The usual: If the law says you're too young to be reading this or it's illegal to have it on your screen, go elsewhere. If you don't like man sex, go elsewhere. Author retains rights to this story...
The Rent: Mark Down
So Far: Six friends had cut through the woods and caught Luis Castro going down on Nick Pappos. Five of them wound up getting blown. Five of them gave BJS. Three of them got to fuck some ass. Two even had their asses fucked. All six were freaked out afterwards but Mark especially...
Okay, so what do you need to know about me? I'm Mark Lucas, former star of the JV swim team. I've got very dark eyes and hair, always a mess but it works. I still swim so I'm still built like a swimmer. No dad thanks to a drunk driver but me and mom live with my best friend Jamie Davis and his mom, Noreen. Mom and Noreen weren't friends in high school but being widowed by the same asshole changed that and we started living together cause both of em would have lost the houses without that. Course, Jamie's grandma left him a shit ton of money and just the interest pays for living expenses but it's cool we didn't know that was coming cause living together gave me a best friend I'll have til I die. That's about it of interest.
Oh yeah. One more thing: I'm gay.
Didn't wanna be. Ignored it as long as I could. It started with just sex dreams about Jamie, blond cutie Jamie. Not a jock but he swims with me so he's very much in shape. Got harder to ignore when teammates in the locker room started making me bone up. The asses on Patrick Castle and Keith Yates were a real problem there so I wound up quitting the team.
Keith doesn't know it but he even helped me find out how Mom and Noreen, very religious women, would take me being gay. After we hung out one day I told them I thought Keith might be gay and found out they believed he was going to Hell and I should do anything I could to try to get him to choose being straight. I should have told them it's not a choice but I was too scared they'd figure out my lie and reject me.
So anyway, I decided I'd be like an alcoholic. I'd be gay but I'd never act on it. Heck, I even tried not jacking off anymore. That's made the dreams worse and after one about Jamie, Keith, or Patrick I'd wake up glued to sheets from firing a massive load in my sleep. Still, I was doing pretty good until today and what we saw out in the woods.
I was with Jamie and the other sons of the ladies in Mom's bible study group. We rounded a corner with Willy Cantrell, Shawn Han, James Ortiz, and James Ortiz and there they were. Nick Pappos was being blown by one of the little brothers of our next door neighbor Diego Castro. Hector, I think. Nick had almost no trouble getting us all to join in and it was like I lost control. First I kinda made Jamie blow me and then James and I didn't care whether Jamie was straight or not. I fucked him. Then Nick fucked me and shame or no shame, it was like I was in heaven. I even gave Nick my cell phone number.
Trouble was the guilt only vacationed, it didn't move. I couldn't even look at Jamie the whole way home. I took a quick shower, almost jacked off thinking of how great Nick fucking me was, and then took off again without telling anyone, even taking some money I had stashed away for an emergency in case I couldn't come home tonight. I was going to Hell and probably gonna be kicked out once Jamie told the Moms I raped him so I had no clue what I was doing or where I was going. I just had to get away.
"Lucas!" I look up and find out I've gone over a mile `cause I'm in front of Keith's house. He's in his driveway shooting baskets alone and looks so fine in just his running shorts. I've stayed friends with him after quitting the team and the sight of that hot body and his smile on seeing me almost has me chubbing up again.
I can't think of any good excuse not to go over and it's not hard for Keith to get me to play some one on one with him. Well, something's hard...
"Where is everybody?" Keith's third of five kids and his uncle lives with them but there's no one in sight when we go inside.
"Twins are looking at some college with Dad and Mom and Uncle Ray took Freddie and Gail to see the Canyon." We down some Gatorade and Keith says he has some killer weed upstairs. "Matt and Ricky were gonna hang out all day but Ricky was on the phone with the Griffin twins and they made it sound like they'd put out so..." I laugh. Keith, Matt, and Ricky are all so desperate to get laid I wouldn't be surprised if the other guys didn't even bother saying bye to Keith once the twins made their offer.
Keith opens his window and lights some incense in the twins room. Smart. Mr. and Mrs. Yates are probably too clueless to smell the pot or know what it is but if they do they'll assume it's Dixon or Shane smoking out. We do talk some at first but the weed starts me thinking about the fun in the woods and the disaster it's gonna cause. Ever been depressed and horny at the same time? Sucks.
"Mark, what's wrong? You look just like you did when you told the coach you were quitting the team." If only Keith knew how much his own ass made my decision to quit! The way he's sitting on his bed, him on his stomach on one side, I can see it clearly outlined by his shorts from where I'm sitting at his computer. Horny starts winning over depressed.
And I tell him a very edited version of what happened in the woods. I don't tell him about feeling gay before but I do tell him about spit roasting Jamie with James and then Jamie and Nick tag teaming me. He doesn't say anything at first.
"So you're gay." I don't know. It's true but to hear it said like that by Keith bugs me.
"No." Keith smirks. "We're teenagers. Seeing two dogs fuck give you a woody." Keith snickered.
"But I wouldn't fuck a dog." Keith can see I'm bothered. "It's okay if you're gay. We'll still be friends just like this."
"But having guy sex doesn't make you gay." One eyebrow goes up. "We have the same bodies and doing the same thing to a straight guy and a gay guy would feel just as good. Gay is thinking guys are hot and going after it. You'd still be straight if you just went along with it and didn't start scoping out guys after."
"I don't know..."
"Fifty bucks says I can work you up enough where gay or straight won't matter. Then you'll understand." Keith's family is kinda broke so I know the money sounds good and he is convinced he's right, that a straight guy couldn't do any of the stuff I told him about. I take that emergency money out, peel off fifty, and toss it on his night stand. Keith looks at it like I do at his ass so I know I've got him. I also know virgin Keith wants real bad to make a sex tape once he gets his cherry popped and has things ready to go in this room. While Keith's thinking I start up the system and then head to send it to my iPad. Keith's sent me some webcam stuff before so it's easy to rig it to send. I turn back to him and climb on to the bed with a great big smile on my face. "So you get the fifty bucks if a straight guy can't be turned on so much by a guy he stops caring it's a guy. Deal?"
"Deal. What do we do?" He turns over and reaches out to stub out the joint. Keith is getting shy all of a sudden, realizing he's nearly naked with a guy he now knows is gay. I reach over and take one of his very big nipples between my fingers and start playing. Keith tenses at first like he wants to throw me off his bed but forces himself to relax.
"How's that feel?" I get a duh look but I knew this wouldn't be enough, so even before he can follow the look with any words, I lean over and take Keith's other nipple in my mouth and start sucking and nibbling. Before he can say anything though I lean and take Keith's other nipple between my lips and start nibbling and suckling. His moan tells me Keith finds this a lot more hot than fingers. Looking up in Keith's eyes there's the fear that he's going to lose the bet or maybe it's just fear we'll have sex. There's also the start of horniness in Keith's eyes so if I act quick enough...
While still taste testing Keith's nipples, one then the other and back again, one arm goes around his body. That way Keith can't jump back when the other hand goes to his crotch. Good call, by the way. The second I grasp his mostly hard dick through jock strap and running shorts, Keith does try to pull away. Not for long though. Mister Hand gets Keith all the way hard and starts jacking him through the cloth and Keith isn't going anywhere.
I lean in and kiss him. Keith looks scared as I near but he doesn't try to move. Held in place, his mouth opens after a moment and we start Frenching, with Keith pretty quickly kissing back. After a minute, I pull back but my hand slips into the shorts and he gasps when bare hand meets bare cock. Keith's breathing is ragged as all get out.
"So, a straight guy can't get turned on by a gay guy?" Keith swallows hard.
"So you are gay?"
"Yup. Bet you're glad I am right this second. Want me to keep going?" Keith shakes his head yes but that's not good enough. "You gotta say it, Keithy. Do you want me to keep it up?" I swear Keith stops breathing for a second and maybe, just maybe he's gonna find the willpower to say no.
"Oh god yes, don't stop!" That's all I needed to hear. I maneuver him so he's flat on his back and practically rip jock and shorts off of him. His dick looks as nice as it feels, about average length but he's thick. I lick my lips. This is a big moment, the first dick I choose to suck. I wanted Jamie for so long but Nick didn't care or know. I'm glad Jamie was my first all around but Keith is a pretty big first too. As my lips seal around his precum wet head and start sliding down I decide I'm not feeling too guilty about being gay anymore. Not if it means I get to blow guys like Jamie and Keith. Doesn't even matter that they're probably straight. That gets me hotter and Keith sure appreciates me getting hotter. I suck harder and bob faster, my hands roaming all over his chest in between getting myself naked from the waist down.
I start feeling up Keith's ass too, that beautiful ass that I'm betting even a straight guy would have trouble not drooling over. I get to thinking about the stories online, the ones about rimming. I always pictured Keith and Pat whenever I saw myself trying it. Patrick will have to be a project to work on but here's my chance with Keith.
Keith grunts a question when I stop sucking and lift his ass up. He doesn't get a chance to form words before my mouth goes in for the kill on that pretty pink spot between his cheeks. Keith's delighted cry tells me he likes this a lot. He sure is louder as I start invading him with my tongue than he was when I was polishing his knob! I try a finger too just too see how Keith likes it and it sounds like he likes it a lot. I start sucking his balls while one finger and then two starts fucking his hole and then I lick my way up and down his shaft while two then three fingers start driving Keith nuts.
When I stop finger fucking Keith and sucking on his cock and crawl between his legs, Keith goes all nervous. He knows what's coming. Keith sees my dick for the first time, almost as thick as his but maybe an inch longer. Again with the swallowing hard but Keith is too far gone in sex thinking to stop me. I grab his legs under the knees and lift and separate. Keith bites his lip when my dickhead hits his very wet hole and just as it looks like he's finally decided to stop me, I slide I n about an inch. Keith's head goes back like he was hit and I can't tell if it's pleasure or pain. I don't know if I care. I sink in about halfway and pull out to the head and repeat. And repeat. And get deeper. Soon I'm all the way in on every in stroke and going faster and harder.
And you know what? Keith loved it! His dick got stiffer and started leaking precum like a faucet. He raised himself back up on his elbows and finally found his voice again.
"Oh shit, Mark, this is good. Oh fuck!" I pick up speed again. "Oh yeah, fuck me harder, Mark! Fuck my brains out!" Keith cums like a firehose right then and I think it surprised him too. His first shot covered his face and the next eight or nine coated that very hot chest and stomach. Even if his ass wasn't the second hottest I'd ever fucked, just seeing him shoot off like that and the look of sheer delight on his face would have had me losing control and blasting my own load in him. We kiss again as we try to breathe and I was still hard and thinking of fucking him again when we heard them.
"Looks like you both won that bet." We look over and see Matt and Ricky are back, Matt with his own iPad in hand and it looks familiar what's playing. "Yeah, Keith, we know about the bet," Matt says. Matt's a tall redhead who usually looks amused by everything around him. Now he just looks turned on as hell. He shucks his shirt to show off an upper body years of swimming gives you and drops the iPad to the dresser so he can start getting his pants off. Matt definitely has a man sized dick on him for a sixteen year old and it is very, very hard.
"Dumbass recorded it with your set up, Keith," finishes Ricky, his average sized uncut and also quite hard cock already sticking out from his open jeans. It looks like you could hang clothes from it. "He hit my address too and we've been watching all of this coming back from being teased by the Griffins. Looks like we're gonna get laid after all." Ricky strips quick and he's as defined as we are but with hair already coming in on his chest. His shoulder length very dark hair just makes h im look sexier.
"I don't know..." Keith manages, not able to look either of our friends in the eye, focusing only on their up and ready dicks.
"What's not to know, Keith. Didn't what we just did feel ten kinds of awesome?" I can see Keith wants to deny it but he can't get the lie out. "Look at Matt there. If I felt good, imagine how great a bigger one's gonna be!" It's clear Keith isn't going to argue now so I move to stop Matt just jumping on the bed and humping away.
"Uh uh, Matt. I had to work for it. You do too." Matt doesn't get it. "Due, if you want to stick it, you gotta lick it," stealing Nick's line while I grab Keith's still half hard dick.
"But that's..." I know he was going to say gay but since fucking Keith's brains out is too it's not an argument that Matt'd win. With a heavy sigh Matt gives up and replaces my hand on Keith's dick and slowly lowers his face t o it. Matt pauses and I can't be the only one here to think he's changed his mind but then Matt just closes his eyes and starts sucking. Matt isn't bad for a straight first-timer either. It's like Matt decides it's not as bad as he feared and he goes to town. Keith is soon fully hard again and Matt even manages to deep throat his first time out. It clearly gets him more worked up and it's time for the main event. This time Keith moves with who's about to fuck him and between them, Matt is buried balls deep in barely two thrusts.
"So I guess you're mine," gloats Ricky but he's an asshole. There's no way this is gonna be about him using me.
"Nope, Ricky. Same rules." I pull him into a kiss before he can back away and fight to keep him in it until reflex and horniness takes over and Ricky is kissing back with as much gusto as I am. I pull Ricky to the floor and start jacking his cock while aiming my own hard cock for his mouth. Ricky resists again but as soon as I start sucking he opens wide and in goes my dick. Ricky's not the natural Matt turned out to be but he makes up in effort what he lacks in technique.
Keeping a slow fuck in his mouth, I come off of Ricky's dick and go for his hole. Ricky doesn't disappoint. Keith took to it quicker but Ricky is soon grooving on tongue and fingers up hi m just as much as Keith did. With him though I have to move quicker. Before it even registers to Ricky I've switched so that we're face to face, my dick is parting its third virgin hole of the day. Ricky fights a little but gives in before I'm even halfway in him. Ricky goes from putting up a fight to initiating our second kiss even as I start a shallow in and out. Ricky is a bigger surprise here than Keith was!
"I play with my ass sometimes when I jack off butt his feels so much better!" From the way Ricky gave up and gave in that little play has got to be with toys! Well, if he likes plastic up there, he'll love the real thing so I start giving it to him good. Ricky doesn't complain, instead his legs scissoring around my middle and his heels dig in as if he could get my dick even deeper up him.
Over on the bed, Keith is giving Matt the first fuck of a lifetime. Keith didn't just lay there and take it with me but dude is going nuts on Matt's bigger dick. They've shifted around so Matt is on his back and Keith is riding Matt's dick like a crazed yo yo! Not that Ricky's gone all passive either. That man sized shaft is getting humped up as hard as Keith is coming down and Matt's hands are all over Keith's chest. Matt's even sucking on Keith's fingers and that gets me thinking of how to make things hotter. For me at least.
"Get on your knees, Ricky. It can go deeper that way." Matt practically coos as he spins into position while I catch Keith's eye and point towards Ricky's waiting ass with a question on my face. Keith's answer is yes, to Matt's regret. He climbs off Matt and heads right for Ricky. You wouldn't know Keith came about fifteen minutes ago from how angry hard his cock is.
"Keith? I don't know, man." Keith is having none of that.
"So it's cool you come to my house after ditching me and planning on fucking my ass but I can't be the second one to fuck you? Fuck that!" Despite his words Ricky hasn't moved at all. "And fuck you," Keith finishes as he rams his cock all the way to the base in Ricky's waiting hole. Does Ricky complain? Nope. He just groans the most satisfied groan I've ever heard as Keith proceeds to lay a harder fuck on him than I was giving. Matt meanwhile is still up on the bed, acting all butt hurt that he's lost his hole to fuck. A good friend would find him another.
"He's got another end..." Matt is off that bed like a shot and that nice looking, very VERY hard dick is like a rocket towards his best buddy's mouth. I think Ricky was gonna say Dude, that shit's nasty where it's been' or something like that. All he gets out is Dude, that sh-' before that dick is in his open mouth. Matt starts humping right away so what choice does Ricky have but to suck. God, they look great. I have some doubts now about Ricky but still, this is three of my straight ex-teammates and two of them are spit roasting the third! Keith's face looks almost angry as he fucks Ricky so hard it sounds like he's slapping his ass. Ricky is holding on to Matt's ass cheeks for dear life and doing better than he did on me when it comes to swallowing Matt's dick. Time for me to get in on this!
"Any love for the guy who made this all possible?" I ask Matt right after I straddle sweaty, moaning Ricky. Matt gives a wicked grin and bends over and just starts sucking me off! I was right too. Matt is much better than Ricky at blowjobs and in no time he's swallowing a gallon if jizz I start shooting out of nowhere. Ricky's choking sounds are timed so it seems me erupting got Matt shooting too. Spent, we collapse on the bed and watch the show's end.
"Oh god. Here. It. COMES!" Keith starts ramming so hard and grimaces like he's in pain but there has to be his second load getting dumped up Ricky who gets the most amazing O face as Keith literally fucks the cum right out of him. Every time a cumming Keith bottoms out in Ricky another powerful jet of cum flies from Ricky's dick, all without Ricky ever once touching his dick. When they finish, Keith and Ricky collapse in a heap and you'd almost swear they'd fucked themselves to death. Keith finally climbs up off his friend but Ricky stays where he is with his face turned away from them as Keith joins me and Matt on the bed. It's just a twin so there's a lot of skin on skin contact but after what we all just got done doing it's not awkward. We finally notice Ricky hasn't moved after a few minutes.
"What's wrong, Ricky?" There's a muffled, mumbled answer none of use hears. Matt rolls his eyes. Ricky is a bit of a drama queen. Keith asks again and this time we hear Ricky.
"I don't want to be gay." He sounds so sad I can't resist a little laugh. Matt smacks me on the back of the head but he's grinning too.
"So you suddenly think we're fucking hot? The Griffin girls don't stand a chance?" Ricky rises up on his elbows, blowing some stray hairs that are in his face out of the way and grimaces.
"Ugh. Beth said they might still call. I think I have dibs on Beth. Or maybe it's Iris. Which one's sluttier?" Now it's safe to laugh.
"Dude, we're not gay. We've had circle jerks and remember when me and Patrick walked in you using your sister's vibrator on yourself," Ricky blushes and looks away when Matt mentions that. I think I'm gonna be calling him soon. "and you gave us a million reasons why that didn't make you gay. Remember them, okay? Just do it while I shower. I stink." Matt gets up and pads off to Keith's shower and his ass looks fine. Yeah, I'll be calling him too. Ricky finally gets up and says he'll wash up using the sink while Matt showers. Right. Keith stays stretched out naked on his bed while I dress.
"You do know I'm keeping that fifty cause you accidentally' sent that streaming video to them, right?." I laugh and flip him off on the way out the door. I'm halfway home when I get his first text. Next time I'm fucking you' is what I said. The next one shows up just as I get home. Don't worry about Jamie. If you were half as good with him, I bet he wants you to fuck him again too'. Sweet. I went out to clear my head and made three fuck buddies. The last text is a picture one and it turns out I was right about Ricky's intentions: Keith snapped a picture of Ricky bent over the sink while Matt got his turn fucking him.
The scene I walk into going in the back door is hotter than the one Keith texted me. Tall, dark John is sprawled out on our kitchen table and shorter, very pale Willy is ramming a very red hardon in and out of John's ass.
"Ew. You're doing it at my place." John is startled to hear me but Willy just grins and starts fucking John harder. I tweak on of John's nipples as I go by and head upstairs to shower. Doesn't seem right to apologize to Jamie while smelling like three other guys. It's just instead of Jamie in his room, I find James on all fours on Jamie's bed and Shawn is behind him, eating his ass. Turns out seeing someone get rimmed is as much of a turn on for me as doing it. I drop the towel pretty much as soon as James notices me there and he licks his lips at the sight of my hard cock. It's four steps to the bed and my dick is sliding between James' lips pretty much at the same time that Shawn's dick enters James' ass. Honest? I've never really gotten along with Shawn but there's something about doing a guy at the same time. While James finally manages to get all of me down his throat, Shawn and me start making out. When one of James' fingers pushes up my ass that's it for me and load number four of the day is shooting in his mouth.
Shawn's nowhere near done but I watch for a minute or so. They've just switched so they're on their side, Shawn lifting one of James' legs so he can ram harder in him. James' looks so lost in pleasure it's like he's forgotten I'm there. My cue to go throw on some shorts and find Jamie. I think it was just the guys from our little woodsy fun that were supposed to be so Jamie should be alone. Looking out my window I see I'm right, even that Jamie would be in his favorite thinking spot on the porch right below my room. I'm sorta glad John and Willy have moved elsewhere when I get Pepsis from the fridge. I guess John is hot and I figured out months ago he was gay too but he's never done anything for me.
I'm nervous when I head out the front door. What if Jamie hates me? What if he hates what I did so much that's why he's not inside having fun like the others are? I'm about to tell him it's me when Jamie proves he knows the sound of me walking just as good as I know the sound of him.
"How long you been home?" I laugh. Okay, the tone is cool. No hate there.
"About five minutes after Willy started fucking John on our kitchen table and right before Shawn started boning James in your bed." Jamie turns around and that's it. We're cool. This is just like a million other times we've sat out here and shot the shit.
"So who blew you?" Jamie really does know me best.
"James. Sucks pretty well for a straight kid." We laugh. "Jamie, I am sorry about the woods. I don't know what I was thinking, making you do that shit like that. I deserved what Nick did."
"You liked what Nick did. You're gay, right?" No surprise him figuring that out. The only surprise was Jamie didn't figure it out before now. I guess making him blow me and then fucking him followed up by loving him and Nick share me were the final clues he needed.
"I was trying not to be but yeah. I figured I could treat it like your uncle Joe with his alcoholism but honestly? I've wanted you so bad for so long. So much for never doing it. The three times today were too good not to do it ever again." I'll tell Jamie about Keith, Matt, and Ricky later but that's just unimportant now. This is me and my best friend stuff. "I'll tell you later. So you out there and teen boy orgy in there. I guess you're straight." It's his turn to laugh.
"Nah, I'm pretty sure I'm bi. Today hasn't turned me off of still going after Debs but you only saw teen boy orgy the sequel. James fucked me for part one and wow, was it good." It feels so good to know I didn't lose t he best friend I will ever have and we just kinda enjoy sitting there quietly for a bit. "So you wanna..."
"Oh god yeah, just not here. I think if we start doing it at home we'll never do anything else and I'm nowhere near wanting the Moms to find out." I'm glad Jamie doesn't object. No sense rushing into whatever reaction the Moms are going to have.
"Well, grandma's house is gonna be empty soon, what with the last tenant moving out. All we gotta do is find a new person to live there who's cool with us or the guys using part of it for getting it on and we'll have it made." Then we just talk like we always do, about everything and nothing. James and Shawn come down first and then John and Willy and it's just a group of friends, not teen horn dogs who've just realized they can all have sex with each other. If this is what it's going to feel like to be full out gay, which it turns out Shawn and Willy are too just like me and John, then I'm sorry I resisted it so long!