This story contains gay sex between consenting adults. If this story offends you or it is illegal for you, please leave this site.
Remember Nifty relies and survives on generosity of people like you for donations. Please be generous.
Valentine's Day dinner and dessert were finished and I had cleared the table. Blake, my husband, rested on the sofa after a grueling day at work. After 15 years, Valentine's Day was really just another day for us, especially when we both had to work. This year though, I had decided to make it extra special...and spicy. I started the dishwasher and fluffed up the flowers he had brought me and made my way into the living room.
Blake was laid back on the sofa, flipping through the coffee table book on Greek gods that I had given him. He had always had a fascination with Greek and Roman myths and I knew the book was something he would love. I sat down and put his feet on my lap and began to massage them.
"Oh, babe, you don't know how great that feels", he sighed. He ran a restaurant and was on his feet for hours at a time.
"Do you like the book?", I asked. It really was a nice book, even if not the most romantic gift. It was hard-bound and edged with gold leaf and quite thick.
"I love it", he said. He flipped it around to show me a depiction of Zeus. The illustrator had done a fine job. The attention to detail was amazing for a drawing.
"Turn to the chapter on Cupid", I said, as I continued to work his feet over. My stomach fluttered a bit. Here we go.
He flipped through the book until he reached the right chapter. On the left side, a full-page drawing of Eros, or Cupid, the Greek god, was printed. On the right, a single sheet a paper was taped to the page. It read:
"Blake, the last 15 years have been amazing. You are the love of my life and I would give you the world if I could. Tonight, on our 15th Valentine's Day, let's find our own Eros and fulfill a fantasy we've both had for a long time. I love you."
Blake read the note and looked up at me, mouth agape.
"Does this mean what I think it means?", he asked. I nodded.
"Why don't we go shower and see what kind of Greek god we can find".
He grinned and closed the book. He grabbed me and kissed me hard before pulling me to my feet and dragging me upstairs. Valentine's night had begun.
"Geez, he's hot", Blake whispered. The glow of the phone lit his face and I could see his eyes taking in the photo on the screen. We were laying on the bed, looking at the guys that were within a 10 miles radius on one of the popular apps. We had showered and gotten ready and now we were scoping out the dudes, seeing who we might find.
The guy on the screen was gorgeous, the epitome of a Greek god. Dark hair with a brooding smile, thick lips and a scruffy face. His shirtless pic showed a toned and tanned body. His stats listed him as 26 years old, 6'1, 175lbs. He was a versatile top and his profile said he was DTF. And he was only 2 miles away.
"Yea?", I asked. "Want me to message him?"
Blake grabbed his dick through his shorts and nodded, while still staring at the picture. I quickly shot off a message to the guy on the screen telling him that we were a married couple, 42 and 38, looking for our first threesome. We were both down to suck his dick, I'd eat his ass and my husband would get fucked while I watched and played with both. Within a couple of minutes, he responded.
LOOKING4NOW: "Sounds hot. Pics?"
I looked at Blake. "What do you want to send him? Just dick pics?" We were weary of sending face pics. We were private guys and didn't want anyone we knew finding out about what we were up to. Blake agreed with the dick pics and pulled his out while I did the same. I snapped a couple of photos for the guy and sent them. While waiting, I told Blake to turn over and I'd take a pic of his ass too. He had such a beautiful ass, I knew if the guy saw it, he would be down. I snapped that photo as well and sent it off. Like I figured, it didn't take long for him to get back to us.
LOOKING4NOW: "Wow! Send me an address and I'm OMW. Can be there in 10 min. Got condoms or should I bring some?"
I turned to Blake. "Are we sure we want to do this? It sounds fun and all and I want us both to have a good time. I just want to make sure we are ready."
"I'm nervous but you know I've always wanted to try a threesome", he said.
I glanced down at his shorts and seeing his rock-hard dick, I reached down and squeezed it. "Ok. I'll send him the address. We can always kick him out if we get a bad vibe."
I sent the guy our address and put the phone down. Now, we waited. Would he show up? Would he look like he did in the pics? You never knew until the person was standing right in front of you. Catfishes were everywhere these days and I wanted this Valentine's Day to be perfect. I grabbed Blake and pulled him over to me and kissed him deeply. I hoped this experience would be great and a lot of fun. We were heavily making out and rubbing each other when the doorbell rang. Showtime.
I gave Blake one more kiss and got out of bed. I was wearing a tee shirt and a jock strap but nothing else. Blake lay back on the bed as I hurried out of the room and down the stairs. Man, I hoped this dude wasn't catfishing us! Reaching the front door, I took a deep breath and opened it.
The guy standing on the other side was as hot as he was in the photos. Even hotter. The photo on his profile could have been taken that same day. He had the same scruffy face and he gave me a smile as I invited him inside.
"Hey, man", he said. "I'm Apollo."
"I'm Adam and my husband Blake is upstairs." I shut the door and nodded to the stairway. "Look, like I said, this is our first time. So, we are nervous and not sure what to expect. If something seems off or the vibe isn't right, we don't want any drama or anything."
"Hey, I get it", Apollo said. "I've done a few threesomes and I just want everyone to have a good time. You want me to get undressed here or upstairs?" He was already kicking his shoes off.
"You can leave your shoes here, but wait to take everything off upstairs. I'm sure Blake will want to watch that." I was already at ease with this guy. He seemed genuine. I turned and started going up the stairs, Apollo right behind me. About half way up, he smacked my ass cheek and I giggled. I had a feeling this was going to turn out well.
When we entered the bedroom, Blake had moved to the middle of the bed. He was still wearing his shorts but had thrown the blankets back and propped himself up on some pillows. The room was mostly dark, the only light coming from a small lamp near the bed. I saw Blake had also pulled lube and condoms out of the drawer and set them on top of the bedside table. He had a fantasy about being barebacked, but that wasn't something we were comfortable with, not knowing this guy. We had a variety of condoms, hoping that the largest size would be needed.
Apollo introduced himself and started stripping while I got on the bed beside Blake. First the tee shirt came off and we were treated to the sight of his fantastic torso. Smooth, with very little hair. Small nipples on well-developed pics. He quickly unbuttoned and dropped his shorts and we saw that he was going commando. Holy shit. His cock was already getting hard and it was a beauty. It was about 8 inches long and about the size and shape of a cucumber. Cut and tanned like the rest of his body. Once he stepped out of his shorts, Apollo swished his hips, making his cock swing and grinned.
"Will this work for you boys?", he asked. He put his hands on his hips and did a slow turn, showing off his ass. I was practically drooling looking at him. I looked down at Blake's shorts and saw a huge wet spot. Apparently, he liked what he saw as well.
"Fuck, yes!", Blake and I responded at the same time. All three of us chuckled. I told Blake to move to the side of the bed, leaving the spot in between us open.
"Get in the middle of us", I said to Apollo. "We can both play with you that way."
He crawled over Blake, his cock rubbing against Blake's chest on the way to the middle of the bed. He flipped over on his back and rested in Blake's previous spot, arms stretched out, legs slightly open and cock laying straight up against his belly button. I looked at Blake and smiled. He smiled back and blew me a little kiss then got up on his knees and leaned over, grabbing Apollo's cock.
It was so hot watching my husband lightly palm Apollo's dick. He jerked it up and down a few times, slowly milking it. Apollo seemed content to just watch, for now. Blake leaned down and licked the head of the cock, and moaned. It had been over a decade since he had tasted another man's cock and I'm sure he was loving it. He quickly sucked the head into his mouth and started nursing on it.
"That's right, baby," Apollo said, "suck that cock. Suck on my dick." Blake groaned and took more of it into his mouth. I watched, extremely turned on. My own dick was leaking precum through my jock, and I was almost afraid I would blow before we had even begun.
I got up on my knees in the same position as Blake and started rubbing Apollo's balls. They were smooth and heavy and full. I hoped he would blow a huge load. Blake popped off Apollo's cock and pushed it towards me, offering me a taste. I sucked it into my mouth, tasting Blake's saliva and the distinct taste of cock. It made my dick even harder somehow. I bobbed up and down on the cock, trying to force as much as I could down my throat. It was simply too big. I choked and had to come up for air. Instead of trying again, I moved down and started licking Apollo's balls while Blake went back to feasting on his cock.
"Oh yea!", Apollo moaned. "Lick my balls while your husband sucks my cock!" I let out a groan and lapped at his balls some more. I sucked one into my mouth carefully before letting it drop out and going for the other one. His sack was becoming soaked and loose from the licking and sucking. I was in heaven.
While licking Apollo's balls, I heard Blake moan and I glanced up and saw Apollo had put his hand down the back of Blake's shorts and was playing with his ass. I felt Apollo twist his body and reach under Blake, unbuttoning his shorts and trying to slide them off. Blake stopped sucking for a minute and pushed his shorts off onto the floor and then dove back onto Apollo's dick. Without the shorts on, his ass was able to spread out, giving Apollo access to his hole.
Still lapping at his balls, I saw Apollo lick his fingers and reach back to Blake's ass, rubbing his spit onto the hole. Blake moaned around Apollo's dick and pushed his ass back.
"Oh, you like that?", Apollo asked. "You want me to put something in that tight ass?"
Blake moaned in the affirmative and pushed his ass back against Apollo's fingers.
"Soon", Apollo said. "But for now, keep sucking that dick." He looked down at me sucking his balls. "You want some of my ass?", he asked me. I stopped licking his balls.
"Fuuuck yes!", I breathed out. "Let me eat your asshole!"
Apollo spread his legs open some more and raised them up into the air. I grabbed a pillow and slid it under him, propping his ass up so he was more comfortable. I got a good look at his hole. He was either naturally smooth or he shaved because there was no hair anywhere near his ass. His hole was peach colored and looked tight. I couldn't wait to dig in. I leaned down and pulled his balls up out of my way and starting licking all around his hole and taint.
"Oh, fuck man!", Apollo moaned. "I love when dudes eat my ass! Fucking suck on that hole, man!"
I did just that. I used my fingers to spread his cheeks as wide as I could then placed my mouth over his hole and latched on. I started sucking it and tongue fucking it like I was starving. Like I thought, his hole was very tight and I could barely get my tongue in it. I sucked and sucked and tried to wiggle my tongue in, but made little headway. I could feel his balls laying against my nose as I sucked on his hole. Finally, it relaxed just enough for me to get the end of my tongue in and I started making out with it.
"God, yes!", Apollo sighed. "One dude sucking on my hole while I feed his husband my precum. Fuck that's hot! You boys keep that shit up and I'm gonna cum!"
I definitely didn't want that to happen yet. Reluctantly, I pulled my face out of his ass.
"Don't cum yet, not before you fuck Blake! Blake, are you ready? What do you want?"
Blake pulled off Apollo's cock but kept jerking it, slowly. "I want this inside me", he said. "I want to back up on this thing!" He shook Apollo's dick.
"Alright!", Apollo said. "Let me strap up while you get ready." He turned to me while he moved off the pillow. "Do you want to watch me fuck him or...", he trailed off.
"I'll watch at first. Then I'm going to try something else", I replied.
"Cool, cool", Apollo said. He grabbed the lube and condoms from the side table. I was glad that we had bought the large size. He was definitely going to need it. While he put the condom on, Blake got in the middle of the bed on his hands and knees. I leaned towards his face so we could talk.
"You having fun?", I whispered. I ran my hand down his back to his ass and used my finger to tap his hole.
"Yeees", he whispered back. "I'm so horny!"
I laughed quietly. "I bet. He has a nice cock. I'm sure you are going to love it." I kissed his cheek and pulled away. Apollo had finished putting on the condom and was positioning himself behind Blake. He was tall enough that his cock naturally lined up pretty even with Blake's hole. I laid down on the side of the bed so I could watch and lazily play with my dick. I was still wearing my jockstrap and it was soaked with precum. I rubbed my dick a little but was already on the verge of cumming so I stopped.
Apollo squeezed some lube onto his fingers and then added more to Blake's hole. Blake had his head down on a pillow, arms at his sides, laying on the bed. He made a groaning noise as Apollo rubbed his asshole and stretched it out for fucking.
"You have a tight ass, Blake", Apollo said. "You must not get fucked a lot."
"Only dildos", Blake groaned out. "I need to be fucked."
Apollo chuckled. "Don't worry about that. I'm going to fuck the shit out of you!" He leaned forward and placed his cockhead up against Blake's hole. "You said you wanted to back up on it, so go ahead."
Blake started pushing his ass back onto the cock and I watched as his hole tried to open to accommodate Apollo's thickness. The head wasn't even in and Blake was moaning like I had never heard before.
"It's so big!", he cried. "Push it in a little bit!" He reached back and grabbed his own asscheeks and spread them open.
Apollo was steadily holding his cock, keeping it in place. I saw him push forward a little and the head popped into Blake's ass.
"Oh! Oh! Oh!" Blake moaned. "It fucking hurts but don't stop!"
"I'm not stopping until I've fucked all the cum out of you!", Apollo said. "Keep pushing back on this dick!"
I was mesmerized watching Blake take this hung cock. He hadn't had one inside him for years and I knew he would fight through the pain to get to the pleasure that this dick could bring him. He kept his asscheeks spread and pushed back more, taking about half of the cock up his ass. He let out a steady stream of gibberish, lost in the feelings.
Apollo flexed his hips again and drove another couple of inches inside the hole. There were still a couple of inches to go. Instead of just pushing them him, he reached down and grabbed Blake's hands and pulled them off his ass. He then pulled Blake back by the arms, sliding him down onto the rest of the dick until every inch was inside.
"Holy SHIT!", Blake roared. "Goddamn, it's so DEEP! Give me a minute!"
Apollo kept himself in place, not moving another inch. "You let me know when you are ready", he said.
I lay back, watching the entire thing. They were so caught up in their fuck that they probably forgot I was there. I was happy to lay back and watch it all unfold...for the moment.
"Ok, go slow!", Blake breathed out.
Apollo pulled back a few inches and slid back in, testing the waters. He still had Blake's hands in his, holding them behind Blake's back while he thrust slowly in and out.
"It's good, it's good", Blake groaned. "You can go faster. And harder."
Apollo flexed his hips back, pulling his cock almost all of the way out of Blake's hole. "You got it, man", he said, and slammed back in.
"Ugh Ugh Ugh Ugh!" That's all that was coming out of Blake's mouth. I don't think he could even form words. Apollo thrust in and out of him, fucking his ass like a seasoned pro. He let go of Blake's hands and grabbed onto his bubble ass, pulling it towards him, then away. Every time he pulled Blake's ass towards himself, he squeezed the cheeks together, so that his cock rubbed up against the length of Blake's ass trench. He fucked like a man possessed. His cock slammed in and out of Blake's hole, hitting spots inside that hadn't been touched in years by a real dick.
Blake put his hands on the mattress and pushed himself up, giving himself more leverage to slam back against Apollo's cock. He turned his head and looked at me. His eyes were glazed over and there was literal drool hanging from his mouth.
"I'm gonna cum soon!", he uttered. "I can't stop it!" He shoved back against Apollo's cock. "It's..ugh...too good!" That was my cue.
I slid over so that I was laying directly beside them. I had just enough room to slide under Blake so that his leaking cock was level with my mouth. Looking up, I could see Apollo's cock pummeling Blake's hole. I saw his balls slapping against Blake's ass. I latched on to Blake's dick and started sucking it. I wanted all of his load down my throat. As soon as I latched on, Blake went crazy.
"Oh fuck, oh fuck fuck fuck!", he screamed. "I'm gonna CUM I'M GONNA CUM!"
Apollo started groaning and fucked harder and faster before pulling all the way out and ripping off the condom. He pointed his cock at Blake's hole and started shooting all over it.
"OHH SHIT!", he yelled. "I'm CUMMING on your asshole!"
Blake started screeching. "Put it back in! Fuck your cum into my hole!"
I felt Blake's cock swell and then it exploded in my mouth. What felt like a gallon of cum shot down my throat. I couldn't swallow it all and it started running out of my mouth and down the side of my face. His cock kept shooting as he continued to slam his ass back onto Apollo's bare cock.
It was all too much for me. Without ever touching myself, I exploded in my jock. If I didn't have a mouth full of cock, I would have screamed. I may have blacked out for a second. I came so hard that it sort of hurt. Cum was pouring out of the jock pouch. I writhed on the bed as I finished cumming and let Blake's cock fall from my mouth. I moved from under him and caught my breath. I looked back and saw Apollo sliding his softening cock out of Blake's hole. Cum was everywhere. All over me, my face, the bed. Cum dripped off Blake's ass. Apollo's cock was shiny with it.
"Goddamn", I said, trying to breath. "I've never cum that hard in my life!"
Blake laid down on his stomach, exhausted.
We all three lay there for a few minutes, trying to come down from the incredible experience. It had definitely been better than I could have imagined. I hoped Blake had had a great time too. Looking at him, I think he did. He looked completely satisfied.
After a few minutes of rest, I hoped up and said I was going to shower. I offered Apollo the use of the other bathroom.
"I'm going to lay here another couple of minutes and catch my breath", he said.
I left the room and headed to my shower. I was tired but I wanted to wash some of the sweat off. I quickly showered and threw on some pajama pants and a tee shirt and made my way back to the bedroom.
Stepping back inside, I saw Blake still laying in the middle of the bed, on his stomach. His hands were on his ass, spreading it open while Apollo sucked and ate his cummy hole. Hearing me come in, Apollo stopped eating and turned to look at me.
"Ready for round two?", he asked and turned back to Blake's ass. I shut the bedroom door and walked to the bed, watching this Greek god eat my husband's butt. I couldn't wait to see what the rest of Valentine's Night brought.