinking that I should have had more guts. I was more than willing to do anything asked of me. I thought, "I'll have to show more will power when the game re-starts."
After finishing our burgers I was ready to head back to the cabin. Robert surprised me again when he said, "Before we go back I have a few questions to ask each of you. I want you to remember that I am still in charge so you have to tell the truth." He looked at me first and asked, "Did you like the game tonight?"
I looked away from the three faces waiting for my answer and I said, "I have mixed feelings right now. I have had ups and downs this week. I guess to answer your question I would say most of it. I have the same feelings I've had since I started jerking off. You know I was taught that beating my meat was a mortal sin and against God. Well I could not go more than three days without committing a mortal sin. When I was doing it I did not care that I was sinning.
Then after I dropped my load I felt awful. I should have been able to with stand the temptations. But I never could."
"When I saw your hard dick last week I wanted to suck it and I didn't care that it would make me a cocksucker at the time. Tonight when you told me to make out with David it kind of grossed me out. I was ready to suck a dick but I was not ready to kiss my best friend. I guess that sounds a little warped. I did not have any trouble sucking you all off tonight. I even liked the feel, taste and power it gave me making you guys cum. But after we were dressed it was the old MORTAL SIN THING AGAIN. I question that what I am doing is moving me down the queer path. Not to put you down Aaron but I don't want to be gay nor am I ready to come out but I guess I do like sucking dick."
Robert smiled at me and said, "Cool answer." He looked at David, "I want to know whose dick you sucked the first time and did you like the game tonight?" David blushed and he looked over at Robert, "It's a long story so I'll say I was afraid of you being in charge tonight. You are a total pervert and I was unsure what I would do when you asked me to suck your dick. When you kissed me hard tonight on the lips I thought I would be grossed out but my cock immediately hardened. Then when I started making out with James I was on the bone the whole time. When he passed the cum to me I almost shot without being touched. I just didn't think I could do things with another boy."
"I have swallowed more loads of cum than Aaron but all of them were from the same person. I learned when I was about twelve that I could get my own cock in my mouth. I guess it pays to have a longer cock when you are young. After trying it a few times I liked the feel better than jerking. I spit out the load the first few time but then I realized I didn't mind the taste. So I have swallowed my own cum since. I told Aaron that I could do this a couple of years ago and he kept after me until I demonstrated my talents.' I don't care if one or all of us discover we are gay this week. I have always loved you three guys." Robert looked at his brother and he smiled, "Do you have the hots for James?" David looked at me and said, "Maybe." I blushed at this comment.
Robert looked at Aaron, "Who was the first person you sucked and when did you first know you were gay?" Aaron blushed, "I guess you could say that the first dick I had in my mouth was my brother's dick. We were playing a game and I lost and I had to kiss his dick. I kissed the head and then I took it in my mouth. He pushed me away and he told me not do that ever again because it was queer. My brother never mentioned it again to me but he must have told his friend Clay because he started being nice to me. A week or two later he came by and my brother wasn't home. He started talking to me about school and stuff and he asked me if I had really put my brother's cock in my mouth. I told him I had but my brother told me it was queer. He laughed and said my brother was stupid. He said he would have loved for me to suck his dick."
"I thought about it for a few days and I called Clay and I asked him if he would actually let me suck his dick. He said I could any time I wanted as long as my brother never found out. I made a date to meet up with him behind the school the next day. We met at the field next to the school and Clay went behind a few bushes. I followed him and saw that he had his cock outside his zipper. This was the first teen erection I had been near. I was afraid of being caught as I let him enter my mouth. I knew I was a cocksucker when it first entered my mouth. Clay and I repeated these meetings for a few weeks but he would never finish in my mouth. He would pull out each time and spurt his load on the ground. We were almost caught one day by a group of guys and Clay would not come near me again."
"It was two months later before I was able to suck another dick and to taste my first load. You were the first person to feed me your cum, Robert. I had to ask you three of four times to let me suck you before we started fooling around. Tonight was the first time anyone ever went down on me and let me shoot inside them." Robert looked at Aaron and then at me as he said, "No shit."